Condition
BGB 1896: die dreißigjährige Frist ist nicht vollendet
Jurisdiction DeutschlandLaw as of 1900-01-01
Calculation result
Refuted
Input parameters
What we are finding
Verjährung vollendet
c4
Input facts
the debtor bound himself toward the creditor by the contract underlying the claim
creditor: g4debitor: s4causa: c4the claimant brings a claim against the defendant — the contested relation the question is about
causa: c4actor: g4reus: s4the claim arose (the right of action opened) that many full years before the day of the dispute; the term is given as a duration, not a date, so one case can be read at any date of the link's law
causa: c4anni: 4
Original data · JSON
{
"args": [
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
],
"facts": [
{
"args": [
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:g4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:s4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
],
"negated": false,
"origin": "case_input",
"predicate": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#contractus"
},
{
"args": [
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:g4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:s4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
],
"negated": false,
"origin": "case_input",
"predicate": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#petitio"
},
{
"args": [
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"kind": "value",
"type": {
"name": "urn:law:std#Integer"
},
"value": 4
}
],
"negated": false,
"origin": "case_input",
"predicate": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#actio_nata_ante_annos"
}
],
"kind": "truth",
"legalTime": "1900-01-01",
"predicate": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#verjaehrung_vollendet"
}Why this resultApplied rules and conditions
Derivation path3 steps
- 1case fact
the claim arose (the right of action opened) that many full years before the day of the dispute; the term is given as a duration, not a date, so one case can be read at any date of the link's law
causa: urn:de:bgb:p11:c4; anni: 4
- 2rule
Die regelmäßige Verjährungsfrist beträgt dreißig Jahre
not Verjährung vollendet: causa: urn:de:bgb:p11:c4
para. 195, para. 198
Identifier
urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#RegelmaessigeVerjaehrungNochNicht - 3query
Query evaluation
verified by the engine: 2 · case fact: 1 · Full graph: 16 nodes
Steps of the saved proof from the case facts to the answer. Formulas are shown as written in the norm with bound values substituted; the page recomputes nothing.
Basis of this answer
Rules on the saved proof path for this answer.
de.bgb_1896
Die regelmäßige Verjährungsfrist beträgt dreißig Jahre
Identifier
urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#RegelmaessigeVerjaehrungNochNicht
Other rules in the evaluation8
Applied in the overall evaluation, but not on the proof path for this answer.
de.bgb_1896
Das Recht, von einem Anderen ein Thun oder ein Unterlassen zu verlangen (Anspruch)
Identifier
urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#AnspruchRemediumDaturVertrag
Identifier
urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#CausaExContractuAnspruch
Identifier
urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#SchuldverhaeltnisAnspruchschuldrechtlicher Anspruch
Identifier
urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#SchuldverhaeltnisInPersonamSchuldner
Identifier
urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#SchuldverhaeltnisObligatioZur Begründung eines Schuldverhältnisses durch Rechtsgeschäft ist ein Vertrag erforderlich
Identifier
urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#VertragBegruendetSchuldverhaeltnis
doctrine.ius_privatum
the right is effective when the remedy belongs to the claimant
Identifier
urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#IusEfficaxthe remedy given by the legal order belongs to the claimant
Identifier
urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#RemediumCompetitDatum
Proof graph
Proof nodes: 16 · assertion 2, rule_application 9, candidate_closure 4, query_evaluation 1
assertion · urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:de:bgb:ein-fall-zwei-jahrhunderte#jahre
- attributes
- assertion
- jahre
- conclusion
- Arguments
- Identifier
- c4
- Type
- entity_ref
- Type
- value
- type
- name
- Integer
- value
- 4
- Type
- literal
- Polarity
- positive
- Condition
- actio_nata_ante_annos
- evidence
- —
- Identifier
- jahre
- Type
- assertion
- Premises
- —
- sourceAnchors
- —
rule_application · urn:proof:apply:RegelmaessigeVerjaehrungNochNicht:6ca0e7837845009ec542b0c11290c1dce5d613ee5f4f8c1593ab1a4e5a2aac5d
- attributes
- —
- conclusion
- Arguments
- Identifier
- c4
- Type
- entity_ref
- Type
- literal
- Polarity
- negative
- Condition
- verjaehrung_vollendet
- evidence
- —
- Identifier
- 6ca0e7837845009ec542b0c11290c1dce5d613ee5f4f8c1593ab1a4e5a2aac5d
- Type
- rule_application
- Premises
- jahre
- Rule
- RegelmaessigeVerjaehrungNochNicht
- sourceAnchors
- —
- substitution
- v0
- Identifier
- c4
- Type
- entity_ref
- v1
- Type
- value
- type
- name
- Integer
- value
- 4
assertion · urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:de:bgb:ein-fall-zwei-jahrhunderte#vertrag
- attributes
- assertion
- vertrag
- conclusion
- Arguments
- Identifier
- g4
- Type
- entity_ref
- Identifier
- s4
- Type
- entity_ref
- Identifier
- c4
- Type
- entity_ref
- Type
- literal
- Polarity
- positive
- Condition
- contractus
- evidence
- —
- Identifier
- vertrag
- Type
- assertion
- Premises
- —
- sourceAnchors
- —
rule_application · urn:proof:apply:CausaExContractu:9910c0976a2020c1ca51bef1d9e46d76164911b21ab1b980b673328965506afc
- attributes
- —
- conclusion
- Arguments
- Identifier
- c4
- Type
- entity_ref
- Type
- literal
- Polarity
- positive
- Condition
- causa_ex_contractu
- evidence
- —
- Identifier
- 9910c0976a2020c1ca51bef1d9e46d76164911b21ab1b980b673328965506afc
- Type
- rule_application
- Premises
- vertrag
- Rule
- CausaExContractu
- sourceAnchors
- —
- substitution
- v0
- Identifier
- g4
- Type
- entity_ref
- v1
- Identifier
- s4
- Type
- entity_ref
- v2
- Identifier
- c4
- Type
- entity_ref
rule_application · urn:proof:apply:VertragBegruendetSchuldverhaeltnis:e7d53358441ac9fc07350786769858a438cf0a4d46cdaed8e4bdd10c1861be90
- attributes
- —
- conclusion
- Arguments
- Identifier
- g4
- Type
- entity_ref
- Identifier
- s4
- Type
- entity_ref
- Identifier
- c4
- Type
- entity_ref
- Type
- literal
- Polarity
- positive
- Condition
- schuldverhaeltnis
- evidence
- —
- Identifier
- e7d53358441ac9fc07350786769858a438cf0a4d46cdaed8e4bdd10c1861be90
- Type
- rule_application
- Premises
- vertrag
- Rule
- VertragBegruendetSchuldverhaeltnis
- sourceAnchors
- —
- substitution
- v0
- Identifier
- g4
- Type
- entity_ref
- v1
- Identifier
- s4
- Type
- entity_ref
- v2
- Identifier
- c4
- Type
- entity_ref
rule_application · urn:proof:apply:SchuldverhaeltnisAnspruch:a609d3c61a1f31d6fd18dac83f9c7c41d033a75f04f6f91c44b1089d62107db4
- attributes
- —
- conclusion
- Arguments
- Identifier
- g4
- Type
- entity_ref
- Identifier
- s4
- Type
- entity_ref
- Identifier
- c4
- Type
- entity_ref
- Type
- literal
- Polarity
- positive
- Condition
- anspruch
- evidence
- —
- Identifier
- a609d3c61a1f31d6fd18dac83f9c7c41d033a75f04f6f91c44b1089d62107db4
- Type
- rule_application
- Premises
- e7d53358441ac9fc07350786769858a438cf0a4d46cdaed8e4bdd10c1861be90
- Rule
- SchuldverhaeltnisAnspruch
- sourceAnchors
- —
- substitution
- v0
- Identifier
- g4
- Type
- entity_ref
- v1
- Identifier
- s4
- Type
- entity_ref
- v2
- Identifier
- c4
- Type
- entity_ref
rule_application · urn:proof:apply:AnspruchRemediumDatur:d96dd16fa87d2a4368004bd849759bb27ab4a609bc641a88db0c06459a09e706
- attributes
- strength
- defeasible
- conclusion
- Arguments
- Identifier
- g4
- Type
- entity_ref
- Identifier
- s4
- Type
- entity_ref
- Identifier
- c4
- Type
- entity_ref
- Type
- literal
- Polarity
- positive
- Condition
- remedium_datur
- evidence
- —
- Identifier
- d96dd16fa87d2a4368004bd849759bb27ab4a609bc641a88db0c06459a09e706
- Type
- rule_application
- Premises
- a609d3c61a1f31d6fd18dac83f9c7c41d033a75f04f6f91c44b1089d62107db4
- Rule
- AnspruchRemediumDatur
- sourceAnchors
- —
- substitution
- v0
- Identifier
- g4
- Type
- entity_ref
- v1
- Identifier
- s4
- Type
- entity_ref
- v2
- Identifier
- c4
- Type
- entity_ref
rule_application · urn:proof:apply:RemediumCompetitDatum:36729e5b335a0d97ae4a5babffe1406312beb7c02d9460bb2922131b5baf07d8
- attributes
- strength
- defeasible
- conclusion
- Arguments
- Identifier
- g4
- Type
- entity_ref
- Identifier
- s4
- Type
- entity_ref
- Identifier
- c4
- Type
- entity_ref
- Type
- literal
- Polarity
- positive
- Condition
- remedium_competit
- evidence
- —
- Identifier
- 36729e5b335a0d97ae4a5babffe1406312beb7c02d9460bb2922131b5baf07d8
- Type
- rule_application
- Premises
- d96dd16fa87d2a4368004bd849759bb27ab4a609bc641a88db0c06459a09e706
- Rule
- RemediumCompetitDatum
- sourceAnchors
- —
- substitution
- v0
- Identifier
- g4
- Type
- entity_ref
- v1
- Identifier
- s4
- Type
- entity_ref
- v2
- Identifier
- c4
- Type
- entity_ref
rule_application · urn:proof:apply:IusEfficax:6387e197569d8d73af784317f44d5d3e37e4537657fb89a6575319ca2a966bfd
- attributes
- strength
- defeasible
- conclusion
- Arguments
- Identifier
- g4
- Type
- entity_ref
- Identifier
- s4
- Type
- entity_ref
- Identifier
- c4
- Type
- entity_ref
- Type
- literal
- Polarity
- positive
- Condition
- ius_efficax
- evidence
- —
- Identifier
- 6387e197569d8d73af784317f44d5d3e37e4537657fb89a6575319ca2a966bfd
- Type
- rule_application
- Premises
- 36729e5b335a0d97ae4a5babffe1406312beb7c02d9460bb2922131b5baf07d8
- Rule
- IusEfficax
- sourceAnchors
- —
- substitution
- v0
- Identifier
- g4
- Type
- entity_ref
- v1
- Identifier
- s4
- Type
- entity_ref
- v2
- Identifier
- c4
- Type
- entity_ref
rule_application · urn:proof:apply:SchuldverhaeltnisInPersonam:4ed919f9069eb7ddfec3d061af4d15cf98f24833715e015750fa1e53bc4cda8a
- attributes
- strength
- defeasible
- conclusion
- Arguments
- Identifier
- g4
- Type
- entity_ref
- Identifier
- s4
- Type
- entity_ref
- Identifier
- c4
- Type
- entity_ref
- Type
- literal
- Polarity
- positive
- Condition
- remedium_in_personam
- evidence
- —
- Identifier
- 4ed919f9069eb7ddfec3d061af4d15cf98f24833715e015750fa1e53bc4cda8a
- Type
- rule_application
- Premises
- e7d53358441ac9fc07350786769858a438cf0a4d46cdaed8e4bdd10c1861be90
- Rule
- SchuldverhaeltnisInPersonam
- sourceAnchors
- —
- substitution
- v0
- Identifier
- g4
- Type
- entity_ref
- v1
- Identifier
- s4
- Type
- entity_ref
- v2
- Identifier
- c4
- Type
- entity_ref
rule_application · urn:proof:apply:SchuldverhaeltnisObligatio:6aae1458cdf1aa09216dda0a430ec989c33018fce2d82986135cedd75b408c7d
- attributes
- —
- conclusion
- Arguments
- Identifier
- s4
- Type
- entity_ref
- Identifier
- g4
- Type
- entity_ref
- Identifier
- c4
- Type
- entity_ref
- Type
- literal
- Polarity
- positive
- Condition
- obligatio
- evidence
- —
- Identifier
- 6aae1458cdf1aa09216dda0a430ec989c33018fce2d82986135cedd75b408c7d
- Type
- rule_application
- Premises
- e7d53358441ac9fc07350786769858a438cf0a4d46cdaed8e4bdd10c1861be90
- Rule
- SchuldverhaeltnisObligatio
- sourceAnchors
- —
- substitution
- v0
- Identifier
- g4
- Type
- entity_ref
- v1
- Identifier
- s4
- Type
- entity_ref
- v2
- Identifier
- c4
- Type
- entity_ref
candidate_closure · urn:proof:closure:ab49e289649b0c7b299ae3af4a38683fff63235bd0705fd0d326c9f8f61e52e9
- attributes
- allApplicableCandidateIds
- 36729e5b335a0d97ae4a5babffe1406312beb7c02d9460bb2922131b5baf07d8
- conflictKey
- {"args":[{"id":"urn:de:bgb:p11:g4","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:de:bgb:p11:s4","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:de:bgb:p11:c4","kind":"entity_ref"}],"predicate":"urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#remedium_competit"}
- evaluationInputSemanticHash
- sha256:23baf316ba6bbac71641091759bcdaa6a0f86f17f7c310167f33d82be2a2a8c1
- priorityGraphHash
- sha256:58d65b711bddd0dd9aafc2522e89ff89444832e76061b73fc7419c5efbe5bcd6
- programSemanticHash
- sha256:1beaf90a712e5b8f919b03cccd9c8bbbcea2b9895334f14ccde56168b49f8457
- stratum
- 3
- survivingCandidateIds
- 36729e5b335a0d97ae4a5babffe1406312beb7c02d9460bb2922131b5baf07d8
- conclusion
- Arguments
- Identifier
- g4
- Type
- entity_ref
- Identifier
- s4
- Type
- entity_ref
- Identifier
- c4
- Type
- entity_ref
- Type
- literal
- Polarity
- positive
- Condition
- remedium_competit
- evidence
- —
- Identifier
- ab49e289649b0c7b299ae3af4a38683fff63235bd0705fd0d326c9f8f61e52e9
- Type
- candidate_closure
- Premises
- 36729e5b335a0d97ae4a5babffe1406312beb7c02d9460bb2922131b5baf07d8
- sourceAnchors
- —
candidate_closure · urn:proof:closure:c072bf0a2caec1573c624c713246ac70ef547e5720c8dc4859234950645a278b
- attributes
- allApplicableCandidateIds
- 6387e197569d8d73af784317f44d5d3e37e4537657fb89a6575319ca2a966bfd
- conflictKey
- {"args":[{"id":"urn:de:bgb:p11:g4","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:de:bgb:p11:s4","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:de:bgb:p11:c4","kind":"entity_ref"}],"predicate":"urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#ius_efficax"}
- evaluationInputSemanticHash
- sha256:23baf316ba6bbac71641091759bcdaa6a0f86f17f7c310167f33d82be2a2a8c1
- priorityGraphHash
- sha256:58d65b711bddd0dd9aafc2522e89ff89444832e76061b73fc7419c5efbe5bcd6
- programSemanticHash
- sha256:1beaf90a712e5b8f919b03cccd9c8bbbcea2b9895334f14ccde56168b49f8457
- stratum
- 4
- survivingCandidateIds
- 6387e197569d8d73af784317f44d5d3e37e4537657fb89a6575319ca2a966bfd
- conclusion
- Arguments
- Identifier
- g4
- Type
- entity_ref
- Identifier
- s4
- Type
- entity_ref
- Identifier
- c4
- Type
- entity_ref
- Type
- literal
- Polarity
- positive
- Condition
- ius_efficax
- evidence
- —
- Identifier
- c072bf0a2caec1573c624c713246ac70ef547e5720c8dc4859234950645a278b
- Type
- candidate_closure
- Premises
- 6387e197569d8d73af784317f44d5d3e37e4537657fb89a6575319ca2a966bfd
- sourceAnchors
- —
candidate_closure · urn:proof:closure:d03eac116c202ec78d1d6e927bc044cdc254b9660208e6cc1bd8959f9fdb6ced
- attributes
- allApplicableCandidateIds
- d96dd16fa87d2a4368004bd849759bb27ab4a609bc641a88db0c06459a09e706
- conflictKey
- {"args":[{"id":"urn:de:bgb:p11:g4","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:de:bgb:p11:s4","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:de:bgb:p11:c4","kind":"entity_ref"}],"predicate":"urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#remedium_datur"}
- evaluationInputSemanticHash
- sha256:23baf316ba6bbac71641091759bcdaa6a0f86f17f7c310167f33d82be2a2a8c1
- priorityGraphHash
- sha256:58d65b711bddd0dd9aafc2522e89ff89444832e76061b73fc7419c5efbe5bcd6
- programSemanticHash
- sha256:1beaf90a712e5b8f919b03cccd9c8bbbcea2b9895334f14ccde56168b49f8457
- stratum
- 2
- survivingCandidateIds
- d96dd16fa87d2a4368004bd849759bb27ab4a609bc641a88db0c06459a09e706
- conclusion
- Arguments
- Identifier
- g4
- Type
- entity_ref
- Identifier
- s4
- Type
- entity_ref
- Identifier
- c4
- Type
- entity_ref
- Type
- literal
- Polarity
- positive
- Condition
- remedium_datur
- evidence
- —
- Identifier
- d03eac116c202ec78d1d6e927bc044cdc254b9660208e6cc1bd8959f9fdb6ced
- Type
- candidate_closure
- Premises
- d96dd16fa87d2a4368004bd849759bb27ab4a609bc641a88db0c06459a09e706
- sourceAnchors
- —
candidate_closure · urn:proof:closure:e416b1399f8113c6f68ee46ee9b4c5861231f696c0b9717c0d0be89ec40382e3
- attributes
- allApplicableCandidateIds
- 4ed919f9069eb7ddfec3d061af4d15cf98f24833715e015750fa1e53bc4cda8a
- conflictKey
- {"args":[{"id":"urn:de:bgb:p11:g4","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:de:bgb:p11:s4","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:de:bgb:p11:c4","kind":"entity_ref"}],"predicate":"urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#remedium_in_personam"}
- evaluationInputSemanticHash
- sha256:23baf316ba6bbac71641091759bcdaa6a0f86f17f7c310167f33d82be2a2a8c1
- priorityGraphHash
- sha256:58d65b711bddd0dd9aafc2522e89ff89444832e76061b73fc7419c5efbe5bcd6
- programSemanticHash
- sha256:1beaf90a712e5b8f919b03cccd9c8bbbcea2b9895334f14ccde56168b49f8457
- stratum
- 1
- survivingCandidateIds
- 4ed919f9069eb7ddfec3d061af4d15cf98f24833715e015750fa1e53bc4cda8a
- conclusion
- Arguments
- Identifier
- g4
- Type
- entity_ref
- Identifier
- s4
- Type
- entity_ref
- Identifier
- c4
- Type
- entity_ref
- Type
- literal
- Polarity
- positive
- Condition
- remedium_in_personam
- evidence
- —
- Identifier
- e416b1399f8113c6f68ee46ee9b4c5861231f696c0b9717c0d0be89ec40382e3
- Type
- candidate_closure
- Premises
- 4ed919f9069eb7ddfec3d061af4d15cf98f24833715e015750fa1e53bc4cda8a
- sourceAnchors
- —
query_evaluation · urn:proof:query:ein-fall-zwei-jahrhunderte#case/VierJahre_1896/query/v4-1896-vollendet
- attributes
- —
- conclusion
- literal
- Arguments
- Identifier
- c4
- Type
- entity_ref
- Type
- literal
- Polarity
- positive
- Condition
- verjaehrung_vollendet
- truthStatus
- Refuted
- evidence
- —
- Identifier
- case/VierJahre_1896/query/v4-1896-vollendet
- Type
- query_evaluation
- Premises
- 6ca0e7837845009ec542b0c11290c1dce5d613ee5f4f8c1593ab1a4e5a2aac5d
- sourceAnchors
- —
Calendar and proof identifiers
- Proof reference
- case/VierJahre_1896/query/v4-1896-vollendet
Original reasoning · JSON
{
"evaluation": {
"conflicts": [],
"issues": [],
"manifest": {
"artifactHash": "sha256:5b73dc66560078d6d02b2f5dc9919fe9e0fb63d05e648b9ba524e1154a2c449f",
"calendarSnapshot": "",
"caseHash": "sha256:23baf316ba6bbac71641091759bcdaa6a0f86f17f7c310167f33d82be2a2a8c1",
"decisionTime": "2024-06-01T12:00:00Z",
"evidenceSnapshotHash": "sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
"externalSnapshots": {},
"id": "urn:manifest:oracle-1",
"interpretations": [],
"knowledgeTime": "2024-06-01T12:00:00Z",
"legalTime": "1900-01-01",
"lockfileHash": "sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
"mode": "audit",
"policies": {},
"programHash": "sha256:1beaf90a712e5b8f919b03cccd9c8bbbcea2b9895334f14ccde56168b49f8457",
"resolvedEditions": {},
"semanticHash": "sha256:cb2d0635b0c07f680a54fc42b59a9d5ce1604612ac9b3184b5aae23e1edac5d0",
"semantics": "law.core/0.2.1",
"theoryHash": "sha256:1beaf90a712e5b8f919b03cccd9c8bbbcea2b9895334f14ccde56168b49f8457",
"timezone": "Europe/Berlin"
},
"positions": [],
"proofGraph": {
"nodes": [
{
"attributes": {
"assertion": "urn:law:examples:de:bgb:ein-fall-zwei-jahrhunderte#jahre"
},
"conclusion": {
"args": [
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"kind": "value",
"type": {
"name": "urn:law:std#Integer"
},
"value": 4
}
],
"kind": "literal",
"polarity": "positive",
"predicate": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#actio_nata_ante_annos"
},
"evidence": [],
"id": "urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:de:bgb:ein-fall-zwei-jahrhunderte#jahre",
"kind": "assertion",
"premises": [],
"sourceAnchors": []
},
{
"attributes": {},
"conclusion": {
"args": [
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
],
"kind": "literal",
"polarity": "negative",
"predicate": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#verjaehrung_vollendet"
},
"evidence": [],
"id": "urn:proof:apply:RegelmaessigeVerjaehrungNochNicht:6ca0e7837845009ec542b0c11290c1dce5d613ee5f4f8c1593ab1a4e5a2aac5d",
"kind": "rule_application",
"premises": [
"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:de:bgb:ein-fall-zwei-jahrhunderte#jahre"
],
"rule": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#RegelmaessigeVerjaehrungNochNicht",
"sourceAnchors": [],
"substitution": {
"v0": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
"v1": {
"kind": "value",
"type": {
"name": "urn:law:std#Integer"
},
"value": 4
}
}
},
{
"attributes": {
"assertion": "urn:law:examples:de:bgb:ein-fall-zwei-jahrhunderte#vertrag"
},
"conclusion": {
"args": [
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:g4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:s4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
],
"kind": "literal",
"polarity": "positive",
"predicate": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#contractus"
},
"evidence": [],
"id": "urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:de:bgb:ein-fall-zwei-jahrhunderte#vertrag",
"kind": "assertion",
"premises": [],
"sourceAnchors": []
},
{
"attributes": {},
"conclusion": {
"args": [
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
],
"kind": "literal",
"polarity": "positive",
"predicate": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#causa_ex_contractu"
},
"evidence": [],
"id": "urn:proof:apply:CausaExContractu:9910c0976a2020c1ca51bef1d9e46d76164911b21ab1b980b673328965506afc",
"kind": "rule_application",
"premises": [
"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:de:bgb:ein-fall-zwei-jahrhunderte#vertrag"
],
"rule": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#CausaExContractu",
"sourceAnchors": [],
"substitution": {
"v0": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:g4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
"v1": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:s4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
"v2": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
}
},
{
"attributes": {},
"conclusion": {
"args": [
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:g4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:s4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
],
"kind": "literal",
"polarity": "positive",
"predicate": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#schuldverhaeltnis"
},
"evidence": [],
"id": "urn:proof:apply:VertragBegruendetSchuldverhaeltnis:e7d53358441ac9fc07350786769858a438cf0a4d46cdaed8e4bdd10c1861be90",
"kind": "rule_application",
"premises": [
"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:de:bgb:ein-fall-zwei-jahrhunderte#vertrag"
],
"rule": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#VertragBegruendetSchuldverhaeltnis",
"sourceAnchors": [],
"substitution": {
"v0": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:g4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
"v1": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:s4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
"v2": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
}
},
{
"attributes": {},
"conclusion": {
"args": [
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:g4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:s4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
],
"kind": "literal",
"polarity": "positive",
"predicate": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#anspruch"
},
"evidence": [],
"id": "urn:proof:apply:SchuldverhaeltnisAnspruch:a609d3c61a1f31d6fd18dac83f9c7c41d033a75f04f6f91c44b1089d62107db4",
"kind": "rule_application",
"premises": [
"urn:proof:apply:VertragBegruendetSchuldverhaeltnis:e7d53358441ac9fc07350786769858a438cf0a4d46cdaed8e4bdd10c1861be90"
],
"rule": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#SchuldverhaeltnisAnspruch",
"sourceAnchors": [],
"substitution": {
"v0": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:g4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
"v1": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:s4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
"v2": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
}
},
{
"attributes": {
"strength": "defeasible"
},
"conclusion": {
"args": [
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:g4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:s4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
],
"kind": "literal",
"polarity": "positive",
"predicate": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#remedium_datur"
},
"evidence": [],
"id": "urn:proof:apply:AnspruchRemediumDatur:d96dd16fa87d2a4368004bd849759bb27ab4a609bc641a88db0c06459a09e706",
"kind": "rule_application",
"premises": [
"urn:proof:apply:SchuldverhaeltnisAnspruch:a609d3c61a1f31d6fd18dac83f9c7c41d033a75f04f6f91c44b1089d62107db4"
],
"rule": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#AnspruchRemediumDatur",
"sourceAnchors": [],
"substitution": {
"v0": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:g4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
"v1": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:s4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
"v2": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
}
},
{
"attributes": {
"strength": "defeasible"
},
"conclusion": {
"args": [
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:g4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:s4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
],
"kind": "literal",
"polarity": "positive",
"predicate": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#remedium_competit"
},
"evidence": [],
"id": "urn:proof:apply:RemediumCompetitDatum:36729e5b335a0d97ae4a5babffe1406312beb7c02d9460bb2922131b5baf07d8",
"kind": "rule_application",
"premises": [
"urn:proof:apply:AnspruchRemediumDatur:d96dd16fa87d2a4368004bd849759bb27ab4a609bc641a88db0c06459a09e706"
],
"rule": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#RemediumCompetitDatum",
"sourceAnchors": [],
"substitution": {
"v0": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:g4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
"v1": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:s4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
"v2": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
}
},
{
"attributes": {
"strength": "defeasible"
},
"conclusion": {
"args": [
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:g4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:s4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
],
"kind": "literal",
"polarity": "positive",
"predicate": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#ius_efficax"
},
"evidence": [],
"id": "urn:proof:apply:IusEfficax:6387e197569d8d73af784317f44d5d3e37e4537657fb89a6575319ca2a966bfd",
"kind": "rule_application",
"premises": [
"urn:proof:apply:RemediumCompetitDatum:36729e5b335a0d97ae4a5babffe1406312beb7c02d9460bb2922131b5baf07d8"
],
"rule": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#IusEfficax",
"sourceAnchors": [],
"substitution": {
"v0": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:g4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
"v1": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:s4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
"v2": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
}
},
{
"attributes": {
"strength": "defeasible"
},
"conclusion": {
"args": [
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:g4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:s4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
],
"kind": "literal",
"polarity": "positive",
"predicate": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#remedium_in_personam"
},
"evidence": [],
"id": "urn:proof:apply:SchuldverhaeltnisInPersonam:4ed919f9069eb7ddfec3d061af4d15cf98f24833715e015750fa1e53bc4cda8a",
"kind": "rule_application",
"premises": [
"urn:proof:apply:VertragBegruendetSchuldverhaeltnis:e7d53358441ac9fc07350786769858a438cf0a4d46cdaed8e4bdd10c1861be90"
],
"rule": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#SchuldverhaeltnisInPersonam",
"sourceAnchors": [],
"substitution": {
"v0": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:g4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
"v1": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:s4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
"v2": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
}
},
{
"attributes": {},
"conclusion": {
"args": [
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:s4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:g4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
],
"kind": "literal",
"polarity": "positive",
"predicate": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#obligatio"
},
"evidence": [],
"id": "urn:proof:apply:SchuldverhaeltnisObligatio:6aae1458cdf1aa09216dda0a430ec989c33018fce2d82986135cedd75b408c7d",
"kind": "rule_application",
"premises": [
"urn:proof:apply:VertragBegruendetSchuldverhaeltnis:e7d53358441ac9fc07350786769858a438cf0a4d46cdaed8e4bdd10c1861be90"
],
"rule": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#SchuldverhaeltnisObligatio",
"sourceAnchors": [],
"substitution": {
"v0": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:g4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
"v1": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:s4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
"v2": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
}
},
{
"attributes": {
"allApplicableCandidateIds": [
"urn:proof:apply:RemediumCompetitDatum:36729e5b335a0d97ae4a5babffe1406312beb7c02d9460bb2922131b5baf07d8"
],
"conflictKey": "{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:de:bgb:p11:g4\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:de:bgb:p11:s4\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:de:bgb:p11:c4\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"predicate\":\"urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#remedium_competit\"}",
"evaluationInputSemanticHash": "sha256:23baf316ba6bbac71641091759bcdaa6a0f86f17f7c310167f33d82be2a2a8c1",
"priorityGraphHash": "sha256:58d65b711bddd0dd9aafc2522e89ff89444832e76061b73fc7419c5efbe5bcd6",
"programSemanticHash": "sha256:1beaf90a712e5b8f919b03cccd9c8bbbcea2b9895334f14ccde56168b49f8457",
"stratum": 3,
"survivingCandidateIds": [
"urn:proof:apply:RemediumCompetitDatum:36729e5b335a0d97ae4a5babffe1406312beb7c02d9460bb2922131b5baf07d8"
]
},
"conclusion": {
"args": [
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:g4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:s4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
],
"kind": "literal",
"polarity": "positive",
"predicate": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#remedium_competit"
},
"evidence": [],
"id": "urn:proof:closure:ab49e289649b0c7b299ae3af4a38683fff63235bd0705fd0d326c9f8f61e52e9",
"kind": "candidate_closure",
"premises": [
"urn:proof:apply:RemediumCompetitDatum:36729e5b335a0d97ae4a5babffe1406312beb7c02d9460bb2922131b5baf07d8"
],
"sourceAnchors": []
},
{
"attributes": {
"allApplicableCandidateIds": [
"urn:proof:apply:IusEfficax:6387e197569d8d73af784317f44d5d3e37e4537657fb89a6575319ca2a966bfd"
],
"conflictKey": "{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:de:bgb:p11:g4\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:de:bgb:p11:s4\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:de:bgb:p11:c4\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"predicate\":\"urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#ius_efficax\"}",
"evaluationInputSemanticHash": "sha256:23baf316ba6bbac71641091759bcdaa6a0f86f17f7c310167f33d82be2a2a8c1",
"priorityGraphHash": "sha256:58d65b711bddd0dd9aafc2522e89ff89444832e76061b73fc7419c5efbe5bcd6",
"programSemanticHash": "sha256:1beaf90a712e5b8f919b03cccd9c8bbbcea2b9895334f14ccde56168b49f8457",
"stratum": 4,
"survivingCandidateIds": [
"urn:proof:apply:IusEfficax:6387e197569d8d73af784317f44d5d3e37e4537657fb89a6575319ca2a966bfd"
]
},
"conclusion": {
"args": [
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:g4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:s4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
],
"kind": "literal",
"polarity": "positive",
"predicate": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#ius_efficax"
},
"evidence": [],
"id": "urn:proof:closure:c072bf0a2caec1573c624c713246ac70ef547e5720c8dc4859234950645a278b",
"kind": "candidate_closure",
"premises": [
"urn:proof:apply:IusEfficax:6387e197569d8d73af784317f44d5d3e37e4537657fb89a6575319ca2a966bfd"
],
"sourceAnchors": []
},
{
"attributes": {
"allApplicableCandidateIds": [
"urn:proof:apply:AnspruchRemediumDatur:d96dd16fa87d2a4368004bd849759bb27ab4a609bc641a88db0c06459a09e706"
],
"conflictKey": "{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:de:bgb:p11:g4\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:de:bgb:p11:s4\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:de:bgb:p11:c4\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"predicate\":\"urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#remedium_datur\"}",
"evaluationInputSemanticHash": "sha256:23baf316ba6bbac71641091759bcdaa6a0f86f17f7c310167f33d82be2a2a8c1",
"priorityGraphHash": "sha256:58d65b711bddd0dd9aafc2522e89ff89444832e76061b73fc7419c5efbe5bcd6",
"programSemanticHash": "sha256:1beaf90a712e5b8f919b03cccd9c8bbbcea2b9895334f14ccde56168b49f8457",
"stratum": 2,
"survivingCandidateIds": [
"urn:proof:apply:AnspruchRemediumDatur:d96dd16fa87d2a4368004bd849759bb27ab4a609bc641a88db0c06459a09e706"
]
},
"conclusion": {
"args": [
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:g4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:s4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
],
"kind": "literal",
"polarity": "positive",
"predicate": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#remedium_datur"
},
"evidence": [],
"id": "urn:proof:closure:d03eac116c202ec78d1d6e927bc044cdc254b9660208e6cc1bd8959f9fdb6ced",
"kind": "candidate_closure",
"premises": [
"urn:proof:apply:AnspruchRemediumDatur:d96dd16fa87d2a4368004bd849759bb27ab4a609bc641a88db0c06459a09e706"
],
"sourceAnchors": []
},
{
"attributes": {
"allApplicableCandidateIds": [
"urn:proof:apply:SchuldverhaeltnisInPersonam:4ed919f9069eb7ddfec3d061af4d15cf98f24833715e015750fa1e53bc4cda8a"
],
"conflictKey": "{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:de:bgb:p11:g4\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:de:bgb:p11:s4\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:de:bgb:p11:c4\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"predicate\":\"urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#remedium_in_personam\"}",
"evaluationInputSemanticHash": "sha256:23baf316ba6bbac71641091759bcdaa6a0f86f17f7c310167f33d82be2a2a8c1",
"priorityGraphHash": "sha256:58d65b711bddd0dd9aafc2522e89ff89444832e76061b73fc7419c5efbe5bcd6",
"programSemanticHash": "sha256:1beaf90a712e5b8f919b03cccd9c8bbbcea2b9895334f14ccde56168b49f8457",
"stratum": 1,
"survivingCandidateIds": [
"urn:proof:apply:SchuldverhaeltnisInPersonam:4ed919f9069eb7ddfec3d061af4d15cf98f24833715e015750fa1e53bc4cda8a"
]
},
"conclusion": {
"args": [
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:g4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:s4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
],
"kind": "literal",
"polarity": "positive",
"predicate": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#remedium_in_personam"
},
"evidence": [],
"id": "urn:proof:closure:e416b1399f8113c6f68ee46ee9b4c5861231f696c0b9717c0d0be89ec40382e3",
"kind": "candidate_closure",
"premises": [
"urn:proof:apply:SchuldverhaeltnisInPersonam:4ed919f9069eb7ddfec3d061af4d15cf98f24833715e015750fa1e53bc4cda8a"
],
"sourceAnchors": []
},
{
"attributes": {},
"conclusion": {
"literal": {
"args": [
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
],
"kind": "literal",
"polarity": "positive",
"predicate": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#verjaehrung_vollendet"
},
"truthStatus": "FALSE_ONLY"
},
"evidence": [],
"id": "urn:proof:query:ein-fall-zwei-jahrhunderte#case/VierJahre_1896/query/v4-1896-vollendet",
"kind": "query_evaluation",
"premises": [
"urn:proof:apply:RegelmaessigeVerjaehrungNochNicht:6ca0e7837845009ec542b0c11290c1dce5d613ee5f4f8c1593ab1a4e5a2aac5d"
],
"sourceAnchors": []
}
],
"proofHash": "sha256:b66dd0a6fa103c3c789946e9e25d0e23f860915d1b99eba1da5a750d320dcb61",
"roots": [
"urn:proof:query:ein-fall-zwei-jahrhunderte#case/VierJahre_1896/query/v4-1896-vollendet"
]
},
"resultHash": "sha256:5933d7b19e64f6db35601cf6faab0c0e67e60b2db5d270b739146c176da6b0f4",
"results": [
{
"conflicts": [],
"evaluationStatus": "COMPUTED",
"evidence": [],
"id": "urn:result:ein-fall-zwei-jahrhunderte#case/VierJahre_1896/query/v4-1896-vollendet",
"judgmentRequests": [],
"manifest": "urn:manifest:oracle-1",
"missingInputs": [],
"normativeStatusSupports": [],
"proof": "urn:proof:query:ein-fall-zwei-jahrhunderte#case/VierJahre_1896/query/v4-1896-vollendet",
"query": "urn:law:examples:de:bgb:ein-fall-zwei-jahrhunderte#case/VierJahre_1896/query/v4-1896-vollendet",
"resultKind": "PROPOSITION",
"sourceAnchors": [],
"target": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#verjaehrung_vollendet",
"truthStatus": "FALSE_ONLY"
}
],
"schemaVersion": "law.core.evaluation/0.2"
},
"proofRef": "urn:proof:query:ein-fall-zwei-jahrhunderte#case/VierJahre_1896/query/v4-1896-vollendet",
"rulesApplied": [
"urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#AnspruchRemediumDatur",
"urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#CausaExContractu",
"urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#RegelmaessigeVerjaehrungNochNicht",
"urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#SchuldverhaeltnisAnspruch",
"urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#SchuldverhaeltnisInPersonam",
"urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#SchuldverhaeltnisObligatio",
"urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#VertragBegruendetSchuldverhaeltnis",
"urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#IusEfficax",
"urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#RemediumCompetitDatum"
]
}SourcesExcerpts: 5
paragraph/194
§ 194 Das Recht, von einem Anderen ein Thun oder ein Unterlassen zu verlangen (Anspruch), unterliegt der Verjährung. Der Anspruch aus einem familienrechtlichen Verhältniß unterliegt der Verjährung nicht, soweit er auf die Herstellung des dem Verhältniß entsprechenden Zustandes für die Zukunft gerichtet ist.
Original data · JSON
{
"contentHash": "sha256:d6eb2d21893667f66864b2c8b06f80e8852e5ae0fb966a863e715922068d862b",
"edition": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#BGB_1896_WIKISOURCE",
"fragmentKind": "article",
"id": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#BGB_P194",
"kind": "fragment",
"locator": "paragraph/194",
"package": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896",
"texts": [
{
"contentHash": "sha256:6474aa2a7e1f0e3d986a3ac80ca63a34b83a25619ad5db2004eb91505298dbbc",
"language": "de",
"status": "official",
"text": "§ 194\nDas Recht, von einem Anderen ein Thun oder ein Unterlassen zu verlangen (Anspruch), unterliegt der Verjährung.\nDer Anspruch aus einem familienrechtlichen Verhältniß unterliegt der Verjährung nicht, soweit er auf die Herstellung des dem Verhältniß entsprechenden Zustandes für die Zukunft gerichtet ist.\n"
}
]
}paragraph/195
§ 195 Die regelmäßige Verjährungsfrist beträgt dreißig Jahre.
Original data · JSON
{
"contentHash": "sha256:8a81acd785f976eaabdba546f4543d417c6d1ff2eef8acf6ca76099a71edd357",
"edition": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#BGB_1896_WIKISOURCE",
"fragmentKind": "article",
"id": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#BGB_P195",
"kind": "fragment",
"locator": "paragraph/195",
"package": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896",
"texts": [
{
"contentHash": "sha256:06d01bf02e9f3967954cfd8f87137d43a1d771fca4439885d9edff34a5e7e8e9",
"language": "de",
"status": "official",
"text": "§ 195\nDie regelmäßige Verjährungsfrist beträgt dreißig Jahre.\n"
}
]
}paragraph/198
§ 198 Die Verjährung beginnt mit der Entstehung des Anspruchs. Geht der Anspruch auf ein Unterlassen, so beginnt die Verjährung mit der Zuwiderhandlung.
Original data · JSON
{
"contentHash": "sha256:037fad6739ea7d56ff7b9d0d4dcb6a701d682e0a9c29ba2457c23da973c89d90",
"edition": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#BGB_1896_WIKISOURCE",
"fragmentKind": "article",
"id": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#BGB_P198",
"kind": "fragment",
"locator": "paragraph/198",
"package": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896",
"texts": [
{
"contentHash": "sha256:d6ce3ed08efd46b998252501e15d3c1c88b69361afaf5a5509b97c3773f3a8f8",
"language": "de",
"status": "official",
"text": "§ 198\nDie Verjährung beginnt mit der Entstehung des Anspruchs. Geht der Anspruch auf ein Unterlassen, so beginnt die Verjährung mit der Zuwiderhandlung.\n"
}
]
}paragraph/241
§ 241 Kraft des Schuldverhältnisses ist der Gläubiger berechtigt, von dem Schuldner eine Leistung zu fordern. Die Leistung kann auch in einem Unterlassen bestehen.
Original data · JSON
{
"contentHash": "sha256:f62095aa2b5c8da6074b03044927af0797462243e9a68da1c388525d7a17de3c",
"edition": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#BGB_1896_WIKISOURCE",
"fragmentKind": "article",
"id": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#BGB_P241",
"kind": "fragment",
"locator": "paragraph/241",
"package": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896",
"texts": [
{
"contentHash": "sha256:06ce3c0749800023fe4b29d23668cfe3da139dceec73fc8ad76f4e19c590eba4",
"language": "de",
"status": "official",
"text": "§ 241\nKraft des Schuldverhältnisses ist der Gläubiger berechtigt, von dem Schuldner eine Leistung zu fordern. Die Leistung kann auch in einem Unterlassen bestehen.\n"
}
]
}paragraph/305
§ 305 Zur Begründung eines Schuldverhältnisses durch Rechtsgeschäft sowie zur Aenderung des Inhalts eines Schuldverhältnisses ist ein Vertrag zwischen den Betheiligten erforderlich, soweit nicht das Gesetz ein Anderes vorschreibt.
Original data · JSON
{
"contentHash": "sha256:bb00dd1984cf2565662f7fb2ff77c2127c1f51cc631b56fcf109a9f82a22fb14",
"edition": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#BGB_1896_WIKISOURCE",
"fragmentKind": "article",
"id": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#BGB_P305",
"kind": "fragment",
"locator": "paragraph/305",
"package": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896",
"texts": [
{
"contentHash": "sha256:2f476360e1db320eb53d1e6bcece14659f7d2d472c296a4b0d3bc1463a062ea9",
"language": "de",
"status": "official",
"text": "§ 305\nZur Begründung eines Schuldverhältnisses durch Rechtsgeschäft sowie zur Aenderung des Inhalts eines Schuldverhältnisses ist ein Vertrag zwischen den Betheiligten erforderlich, soweit nicht das Gesetz ein Anderes vorschreibt.\n"
}
]
}Packages in the snapshot
- de.bgb.core
- de.bgb.fristen
- de.bgb_1896
- doctrine.ius_privatum
Technical dataFull response, parameters and checksums
- Calculation status
- COMPUTED
Full engine response
BGB 1896: die dreißigjährige Frist ist nicht vollendet
Complete machine result · JSON
{
"answer": {
"evaluationStatus": "COMPUTED",
"kind": "TRUTH",
"missingInputs": [],
"truthStatus": "FALSE_ONLY"
},
"evaluation": {
"conflicts": [],
"issues": [],
"manifest": {
"artifactHash": "sha256:5b73dc66560078d6d02b2f5dc9919fe9e0fb63d05e648b9ba524e1154a2c449f",
"calendarSnapshot": "",
"caseHash": "sha256:23baf316ba6bbac71641091759bcdaa6a0f86f17f7c310167f33d82be2a2a8c1",
"decisionTime": "2024-06-01T12:00:00Z",
"evidenceSnapshotHash": "sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
"externalSnapshots": {},
"id": "urn:manifest:oracle-1",
"interpretations": [],
"knowledgeTime": "2024-06-01T12:00:00Z",
"legalTime": "1900-01-01",
"lockfileHash": "sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
"mode": "audit",
"policies": {},
"programHash": "sha256:1beaf90a712e5b8f919b03cccd9c8bbbcea2b9895334f14ccde56168b49f8457",
"resolvedEditions": {},
"semanticHash": "sha256:cb2d0635b0c07f680a54fc42b59a9d5ce1604612ac9b3184b5aae23e1edac5d0",
"semantics": "law.core/0.2.1",
"theoryHash": "sha256:1beaf90a712e5b8f919b03cccd9c8bbbcea2b9895334f14ccde56168b49f8457",
"timezone": "Europe/Berlin"
},
"positions": [],
"proofGraph": {
"nodes": [
{
"attributes": {
"assertion": "urn:law:examples:de:bgb:ein-fall-zwei-jahrhunderte#jahre"
},
"conclusion": {
"args": [
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"kind": "value",
"type": {
"name": "urn:law:std#Integer"
},
"value": 4
}
],
"kind": "literal",
"polarity": "positive",
"predicate": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#actio_nata_ante_annos"
},
"evidence": [],
"id": "urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:de:bgb:ein-fall-zwei-jahrhunderte#jahre",
"kind": "assertion",
"premises": [],
"sourceAnchors": []
},
{
"attributes": {},
"conclusion": {
"args": [
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
],
"kind": "literal",
"polarity": "negative",
"predicate": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#verjaehrung_vollendet"
},
"evidence": [],
"id": "urn:proof:apply:RegelmaessigeVerjaehrungNochNicht:6ca0e7837845009ec542b0c11290c1dce5d613ee5f4f8c1593ab1a4e5a2aac5d",
"kind": "rule_application",
"premises": [
"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:de:bgb:ein-fall-zwei-jahrhunderte#jahre"
],
"rule": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#RegelmaessigeVerjaehrungNochNicht",
"sourceAnchors": [],
"substitution": {
"v0": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
"v1": {
"kind": "value",
"type": {
"name": "urn:law:std#Integer"
},
"value": 4
}
}
},
{
"attributes": {
"assertion": "urn:law:examples:de:bgb:ein-fall-zwei-jahrhunderte#vertrag"
},
"conclusion": {
"args": [
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:g4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:s4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
],
"kind": "literal",
"polarity": "positive",
"predicate": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#contractus"
},
"evidence": [],
"id": "urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:de:bgb:ein-fall-zwei-jahrhunderte#vertrag",
"kind": "assertion",
"premises": [],
"sourceAnchors": []
},
{
"attributes": {},
"conclusion": {
"args": [
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
],
"kind": "literal",
"polarity": "positive",
"predicate": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#causa_ex_contractu"
},
"evidence": [],
"id": "urn:proof:apply:CausaExContractu:9910c0976a2020c1ca51bef1d9e46d76164911b21ab1b980b673328965506afc",
"kind": "rule_application",
"premises": [
"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:de:bgb:ein-fall-zwei-jahrhunderte#vertrag"
],
"rule": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#CausaExContractu",
"sourceAnchors": [],
"substitution": {
"v0": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:g4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
"v1": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:s4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
"v2": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
}
},
{
"attributes": {},
"conclusion": {
"args": [
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:g4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:s4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
],
"kind": "literal",
"polarity": "positive",
"predicate": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#schuldverhaeltnis"
},
"evidence": [],
"id": "urn:proof:apply:VertragBegruendetSchuldverhaeltnis:e7d53358441ac9fc07350786769858a438cf0a4d46cdaed8e4bdd10c1861be90",
"kind": "rule_application",
"premises": [
"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:de:bgb:ein-fall-zwei-jahrhunderte#vertrag"
],
"rule": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#VertragBegruendetSchuldverhaeltnis",
"sourceAnchors": [],
"substitution": {
"v0": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:g4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
"v1": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:s4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
"v2": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
}
},
{
"attributes": {},
"conclusion": {
"args": [
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:g4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:s4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
],
"kind": "literal",
"polarity": "positive",
"predicate": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#anspruch"
},
"evidence": [],
"id": "urn:proof:apply:SchuldverhaeltnisAnspruch:a609d3c61a1f31d6fd18dac83f9c7c41d033a75f04f6f91c44b1089d62107db4",
"kind": "rule_application",
"premises": [
"urn:proof:apply:VertragBegruendetSchuldverhaeltnis:e7d53358441ac9fc07350786769858a438cf0a4d46cdaed8e4bdd10c1861be90"
],
"rule": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#SchuldverhaeltnisAnspruch",
"sourceAnchors": [],
"substitution": {
"v0": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:g4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
"v1": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:s4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
"v2": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
}
},
{
"attributes": {
"strength": "defeasible"
},
"conclusion": {
"args": [
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:g4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:s4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
],
"kind": "literal",
"polarity": "positive",
"predicate": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#remedium_datur"
},
"evidence": [],
"id": "urn:proof:apply:AnspruchRemediumDatur:d96dd16fa87d2a4368004bd849759bb27ab4a609bc641a88db0c06459a09e706",
"kind": "rule_application",
"premises": [
"urn:proof:apply:SchuldverhaeltnisAnspruch:a609d3c61a1f31d6fd18dac83f9c7c41d033a75f04f6f91c44b1089d62107db4"
],
"rule": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#AnspruchRemediumDatur",
"sourceAnchors": [],
"substitution": {
"v0": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:g4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
"v1": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:s4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
"v2": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
}
},
{
"attributes": {
"strength": "defeasible"
},
"conclusion": {
"args": [
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:g4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:s4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
],
"kind": "literal",
"polarity": "positive",
"predicate": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#remedium_competit"
},
"evidence": [],
"id": "urn:proof:apply:RemediumCompetitDatum:36729e5b335a0d97ae4a5babffe1406312beb7c02d9460bb2922131b5baf07d8",
"kind": "rule_application",
"premises": [
"urn:proof:apply:AnspruchRemediumDatur:d96dd16fa87d2a4368004bd849759bb27ab4a609bc641a88db0c06459a09e706"
],
"rule": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#RemediumCompetitDatum",
"sourceAnchors": [],
"substitution": {
"v0": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:g4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
"v1": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:s4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
"v2": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
}
},
{
"attributes": {
"strength": "defeasible"
},
"conclusion": {
"args": [
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:g4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:s4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
],
"kind": "literal",
"polarity": "positive",
"predicate": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#ius_efficax"
},
"evidence": [],
"id": "urn:proof:apply:IusEfficax:6387e197569d8d73af784317f44d5d3e37e4537657fb89a6575319ca2a966bfd",
"kind": "rule_application",
"premises": [
"urn:proof:apply:RemediumCompetitDatum:36729e5b335a0d97ae4a5babffe1406312beb7c02d9460bb2922131b5baf07d8"
],
"rule": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#IusEfficax",
"sourceAnchors": [],
"substitution": {
"v0": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:g4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
"v1": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:s4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
"v2": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
}
},
{
"attributes": {
"strength": "defeasible"
},
"conclusion": {
"args": [
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:g4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:s4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
],
"kind": "literal",
"polarity": "positive",
"predicate": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#remedium_in_personam"
},
"evidence": [],
"id": "urn:proof:apply:SchuldverhaeltnisInPersonam:4ed919f9069eb7ddfec3d061af4d15cf98f24833715e015750fa1e53bc4cda8a",
"kind": "rule_application",
"premises": [
"urn:proof:apply:VertragBegruendetSchuldverhaeltnis:e7d53358441ac9fc07350786769858a438cf0a4d46cdaed8e4bdd10c1861be90"
],
"rule": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#SchuldverhaeltnisInPersonam",
"sourceAnchors": [],
"substitution": {
"v0": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:g4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
"v1": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:s4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
"v2": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
}
},
{
"attributes": {},
"conclusion": {
"args": [
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:s4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:g4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
],
"kind": "literal",
"polarity": "positive",
"predicate": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#obligatio"
},
"evidence": [],
"id": "urn:proof:apply:SchuldverhaeltnisObligatio:6aae1458cdf1aa09216dda0a430ec989c33018fce2d82986135cedd75b408c7d",
"kind": "rule_application",
"premises": [
"urn:proof:apply:VertragBegruendetSchuldverhaeltnis:e7d53358441ac9fc07350786769858a438cf0a4d46cdaed8e4bdd10c1861be90"
],
"rule": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#SchuldverhaeltnisObligatio",
"sourceAnchors": [],
"substitution": {
"v0": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:g4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
"v1": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:s4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
"v2": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
}
},
{
"attributes": {
"allApplicableCandidateIds": [
"urn:proof:apply:RemediumCompetitDatum:36729e5b335a0d97ae4a5babffe1406312beb7c02d9460bb2922131b5baf07d8"
],
"conflictKey": "{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:de:bgb:p11:g4\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:de:bgb:p11:s4\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:de:bgb:p11:c4\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"predicate\":\"urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#remedium_competit\"}",
"evaluationInputSemanticHash": "sha256:23baf316ba6bbac71641091759bcdaa6a0f86f17f7c310167f33d82be2a2a8c1",
"priorityGraphHash": "sha256:58d65b711bddd0dd9aafc2522e89ff89444832e76061b73fc7419c5efbe5bcd6",
"programSemanticHash": "sha256:1beaf90a712e5b8f919b03cccd9c8bbbcea2b9895334f14ccde56168b49f8457",
"stratum": 3,
"survivingCandidateIds": [
"urn:proof:apply:RemediumCompetitDatum:36729e5b335a0d97ae4a5babffe1406312beb7c02d9460bb2922131b5baf07d8"
]
},
"conclusion": {
"args": [
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:g4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:s4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
],
"kind": "literal",
"polarity": "positive",
"predicate": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#remedium_competit"
},
"evidence": [],
"id": "urn:proof:closure:ab49e289649b0c7b299ae3af4a38683fff63235bd0705fd0d326c9f8f61e52e9",
"kind": "candidate_closure",
"premises": [
"urn:proof:apply:RemediumCompetitDatum:36729e5b335a0d97ae4a5babffe1406312beb7c02d9460bb2922131b5baf07d8"
],
"sourceAnchors": []
},
{
"attributes": {
"allApplicableCandidateIds": [
"urn:proof:apply:IusEfficax:6387e197569d8d73af784317f44d5d3e37e4537657fb89a6575319ca2a966bfd"
],
"conflictKey": "{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:de:bgb:p11:g4\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:de:bgb:p11:s4\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:de:bgb:p11:c4\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"predicate\":\"urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#ius_efficax\"}",
"evaluationInputSemanticHash": "sha256:23baf316ba6bbac71641091759bcdaa6a0f86f17f7c310167f33d82be2a2a8c1",
"priorityGraphHash": "sha256:58d65b711bddd0dd9aafc2522e89ff89444832e76061b73fc7419c5efbe5bcd6",
"programSemanticHash": "sha256:1beaf90a712e5b8f919b03cccd9c8bbbcea2b9895334f14ccde56168b49f8457",
"stratum": 4,
"survivingCandidateIds": [
"urn:proof:apply:IusEfficax:6387e197569d8d73af784317f44d5d3e37e4537657fb89a6575319ca2a966bfd"
]
},
"conclusion": {
"args": [
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:g4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:s4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
],
"kind": "literal",
"polarity": "positive",
"predicate": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#ius_efficax"
},
"evidence": [],
"id": "urn:proof:closure:c072bf0a2caec1573c624c713246ac70ef547e5720c8dc4859234950645a278b",
"kind": "candidate_closure",
"premises": [
"urn:proof:apply:IusEfficax:6387e197569d8d73af784317f44d5d3e37e4537657fb89a6575319ca2a966bfd"
],
"sourceAnchors": []
},
{
"attributes": {
"allApplicableCandidateIds": [
"urn:proof:apply:AnspruchRemediumDatur:d96dd16fa87d2a4368004bd849759bb27ab4a609bc641a88db0c06459a09e706"
],
"conflictKey": "{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:de:bgb:p11:g4\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:de:bgb:p11:s4\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:de:bgb:p11:c4\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"predicate\":\"urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#remedium_datur\"}",
"evaluationInputSemanticHash": "sha256:23baf316ba6bbac71641091759bcdaa6a0f86f17f7c310167f33d82be2a2a8c1",
"priorityGraphHash": "sha256:58d65b711bddd0dd9aafc2522e89ff89444832e76061b73fc7419c5efbe5bcd6",
"programSemanticHash": "sha256:1beaf90a712e5b8f919b03cccd9c8bbbcea2b9895334f14ccde56168b49f8457",
"stratum": 2,
"survivingCandidateIds": [
"urn:proof:apply:AnspruchRemediumDatur:d96dd16fa87d2a4368004bd849759bb27ab4a609bc641a88db0c06459a09e706"
]
},
"conclusion": {
"args": [
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:g4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:s4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
],
"kind": "literal",
"polarity": "positive",
"predicate": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#remedium_datur"
},
"evidence": [],
"id": "urn:proof:closure:d03eac116c202ec78d1d6e927bc044cdc254b9660208e6cc1bd8959f9fdb6ced",
"kind": "candidate_closure",
"premises": [
"urn:proof:apply:AnspruchRemediumDatur:d96dd16fa87d2a4368004bd849759bb27ab4a609bc641a88db0c06459a09e706"
],
"sourceAnchors": []
},
{
"attributes": {
"allApplicableCandidateIds": [
"urn:proof:apply:SchuldverhaeltnisInPersonam:4ed919f9069eb7ddfec3d061af4d15cf98f24833715e015750fa1e53bc4cda8a"
],
"conflictKey": "{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:de:bgb:p11:g4\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:de:bgb:p11:s4\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:de:bgb:p11:c4\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"predicate\":\"urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#remedium_in_personam\"}",
"evaluationInputSemanticHash": "sha256:23baf316ba6bbac71641091759bcdaa6a0f86f17f7c310167f33d82be2a2a8c1",
"priorityGraphHash": "sha256:58d65b711bddd0dd9aafc2522e89ff89444832e76061b73fc7419c5efbe5bcd6",
"programSemanticHash": "sha256:1beaf90a712e5b8f919b03cccd9c8bbbcea2b9895334f14ccde56168b49f8457",
"stratum": 1,
"survivingCandidateIds": [
"urn:proof:apply:SchuldverhaeltnisInPersonam:4ed919f9069eb7ddfec3d061af4d15cf98f24833715e015750fa1e53bc4cda8a"
]
},
"conclusion": {
"args": [
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:g4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:s4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
],
"kind": "literal",
"polarity": "positive",
"predicate": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#remedium_in_personam"
},
"evidence": [],
"id": "urn:proof:closure:e416b1399f8113c6f68ee46ee9b4c5861231f696c0b9717c0d0be89ec40382e3",
"kind": "candidate_closure",
"premises": [
"urn:proof:apply:SchuldverhaeltnisInPersonam:4ed919f9069eb7ddfec3d061af4d15cf98f24833715e015750fa1e53bc4cda8a"
],
"sourceAnchors": []
},
{
"attributes": {},
"conclusion": {
"literal": {
"args": [
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
],
"kind": "literal",
"polarity": "positive",
"predicate": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#verjaehrung_vollendet"
},
"truthStatus": "FALSE_ONLY"
},
"evidence": [],
"id": "urn:proof:query:ein-fall-zwei-jahrhunderte#case/VierJahre_1896/query/v4-1896-vollendet",
"kind": "query_evaluation",
"premises": [
"urn:proof:apply:RegelmaessigeVerjaehrungNochNicht:6ca0e7837845009ec542b0c11290c1dce5d613ee5f4f8c1593ab1a4e5a2aac5d"
],
"sourceAnchors": []
}
],
"proofHash": "sha256:b66dd0a6fa103c3c789946e9e25d0e23f860915d1b99eba1da5a750d320dcb61",
"roots": [
"urn:proof:query:ein-fall-zwei-jahrhunderte#case/VierJahre_1896/query/v4-1896-vollendet"
]
},
"resultHash": "sha256:5933d7b19e64f6db35601cf6faab0c0e67e60b2db5d270b739146c176da6b0f4",
"results": [
{
"conflicts": [],
"evaluationStatus": "COMPUTED",
"evidence": [],
"id": "urn:result:ein-fall-zwei-jahrhunderte#case/VierJahre_1896/query/v4-1896-vollendet",
"judgmentRequests": [],
"manifest": "urn:manifest:oracle-1",
"missingInputs": [],
"normativeStatusSupports": [],
"proof": "urn:proof:query:ein-fall-zwei-jahrhunderte#case/VierJahre_1896/query/v4-1896-vollendet",
"query": "urn:law:examples:de:bgb:ein-fall-zwei-jahrhunderte#case/VierJahre_1896/query/v4-1896-vollendet",
"resultKind": "PROPOSITION",
"sourceAnchors": [],
"target": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#verjaehrung_vollendet",
"truthStatus": "FALSE_ONLY"
}
],
"schemaVersion": "law.core.evaluation/0.2"
},
"evaluationStatus": "COMPUTED",
"issues": [],
"judgmentRequests": [],
"proofRef": "urn:proof:query:ein-fall-zwei-jahrhunderte#case/VierJahre_1896/query/v4-1896-vollendet",
"provenance": {
"acts": [
{
"artifactHash": "sha256:a6813604c35567e7c586d334efbf524d08f3467170c4b732cfb15809cacf4ff4",
"namespace": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-core",
"package": "de.bgb.core"
},
{
"artifactHash": "sha256:998148eaeeed28f1565811474ee7beb7eacc616c5681ed9638edc976512a9884",
"namespace": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-fristen",
"package": "de.bgb.fristen"
},
{
"artifactHash": "sha256:f534fb22166732d16b0c7fd87e539b4e95cfde2b8811a3247a0915eebfb597aa",
"namespace": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896",
"package": "de.bgb_1896"
},
{
"artifactHash": "sha256:7202de5de49a8a9d12837bc19cb7008ba2d1a68dbcc0134e0afccf1440a6d5ed",
"namespace": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum",
"package": "doctrine.ius_privatum"
}
],
"caseHash": "sha256:23baf316ba6bbac71641091759bcdaa6a0f86f17f7c310167f33d82be2a2a8c1",
"jurisdiction": "Deutschland",
"legalTime": "1900-01-01",
"mode": "audit",
"programHash": "sha256:1beaf90a712e5b8f919b03cccd9c8bbbcea2b9895334f14ccde56168b49f8457",
"resultHash": "sha256:5933d7b19e64f6db35601cf6faab0c0e67e60b2db5d270b739146c176da6b0f4",
"timezone": "Europe/Berlin"
},
"rulesApplied": [
"urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#AnspruchRemediumDatur",
"urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#CausaExContractu",
"urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#RegelmaessigeVerjaehrungNochNicht",
"urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#SchuldverhaeltnisAnspruch",
"urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#SchuldverhaeltnisInPersonam",
"urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#SchuldverhaeltnisObligatio",
"urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#VertragBegruendetSchuldverhaeltnis",
"urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#IusEfficax",
"urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#RemediumCompetitDatum"
]
}Execution · JSON
This block is too large for inline viewing. It is included in full in the document JSON, without truncation.
Download JSON ↓Display metadata
{
"schemaVersion": "law.answers.presentation/0.1",
"source": {
"requestCanonicalSha256": "sha256:80566e19bc88f4c7ffcf3cb0f83394533ae7c295f03fc3be9cd6c2a20306f007"
},
"steps": [
{
"assertionOrigin": "case_input",
"conclusion": {
"args": [
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"kind": "value",
"type": {
"name": "urn:law:std#Integer"
},
"value": 4
}
],
"kind": "literal",
"polarity": "positive",
"predicate": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#actio_nata_ante_annos"
},
"id": "urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:de:bgb:ein-fall-zwei-jahrhunderte#jahre",
"kind": "assertion",
"originStatus": "available",
"premises": [],
"trust": "case"
},
{
"conclusion": {
"args": [
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
],
"kind": "literal",
"polarity": "negative",
"predicate": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#verjaehrung_vollendet"
},
"head": {
"args": [
{
"kind": "var",
"var": "v0"
}
],
"kind": "literal",
"polarity": "negative",
"predicate": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#verjaehrung_vollendet"
},
"id": "urn:proof:apply:RegelmaessigeVerjaehrungNochNicht:6ca0e7837845009ec542b0c11290c1dce5d613ee5f4f8c1593ab1a4e5a2aac5d",
"kind": "rule_application",
"originStatus": "available",
"premises": [
"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:de:bgb:ein-fall-zwei-jahrhunderte#jahre"
],
"rule": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#RegelmaessigeVerjaehrungNochNicht",
"sourceAnchors": [
"urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#BGB_P195",
"urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#BGB_P198"
],
"strength": "strict",
"substitution": {
"v0": {
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
"v1": {
"kind": "value",
"type": {
"name": "urn:law:std#Integer"
},
"value": 4
}
},
"trust": "engine",
"variables": [
{
"id": "v0",
"type": {
"name": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#Causa"
}
},
{
"id": "v1",
"type": {
"name": "urn:law:std#Integer"
}
}
]
},
{
"conclusion": {
"literal": {
"args": [
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
],
"kind": "literal",
"polarity": "positive",
"predicate": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#verjaehrung_vollendet"
},
"truthStatus": "FALSE_ONLY"
},
"id": "urn:proof:query:ein-fall-zwei-jahrhunderte#case/VierJahre_1896/query/v4-1896-vollendet",
"kind": "query_evaluation",
"originStatus": "available",
"premises": [
"urn:proof:apply:RegelmaessigeVerjaehrungNochNicht:6ca0e7837845009ec542b0c11290c1dce5d613ee5f4f8c1593ab1a4e5a2aac5d"
],
"trust": "engine"
}
],
"symbols": [
{
"id": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#AnspruchRemediumDatur",
"kind": "rule",
"labels": [
{
"language": "de",
"status": "official",
"text": "Das Recht, von einem Anderen ein Thun oder ein Unterlassen zu verlangen (Anspruch)"
},
{
"language": "en",
"status": "unofficial",
"text": "The holder of an Anspruch is given a remedy against the obligor (§ 194)"
}
],
"package": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896",
"strength": "defeasible"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#CausaExContractu",
"kind": "rule",
"labels": [
{
"language": "de",
"status": "official",
"text": "Vertrag"
},
{
"language": "en",
"status": "unofficial",
"text": "A claim arising from a contract (§ 305)"
}
],
"package": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896",
"strength": "strict"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#RegelmaessigeVerjaehrungNochNicht",
"kind": "rule",
"labels": [
{
"language": "de",
"status": "official",
"text": "Die regelmäßige Verjährungsfrist beträgt dreißig Jahre"
},
{
"language": "en",
"status": "unofficial",
"text": "A claim that arose fewer than thirty years ago is not yet time-barred (§ 195; § 198)"
}
],
"package": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896",
"strength": "strict"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#SchuldverhaeltnisAnspruch",
"kind": "rule",
"labels": [
{
"language": "de",
"status": "official",
"text": "Anspruch"
},
{
"language": "en",
"status": "unofficial",
"text": "The creditor may require performance from the debtor — Anspruch (§ 241; § 194)"
}
],
"package": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896",
"strength": "strict"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#SchuldverhaeltnisInPersonam",
"kind": "rule",
"labels": [
{
"language": "de",
"status": "official",
"text": "schuldrechtlicher Anspruch"
},
{
"language": "en",
"status": "unofficial",
"text": "The claim to performance of an obligation is a personal remedy (§ 241)"
}
],
"package": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896",
"strength": "defeasible"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#SchuldverhaeltnisObligatio",
"kind": "rule",
"labels": [
{
"language": "de",
"status": "official",
"text": "Schuldner"
},
{
"language": "en",
"status": "unofficial",
"text": "The debtor of an obligation is the debtor under this law (§ 241)"
}
],
"package": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896",
"strength": "strict"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#VertragBegruendetSchuldverhaeltnis",
"kind": "rule",
"labels": [
{
"language": "de",
"status": "official",
"text": "Zur Begründung eines Schuldverhältnisses durch Rechtsgeschäft ist ein Vertrag erforderlich"
},
{
"language": "en",
"status": "unofficial",
"text": "A contract creates an obligation: the creditor may require performance from the debtor (§ 305; § 241)"
}
],
"package": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896",
"strength": "strict"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#anspruch",
"kind": "symbol_decl",
"labels": [
{
"language": "de",
"status": "official",
"text": "Anspruch"
},
{
"language": "en",
"status": "unofficial",
"text": "the right to require another to do or refrain from an act (§ 194)"
}
],
"name": "anspruch",
"package": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896",
"parameters": [
{
"id": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#anspruch/arg/glaeubiger",
"labels": [],
"name": "glaeubiger",
"type": {
"name": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#Persona"
}
},
{
"id": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#anspruch/arg/schuldner",
"labels": [],
"name": "schuldner",
"type": {
"name": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#Persona"
}
},
{
"id": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#anspruch/arg/causa",
"labels": [],
"name": "causa",
"type": {
"name": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#Causa"
}
}
],
"symbolKind": "relation"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#schuldverhaeltnis",
"kind": "symbol_decl",
"labels": [
{
"language": "de",
"status": "official",
"text": "Schuldverhältniß"
},
{
"language": "en",
"status": "unofficial",
"text": "an obligation between creditor and debtor (§ 241, § 305)"
}
],
"name": "schuldverhaeltnis",
"package": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896",
"parameters": [
{
"id": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#schuldverhaeltnis/arg/glaeubiger",
"labels": [],
"name": "glaeubiger",
"type": {
"name": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#Persona"
}
},
{
"id": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#schuldverhaeltnis/arg/schuldner",
"labels": [],
"name": "schuldner",
"type": {
"name": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#Persona"
}
},
{
"id": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#schuldverhaeltnis/arg/causa",
"labels": [],
"name": "causa",
"type": {
"name": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#Causa"
}
}
],
"symbolKind": "relation"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#verjaehrung_vollendet",
"kind": "symbol_decl",
"labels": [
{
"language": "de",
"status": "official",
"text": "Verjährung vollendet"
},
{
"language": "en",
"status": "unofficial",
"text": "the thirty-year limitation of the claim has been completed (§ 195, § 198)"
}
],
"name": "verjaehrung_vollendet",
"package": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896",
"parameters": [
{
"id": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#verjaehrung_vollendet/arg/causa",
"labels": [],
"name": "causa",
"type": {
"name": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#Causa"
}
}
],
"symbolKind": "relation"
},
{
"id": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#Causa",
"kind": "type_decl",
"labels": [
{
"language": "ru-KZ",
"status": "unofficial",
"text": "притязание как основание тяжбы: договор, деликт, собственность, наследство — одно спорное отношение между двумя лицами"
}
],
"name": "Causa",
"package": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum"
},
{
"id": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#IusEfficax",
"kind": "rule",
"labels": [
{
"language": "ru-KZ",
"status": "unofficial",
"text": "Право действенно, когда истцу принадлежит средство защиты"
}
],
"package": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum",
"strength": "defeasible"
},
{
"id": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#Persona",
"kind": "type_decl",
"labels": [
{
"language": "ru-KZ",
"status": "unofficial",
"text": "лицо частного права: истец, ответчик, собственник, должник, кредитор, наследник"
}
],
"name": "Persona",
"package": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum"
},
{
"id": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#RemediumCompetitDatum",
"kind": "rule",
"labels": [
{
"language": "ru-KZ",
"status": "unofficial",
"text": "Данное правопорядком средство защиты принадлежит истцу"
}
],
"package": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum",
"strength": "defeasible"
},
{
"id": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#actio_nata_ante_annos",
"kind": "symbol_decl",
"labels": [
{
"language": "ru-KZ",
"status": "unofficial",
"text": "притязание возникло (право на иск открылось) столько полных лет назад на день спора; срок дан длительностью, а не датой, чтобы один казус читался на любую дату права звена"
}
],
"name": "actio_nata_ante_annos",
"package": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum",
"parameters": [
{
"id": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#actio_nata_ante_annos/arg/causa",
"labels": [],
"name": "causa",
"type": {
"name": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#Causa"
}
},
{
"id": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#actio_nata_ante_annos/arg/anni",
"labels": [],
"name": "anni",
"type": {
"name": "urn:law:std#Integer"
}
}
],
"symbolKind": "relation"
},
{
"id": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#causa_ex_contractu",
"kind": "symbol_decl",
"labels": [
{
"language": "ru-KZ",
"status": "unofficial",
"text": "притязание возникло из договора"
}
],
"name": "causa_ex_contractu",
"package": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum",
"parameters": [
{
"id": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#causa_ex_contractu/arg/causa",
"labels": [],
"name": "causa",
"type": {
"name": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#Causa"
}
}
],
"symbolKind": "relation"
},
{
"id": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#contractus",
"kind": "symbol_decl",
"labels": [
{
"language": "ru-KZ",
"status": "unofficial",
"text": "должник обязался перед кредитором по договору, лежащему в основании притязания"
}
],
"name": "contractus",
"package": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum",
"parameters": [
{
"id": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#contractus/arg/creditor",
"labels": [],
"name": "creditor",
"type": {
"name": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#Persona"
}
},
{
"id": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#contractus/arg/debitor",
"labels": [],
"name": "debitor",
"type": {
"name": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#Persona"
}
},
{
"id": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#contractus/arg/causa",
"labels": [],
"name": "causa",
"type": {
"name": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#Causa"
}
}
],
"symbolKind": "relation"
},
{
"id": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#ius_efficax",
"kind": "symbol_decl",
"labels": [
{
"language": "ru-KZ",
"status": "unofficial",
"text": "право действенно: средство защиты дано и не отнято"
}
],
"name": "ius_efficax",
"package": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum",
"parameters": [
{
"id": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#ius_efficax/arg/actor",
"labels": [],
"name": "actor",
"type": {
"name": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#Persona"
}
},
{
"id": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#ius_efficax/arg/reus",
"labels": [],
"name": "reus",
"type": {
"name": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#Persona"
}
},
{
"id": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#ius_efficax/arg/causa",
"labels": [],
"name": "causa",
"type": {
"name": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#Causa"
}
}
],
"symbolKind": "relation"
},
{
"id": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#obligatio",
"kind": "symbol_decl",
"labels": [
{
"language": "ru-KZ",
"status": "unofficial",
"text": "должник обязан перед кредитором по этому притязанию"
}
],
"name": "obligatio",
"package": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum",
"parameters": [
{
"id": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#obligatio/arg/debitor",
"labels": [],
"name": "debitor",
"type": {
"name": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#Persona"
}
},
{
"id": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#obligatio/arg/creditor",
"labels": [],
"name": "creditor",
"type": {
"name": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#Persona"
}
},
{
"id": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#obligatio/arg/causa",
"labels": [],
"name": "causa",
"type": {
"name": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#Causa"
}
}
],
"symbolKind": "relation"
},
{
"id": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#petitio",
"kind": "symbol_decl",
"labels": [
{
"language": "ru-KZ",
"status": "unofficial",
"text": "истец предъявляет к ответчику притязание — спорное отношение, о котором задаётся вопрос"
}
],
"name": "petitio",
"package": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum",
"parameters": [
{
"id": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#petitio/arg/causa",
"labels": [],
"name": "causa",
"type": {
"name": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#Causa"
}
},
{
"id": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#petitio/arg/actor",
"labels": [],
"name": "actor",
"type": {
"name": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#Persona"
}
},
{
"id": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#petitio/arg/reus",
"labels": [],
"name": "reus",
"type": {
"name": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#Persona"
}
}
],
"symbolKind": "relation"
},
{
"id": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#remedium_competit",
"kind": "symbol_decl",
"labels": [
{
"language": "ru-KZ",
"status": "unofficial",
"text": "средство защиты принадлежит истцу против ответчика: дано ему самому либо перешло к нему или против него по наследству"
}
],
"name": "remedium_competit",
"package": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum",
"parameters": [
{
"id": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#remedium_competit/arg/actor",
"labels": [],
"name": "actor",
"type": {
"name": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#Persona"
}
},
{
"id": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#remedium_competit/arg/reus",
"labels": [],
"name": "reus",
"type": {
"name": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#Persona"
}
},
{
"id": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#remedium_competit/arg/causa",
"labels": [],
"name": "causa",
"type": {
"name": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#Causa"
}
}
],
"symbolKind": "relation"
},
{
"id": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#remedium_datur",
"kind": "symbol_decl",
"labels": [
{
"language": "ru-KZ",
"status": "unofficial",
"text": "правопорядок даёт истцу средство защиты против ответчика по этому притязанию"
}
],
"name": "remedium_datur",
"package": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum",
"parameters": [
{
"id": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#remedium_datur/arg/actor",
"labels": [],
"name": "actor",
"type": {
"name": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#Persona"
}
},
{
"id": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#remedium_datur/arg/reus",
"labels": [],
"name": "reus",
"type": {
"name": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#Persona"
}
},
{
"id": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#remedium_datur/arg/causa",
"labels": [],
"name": "causa",
"type": {
"name": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#Causa"
}
}
],
"symbolKind": "relation"
},
{
"id": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#remedium_in_personam",
"kind": "symbol_decl",
"labels": [
{
"language": "ru-KZ",
"status": "unofficial",
"text": "средство защиты личное: истец требует от ответчика дать, сделать, предоставить"
}
],
"name": "remedium_in_personam",
"package": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum",
"parameters": [
{
"id": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#remedium_in_personam/arg/actor",
"labels": [],
"name": "actor",
"type": {
"name": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#Persona"
}
},
{
"id": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#remedium_in_personam/arg/reus",
"labels": [],
"name": "reus",
"type": {
"name": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#Persona"
}
},
{
"id": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#remedium_in_personam/arg/causa",
"labels": [],
"name": "causa",
"type": {
"name": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#Causa"
}
}
],
"symbolKind": "relation"
}
]
}JSON · calculations, sources and exact data
{
"acts": [
{
"artifactHash": "sha256:a6813604c35567e7c586d334efbf524d08f3467170c4b732cfb15809cacf4ff4",
"namespace": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-core",
"package": "de.bgb.core"
},
{
"artifactHash": "sha256:998148eaeeed28f1565811474ee7beb7eacc616c5681ed9638edc976512a9884",
"namespace": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-fristen",
"package": "de.bgb.fristen"
},
{
"artifactHash": "sha256:f534fb22166732d16b0c7fd87e539b4e95cfde2b8811a3247a0915eebfb597aa",
"namespace": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896",
"package": "de.bgb_1896"
},
{
"artifactHash": "sha256:7202de5de49a8a9d12837bc19cb7008ba2d1a68dbcc0134e0afccf1440a6d5ed",
"namespace": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum",
"package": "doctrine.ius_privatum"
}
],
"caseHash": "sha256:23baf316ba6bbac71641091759bcdaa6a0f86f17f7c310167f33d82be2a2a8c1",
"jurisdiction": "Deutschland",
"legalTime": "1900-01-01",
"mode": "audit",
"programHash": "sha256:1beaf90a712e5b8f919b03cccd9c8bbbcea2b9895334f14ccde56168b49f8457",
"resultHash": "sha256:5933d7b19e64f6db35601cf6faab0c0e67e60b2db5d270b739146c176da6b0f4",
"timezone": "Europe/Berlin"
}- evaluation SHA-256
- sha256:faf0c10d64a5663adc9e2d83d1ae510ddeb01a4db2738bf1f2ba6316449869ef
Original data · JSON
{
"args": [
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
],
"facts": [
{
"args": [
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:g4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:s4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
],
"negated": false,
"origin": "case_input",
"predicate": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#contractus"
},
{
"args": [
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:g4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:s4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
}
],
"negated": false,
"origin": "case_input",
"predicate": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#petitio"
},
{
"args": [
{
"id": "urn:de:bgb:p11:c4",
"kind": "entity_ref"
},
{
"kind": "value",
"type": {
"name": "urn:law:std#Integer"
},
"value": 4
}
],
"negated": false,
"origin": "case_input",
"predicate": "urn:doctrine:clir:ius-privatum#actio_nata_ante_annos"
}
],
"kind": "truth",
"legalTime": "1900-01-01",
"predicate": "urn:de:corpus:clir:bgb-1896#verjaehrung_vollendet"
}