{"assistant":{"explanations":[{"calculationRefs":["vote-procedural-adopted","vote-procedural-blocked"],"text":"Nine votes on a procedural matter adopt the decision. Paragraph 3 does not block it."},{"calculationRefs":["vote-letter-adopted","vote-letter-blocked"],"text":"On the letter, a permanent member's abstention is not a concurring vote. The decision is not adopted, and the missing vote blocks."},{"calculationRefs":["vote-practice-adopted","vote-practice-blocked"],"text":"Practice adds a path on which the same abstention does not prevent adoption. The blocking path of the letter remains."}],"origin":"assistant","summary":"Nine votes in favour. Article 27(2) adopts a procedural decision. Article 27(3) requires the concurring votes of the permanent members. A later reading adds a path; it does not erase the letter."},"calculations":[{"answer":{"answer":{"evaluationStatus":"COMPUTED","kind":"TRUTH","missingInputs":[],"truthStatus":"TRUE_ONLY"},"evaluation":{"conflicts":[],"issues":[],"manifest":{"artifactHash":"sha256:0767659ce1336a603665167add3678052c57846e4619007a6ccdc6398fcf294e","calendarSnapshot":"","caseHash":"sha256:1f67054f049ffdc7e642488912ebfd3e0f3d27a06f383220673bf3a4531fb783","decisionTime":"2026-01-01T12:00:00Z","evidenceSnapshotHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","externalSnapshots":{},"id":"urn:manifest:oracle-1","interpretations":[],"knowledgeTime":"2026-01-01T12:00:00Z","legalTime":"2026-01-01","lockfileHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","mode":"audit","policies":{},"programHash":"sha256:53761165015b682383430aa74b59233f973da8e16ffe719420f98edd8b25519d","resolvedEditions":{},"semanticHash":"sha256:3cf0568970e1a06c5498d2ee5503776286b0db7486adea19f9581089911be5da","semantics":"law.core/0.2.1","theoryHash":"sha256:53761165015b682383430aa74b59233f973da8e16ffe719420f98edd8b25519d","timezone":"UTC"},"positions":[],"proofGraph":{"nodes":[{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#fr"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#fr","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m0","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m1","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m2","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m3","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m4","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m5","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#procedural"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#procedural_matter"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#procedural","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_adopted"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:ProceduralDecisionAdopted:ecf3ae070b6fea45f81712b543c968f84457703d01a48e0ee9b6564f33a5f615","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#fr","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#procedural","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us"],"rule":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#ProceduralDecisionAdopted","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h16351e0bed59b62494f1c5210d0fd5a006de40ee549557096968b0b2c2e81693"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h16351e0bed59b62494f1c5210d0fd5a006de40ee549557096968b0b2c2e81693","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:e6cdd1b41bb6a401a290db8d3f9e0e3e09802f9c184a1edc05d29d0412a6717f","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h16351e0bed59b62494f1c5210d0fd5a006de40ee549557096968b0b2c2e81693"],"rule":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h1670ff143db3b3d29021dc7ad7985b349772e84c0b76792a3ee656307d221a85"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h1670ff143db3b3d29021dc7ad7985b349772e84c0b76792a3ee656307d221a85","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:8b78e920fb454ef68cfd4d28faa95e701383a4945549927ddb0e490175215890","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h1670ff143db3b3d29021dc7ad7985b349772e84c0b76792a3ee656307d221a85"],"rule":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h2577471a877f419d16417bc8ce7642e21e0eaa2649933f621cead7f558251c22"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h2577471a877f419d16417bc8ce7642e21e0eaa2649933f621cead7f558251c22","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:a2e3e604e9de005e17c81a51ce629be98e8e9e509a506046e0cde52b32321222","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h2577471a877f419d16417bc8ce7642e21e0eaa2649933f621cead7f558251c22"],"rule":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h5c5d3b5c9ef348f54b5802f708fcfb08ffdf58f3b19d9f2957124cc18c49ca25"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#RepublicOfChina","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h5c5d3b5c9ef348f54b5802f708fcfb08ffdf58f3b19d9f2957124cc18c49ca25","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#RepublicOfChina","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:4b1a6f6f8748646d22693b4c086f59515bea5071b14cc9f60294942b421440aa","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h5c5d3b5c9ef348f54b5802f708fcfb08ffdf58f3b19d9f2957124cc18c49ca25"],"rule":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#RepublicOfChina","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h95b1a57a07a53f49ec8dcbb91c442be4fdf9ca5f19fb2fa7ee84192725768c7a"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h95b1a57a07a53f49ec8dcbb91c442be4fdf9ca5f19fb2fa7ee84192725768c7a","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:ce60c6e3d670f6229c478e6f4fa5860728de789f588132e65e8a1127d110648f","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h95b1a57a07a53f49ec8dcbb91c442be4fdf9ca5f19fb2fa7ee84192725768c7a"],"rule":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_adopted"},"truthStatus":"TRUE_ONLY"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/ProceduralNineFor/query/decision-adopted-procedural","kind":"query_evaluation","premises":["urn:proof:apply:ProceduralDecisionAdopted:ecf3ae070b6fea45f81712b543c968f84457703d01a48e0ee9b6564f33a5f615"],"sourceAnchors":[]}],"proofHash":"sha256:d5afcbd4f5ed639e1c852efb8a92b6aa2384178363b432795b76c294e268af0c","roots":["urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/ProceduralNineFor/query/decision-adopted-procedural"]},"resultHash":"sha256:fe9c532d0c3705c6cc77d762e5420dfcb2fb09439b5ce60c320aa415b1e43eb7","results":[{"conflicts":[],"evaluationStatus":"COMPUTED","evidence":[],"id":"urn:result:same-vote#case/ProceduralNineFor/query/decision-adopted-procedural","judgmentRequests":[],"manifest":"urn:manifest:oracle-1","missingInputs":[],"normativeStatusSupports":[],"proof":"urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/ProceduralNineFor/query/decision-adopted-procedural","query":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#case/ProceduralNineFor/query/decision-adopted-procedural","resultKind":"PROPOSITION","sourceAnchors":[],"target":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_adopted","truthStatus":"TRUE_ONLY"}],"schemaVersion":"law.core.evaluation/0.2"},"evaluationStatus":"COMPUTED","issues":[],"judgmentRequests":[],"proofRef":"urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/ProceduralNineFor/query/decision-adopted-procedural","provenance":{"acts":[{"artifactHash":"sha256:1d123a11b4c6e20a0c1042d7d0ae2f6cca7396f20ebd75136836d48735a4b835","namespace":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","package":"un.charter"}],"caseHash":"sha256:1f67054f049ffdc7e642488912ebfd3e0f3d27a06f383220673bf3a4531fb783","jurisdiction":"International","legalTime":"2026-01-01","mode":"audit","programHash":"sha256:53761165015b682383430aa74b59233f973da8e16ffe719420f98edd8b25519d","resultHash":"sha256:fe9c532d0c3705c6cc77d762e5420dfcb2fb09439b5ce60c320aa415b1e43eb7","timezone":"UTC"},"rulesApplied":["urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat","urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#ProceduralDecisionAdopted"]},"execution":{"evaluationBytes":"{\"conflicts\":[],\"issues\":[],\"manifest\":{\"artifactHash\":\"sha256:0767659ce1336a603665167add3678052c57846e4619007a6ccdc6398fcf294e\",\"calendarSnapshot\":\"\",\"caseHash\":\"sha256:1f67054f049ffdc7e642488912ebfd3e0f3d27a06f383220673bf3a4531fb783\",\"decisionTime\":\"2026-01-01T12:00:00Z\",\"evidenceSnapshotHash\":\"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000\",\"externalSnapshots\":{},\"id\":\"urn:manifest:oracle-1\",\"interpretations\":[],\"knowledgeTime\":\"2026-01-01T12:00:00Z\",\"legalTime\":\"2026-01-01\",\"lockfileHash\":\"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000\",\"mode\":\"audit\",\"policies\":{},\"programHash\":\"sha256:53761165015b682383430aa74b59233f973da8e16ffe719420f98edd8b25519d\",\"resolvedEditions\":{},\"semanticHash\":\"sha256:3cf0568970e1a06c5498d2ee5503776286b0db7486adea19f9581089911be5da\",\"semantics\":\"law.core/0.2.1\",\"theoryHash\":\"sha256:53761165015b682383430aa74b59233f973da8e16ffe719420f98edd8b25519d\",\"timezone\":\"UTC\"},\"positions\":[],\"proofGraph\":{\"nodes\":[{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#fr\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#fr\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m0\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m1\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m2\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m3\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m4\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m5\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#procedural\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#procedural_matter\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#procedural\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_adopted\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:ProceduralDecisionAdopted:ecf3ae070b6fea45f81712b543c968f84457703d01a48e0ee9b6564f33a5f615\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#fr\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#procedural\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us\"],\"rule\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#ProceduralDecisionAdopted\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h16351e0bed59b62494f1c5210d0fd5a006de40ee549557096968b0b2c2e81693\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h16351e0bed59b62494f1c5210d0fd5a006de40ee549557096968b0b2c2e81693\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:e6cdd1b41bb6a401a290db8d3f9e0e3e09802f9c184a1edc05d29d0412a6717f\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h16351e0bed59b62494f1c5210d0fd5a006de40ee549557096968b0b2c2e81693\"],\"rule\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h1670ff143db3b3d29021dc7ad7985b349772e84c0b76792a3ee656307d221a85\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h1670ff143db3b3d29021dc7ad7985b349772e84c0b76792a3ee656307d221a85\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:8b78e920fb454ef68cfd4d28faa95e701383a4945549927ddb0e490175215890\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h1670ff143db3b3d29021dc7ad7985b349772e84c0b76792a3ee656307d221a85\"],\"rule\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h2577471a877f419d16417bc8ce7642e21e0eaa2649933f621cead7f558251c22\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h2577471a877f419d16417bc8ce7642e21e0eaa2649933f621cead7f558251c22\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:a2e3e604e9de005e17c81a51ce629be98e8e9e509a506046e0cde52b32321222\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h2577471a877f419d16417bc8ce7642e21e0eaa2649933f621cead7f558251c22\"],\"rule\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h5c5d3b5c9ef348f54b5802f708fcfb08ffdf58f3b19d9f2957124cc18c49ca25\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#RepublicOfChina\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h5c5d3b5c9ef348f54b5802f708fcfb08ffdf58f3b19d9f2957124cc18c49ca25\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#RepublicOfChina\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:4b1a6f6f8748646d22693b4c086f59515bea5071b14cc9f60294942b421440aa\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h5c5d3b5c9ef348f54b5802f708fcfb08ffdf58f3b19d9f2957124cc18c49ca25\"],\"rule\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#RepublicOfChina\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h95b1a57a07a53f49ec8dcbb91c442be4fdf9ca5f19fb2fa7ee84192725768c7a\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h95b1a57a07a53f49ec8dcbb91c442be4fdf9ca5f19fb2fa7ee84192725768c7a\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:ce60c6e3d670f6229c478e6f4fa5860728de789f588132e65e8a1127d110648f\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h95b1a57a07a53f49ec8dcbb91c442be4fdf9ca5f19fb2fa7ee84192725768c7a\"],\"rule\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"literal\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_adopted\"},\"truthStatus\":\"TRUE_ONLY\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/ProceduralNineFor/query/decision-adopted-procedural\",\"kind\":\"query_evaluation\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:ProceduralDecisionAdopted:ecf3ae070b6fea45f81712b543c968f84457703d01a48e0ee9b6564f33a5f615\"],\"sourceAnchors\":[]}],\"proofHash\":\"sha256:d5afcbd4f5ed639e1c852efb8a92b6aa2384178363b432795b76c294e268af0c\",\"roots\":[\"urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/ProceduralNineFor/query/decision-adopted-procedural\"]},\"resultHash\":\"sha256:fe9c532d0c3705c6cc77d762e5420dfcb2fb09439b5ce60c320aa415b1e43eb7\",\"results\":[{\"conflicts\":[],\"evaluationStatus\":\"COMPUTED\",\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:result:same-vote#case/ProceduralNineFor/query/decision-adopted-procedural\",\"judgmentRequests\":[],\"manifest\":\"urn:manifest:oracle-1\",\"missingInputs\":[],\"normativeStatusSupports\":[],\"proof\":\"urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/ProceduralNineFor/query/decision-adopted-procedural\",\"query\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#case/ProceduralNineFor/query/decision-adopted-procedural\",\"resultKind\":\"PROPOSITION\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"target\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_adopted\",\"truthStatus\":\"TRUE_ONLY\"}],\"schemaVersion\":\"law.core.evaluation/0.2\"}","evaluationSha256":"sha256:c2c068235a90267cd658789bf66bdaf7fb277cb5e4b85c113d9b5709b301a27d","request":{"case":{"assertions":[{"contentHash":"sha256:e06e61d7422748fc4a29fea357bbf260d61a6a0e1d22033506728de11ebeecdf","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#procedural","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#procedural_matter"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:835a2784f2e9335ce057e68ca26e6fd46cdefaf893a6668ccc8435093a25ce22","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#fr","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#france","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:fd044c0d27c4272b764622063251f35b52c428f75c82695bea2aaba84010b60d","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:516f618ced41fd2bedcb6bcc72c66e846ac761be34a87ce71e94cbf83d961355","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:aae866ff0556a4168a1ea040f8c1893cc2aab8e62ab1bd16f0c6482671fcbdc6","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:196834658ef37892350f21afb8d650b8d378eab77a316a19c4ba43060e823fae","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:e83f2c95c580a2605896f25cb8f14c403330c50e875b50511f4b0e1a1ac8a59c","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:3357701bb3c195ad49e9202437a3d1a52e5a4f26be5d15c57b4833755bde02b9","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:dbe0ed67e1d2f83bc758fbeece4ca2da754e1046f014484f6ac8b7c8e98016f5","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:7e8a7dc5166e252cf5b9a1ca3062ede63145bac1eb123e1947cbadd900f59928","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:825fcbf9094100876a0401f5b75109de4cd117ce9584f406d35e1fa32104507a","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#su","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#soviet","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#abstains"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"}],"constants":{"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#france":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m0","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m1","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m2","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m3","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m4","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m5","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#soviet":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState","kind":"entity_ref"}},"context":{"decisionTime":"2026-01-01T12:00:00Z","knowledgeTime":"2026-01-01T12:00:00Z","legalTime":"2026-01-01","timezone":"UTC"},"options":{}},"ir":{"irSha256":"sha256:b80968c289f44aa8407d3db4b14414d1a8270bd8ecb49efaf538431149c787a9","kind":"world_ref","nodeCount":713,"packages":[{"artifactHash":"sha256:1d123a11b4c6e20a0c1042d7d0ae2f6cca7396f20ebd75136836d48735a4b835","namespace":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","package":"un.charter","semanticHash":"sha256:b75234dd3b9d08a90304c97ed60d6430f3ce09b4dbce585b52ebf491721efadf"}],"programHash":"sha256:53761165015b682383430aa74b59233f973da8e16ffe719420f98edd8b25519d"},"query":{"kind":"truth","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_adopted"},"queryId":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#case/ProceduralNineFor/query/decision-adopted-procedural"},"semanticVersion":"0.2.1"},"requestCanonicalSha256":"sha256:d4201daff55cb5d1f11dbdec1ab846095cbd18be5f82389d32fe9b21aa5bb8a8","verification":{"matched":true,"method":"law ask: attentes du texte, Rust = Python = rejeu"}},"id":"vote-procedural-adopted","kind":"truth","label":"Procedural vote: the decision is adopted","presentation":{"schemaVersion":"law.answers.presentation/0.1","source":{"requestCanonicalSha256":"sha256:d4201daff55cb5d1f11dbdec1ab846095cbd18be5f82389d32fe9b21aa5bb8a8"},"steps":[{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#fr","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m0","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m1","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m2","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m3","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m4","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m5","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#procedural_matter"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#procedural","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_adopted"},"head":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_adopted"},"id":"urn:proof:apply:ProceduralDecisionAdopted:ecf3ae070b6fea45f81712b543c968f84457703d01a48e0ee9b6564f33a5f615","kind":"rule_application","originStatus":"available","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#fr","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#procedural","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us"],"rule":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#ProceduralDecisionAdopted","sourceAnchors":["urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UNC_EN_ART27"],"strength":"strict","substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"}},"trust":"engine","variables":[{"id":"v0","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#Decision"}}]},{"conclusion":{"literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_adopted"},"truthStatus":"TRUE_ONLY"},"id":"urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/ProceduralNineFor/query/decision-adopted-procedural","kind":"query_evaluation","originStatus":"available","premises":["urn:proof:apply:ProceduralDecisionAdopted:ecf3ae070b6fea45f81712b543c968f84457703d01a48e0ee9b6564f33a5f615"],"trust":"engine"}],"symbols":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#Decision","kind":"type_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"Decision (of the Security Council or the General Assembly)"}],"name":"Decision","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"France State"}],"name":"FranceState","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[],"symbolKind":"constant"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"The letter of Article 23: the five named States hold a permanent seat"}],"package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","strength":"strict"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#ProceduralDecisionAdopted","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"Article 27, paragraph 2. Decisions of the Security Council on procedural matters shall be made by an affirmative vote of nine members."}],"package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","strength":"strict"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#RepublicOfChina","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"Republic Of China"}],"name":"RepublicOfChina","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[],"symbolKind":"constant"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"Soviet Union"}],"name":"SovietUnion","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[],"symbolKind":"constant"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#State","kind":"type_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"State"}],"name":"State","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"United Kingdom State"}],"name":"UnitedKingdomState","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[],"symbolKind":"constant"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"United States State"}],"name":"UnitedStatesState","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[],"symbolKind":"constant"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#abstains","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the State abstains (Art. 27, para. 3)"}],"name":"abstains","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#abstains/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#Decision"}},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#abstains/arg/s","labels":[],"name":"s","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#State"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the State casts a vote in favour (Art. 18, Art. 27)"}],"name":"casts_vote_for","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#Decision"}},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for/arg/s","labels":[],"name":"s","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#State"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_adopted","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"the Security Council decision is adopted"}],"name":"decision_adopted","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_adopted/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#Decision"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"permanent member of the Security Council (Art. 23, para. 1)"}],"name":"permanent_member","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member/arg/s","labels":[],"name":"s","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#State"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"the State holds a permanent seat for voting purposes (letter of Art. 23, or continuity/seat transfer)"}],"name":"permanent_member_seat_held_by","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by/arg/s","labels":[],"name":"s","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#State"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#procedural_matter","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the decision is on a procedural matter (Art. 27, para. 2)"}],"name":"procedural_matter","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#procedural_matter/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#Decision"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"}]},"provenance":{"acts":[{"artifactHash":"sha256:1d123a11b4c6e20a0c1042d7d0ae2f6cca7396f20ebd75136836d48735a4b835","namespace":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","package":"un.charter"}],"caseHash":"sha256:1f67054f049ffdc7e642488912ebfd3e0f3d27a06f383220673bf3a4531fb783","jurisdiction":"International","legalTime":"2026-01-01","mode":"audit","programHash":"sha256:53761165015b682383430aa74b59233f973da8e16ffe719420f98edd8b25519d","resultHash":"sha256:fe9c532d0c3705c6cc77d762e5420dfcb2fb09439b5ce60c320aa415b1e43eb7","timezone":"UTC"},"request":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"}],"facts":[{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#procedural_matter"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#france","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#soviet","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#abstains"}],"kind":"truth","legalTime":"2026-01-01","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_adopted"},"sources":[{"contentHash":"sha256:7b43f3150e9a17e3213539187ddf364d08bfc106551b59bb6f2062c9769bb2c4","edition":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UN_CHARTER_EN","fragmentKind":"article","id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UNC_EN_ART23","kind":"fragment","locator":"article/23","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","texts":[{"contentHash":"sha256:04634bcee8d5f914608d8ed6dce1d8bde70766de1ad6f66aded63661b6cceeb7","language":"en","status":"official","text":"Article 23\nThe Security Council shall consist of fifteen Members of the United Nations. The Republic of China, France, the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics, the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, and the United States of America shall be permanent members of the Security Council. The General Assembly shall elect ten other Members of the United Nations to be non-permanent members of the Security Council, due regard being specially paid, in the first instance to the contribution of Members of the United Nations to the maintenance of international peace and security and to the other purposes of the Organization, and also to equitable geographical distribution.\nThe non-permanent members of the Security Council shall be elected for a term of two years. In the first election of the non-permanent members after the increase of the membership of the Security Council from eleven to fifteen, two of the four additional members shall be chosen for a term of one year. A retiring member shall not be eligible for immediate re-election.\nEach member of the Security Council shall have one representative."}]},{"contentHash":"sha256:d76f30a3ec91422c1506becd5504f2054bd298551bdef3717ebfbb411ee4fda6","edition":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UN_CHARTER_EN","fragmentKind":"article","id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UNC_EN_ART27","kind":"fragment","locator":"article/27","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","texts":[{"contentHash":"sha256:d2e1200a16b6cc23e35a408e6f305c6a42aec1ae602e3202d05006d4577ea403","language":"en","status":"official","text":"Article 27\nEach member of the Security Council shall have one vote.\nDecisions of the Security Council on procedural matters shall be made by an affirmative vote of nine members.\nDecisions of the Security Council on all other matters shall be made by an affirmative vote of nine members including the concurring votes of the permanent members; provided that, in decisions under Chapter VI, and under paragraph 3 of Article 52, a party to a dispute shall abstain from voting."}]}],"text":"Procedural vote: the decision is adopted"},{"answer":{"answer":{"evaluationStatus":"COMPUTED","kind":"TRUTH","missingInputs":[],"truthStatus":"NEITHER"},"evaluation":{"conflicts":[],"issues":[],"manifest":{"artifactHash":"sha256:0767659ce1336a603665167add3678052c57846e4619007a6ccdc6398fcf294e","calendarSnapshot":"","caseHash":"sha256:1f67054f049ffdc7e642488912ebfd3e0f3d27a06f383220673bf3a4531fb783","decisionTime":"2026-01-01T12:00:00Z","evidenceSnapshotHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","externalSnapshots":{},"id":"urn:manifest:oracle-1","interpretations":[],"knowledgeTime":"2026-01-01T12:00:00Z","legalTime":"2026-01-01","lockfileHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","mode":"audit","policies":{},"programHash":"sha256:53761165015b682383430aa74b59233f973da8e16ffe719420f98edd8b25519d","resolvedEditions":{},"semanticHash":"sha256:3cf0568970e1a06c5498d2ee5503776286b0db7486adea19f9581089911be5da","semantics":"law.core/0.2.1","theoryHash":"sha256:53761165015b682383430aa74b59233f973da8e16ffe719420f98edd8b25519d","timezone":"UTC"},"positions":[],"proofGraph":{"nodes":[{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#fr"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#fr","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m0","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m1","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m2","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m3","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m4","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m5","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#procedural"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#procedural_matter"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#procedural","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_adopted"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:ProceduralDecisionAdopted:ecf3ae070b6fea45f81712b543c968f84457703d01a48e0ee9b6564f33a5f615","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#fr","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#procedural","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us"],"rule":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#ProceduralDecisionAdopted","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h16351e0bed59b62494f1c5210d0fd5a006de40ee549557096968b0b2c2e81693"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h16351e0bed59b62494f1c5210d0fd5a006de40ee549557096968b0b2c2e81693","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:e6cdd1b41bb6a401a290db8d3f9e0e3e09802f9c184a1edc05d29d0412a6717f","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h16351e0bed59b62494f1c5210d0fd5a006de40ee549557096968b0b2c2e81693"],"rule":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h1670ff143db3b3d29021dc7ad7985b349772e84c0b76792a3ee656307d221a85"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h1670ff143db3b3d29021dc7ad7985b349772e84c0b76792a3ee656307d221a85","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:8b78e920fb454ef68cfd4d28faa95e701383a4945549927ddb0e490175215890","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h1670ff143db3b3d29021dc7ad7985b349772e84c0b76792a3ee656307d221a85"],"rule":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h2577471a877f419d16417bc8ce7642e21e0eaa2649933f621cead7f558251c22"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h2577471a877f419d16417bc8ce7642e21e0eaa2649933f621cead7f558251c22","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:a2e3e604e9de005e17c81a51ce629be98e8e9e509a506046e0cde52b32321222","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h2577471a877f419d16417bc8ce7642e21e0eaa2649933f621cead7f558251c22"],"rule":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h5c5d3b5c9ef348f54b5802f708fcfb08ffdf58f3b19d9f2957124cc18c49ca25"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#RepublicOfChina","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h5c5d3b5c9ef348f54b5802f708fcfb08ffdf58f3b19d9f2957124cc18c49ca25","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#RepublicOfChina","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:4b1a6f6f8748646d22693b4c086f59515bea5071b14cc9f60294942b421440aa","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h5c5d3b5c9ef348f54b5802f708fcfb08ffdf58f3b19d9f2957124cc18c49ca25"],"rule":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#RepublicOfChina","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h95b1a57a07a53f49ec8dcbb91c442be4fdf9ca5f19fb2fa7ee84192725768c7a"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h95b1a57a07a53f49ec8dcbb91c442be4fdf9ca5f19fb2fa7ee84192725768c7a","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:ce60c6e3d670f6229c478e6f4fa5860728de789f588132e65e8a1127d110648f","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h95b1a57a07a53f49ec8dcbb91c442be4fdf9ca5f19fb2fa7ee84192725768c7a"],"rule":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_blocked_by_permanent_member"},"truthStatus":"NEITHER"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/ProceduralNineFor/query/decision-blocked-procedural","kind":"query_evaluation","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]}],"proofHash":"sha256:8a0e82f6b964cfb75284c7ab5a33d2be651d070189489d21e79491b9ef205e85","roots":["urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/ProceduralNineFor/query/decision-blocked-procedural"]},"resultHash":"sha256:9b2334fae721f0821fdc794f9677fd2e2e9ca11e511d059de4623b785889b3c7","results":[{"conflicts":[],"evaluationStatus":"COMPUTED","evidence":[],"id":"urn:result:same-vote#case/ProceduralNineFor/query/decision-blocked-procedural","judgmentRequests":[],"manifest":"urn:manifest:oracle-1","missingInputs":[],"normativeStatusSupports":[],"proof":"urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/ProceduralNineFor/query/decision-blocked-procedural","query":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#case/ProceduralNineFor/query/decision-blocked-procedural","resultKind":"PROPOSITION","sourceAnchors":[],"target":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_blocked_by_permanent_member","truthStatus":"NEITHER"}],"schemaVersion":"law.core.evaluation/0.2"},"evaluationStatus":"COMPUTED","issues":[],"judgmentRequests":[],"proofRef":"urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/ProceduralNineFor/query/decision-blocked-procedural","provenance":{"acts":[{"artifactHash":"sha256:1d123a11b4c6e20a0c1042d7d0ae2f6cca7396f20ebd75136836d48735a4b835","namespace":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","package":"un.charter"}],"caseHash":"sha256:1f67054f049ffdc7e642488912ebfd3e0f3d27a06f383220673bf3a4531fb783","jurisdiction":"International","legalTime":"2026-01-01","mode":"audit","programHash":"sha256:53761165015b682383430aa74b59233f973da8e16ffe719420f98edd8b25519d","resultHash":"sha256:9b2334fae721f0821fdc794f9677fd2e2e9ca11e511d059de4623b785889b3c7","timezone":"UTC"},"rulesApplied":["urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat","urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#ProceduralDecisionAdopted"]},"execution":{"evaluationBytes":"{\"conflicts\":[],\"issues\":[],\"manifest\":{\"artifactHash\":\"sha256:0767659ce1336a603665167add3678052c57846e4619007a6ccdc6398fcf294e\",\"calendarSnapshot\":\"\",\"caseHash\":\"sha256:1f67054f049ffdc7e642488912ebfd3e0f3d27a06f383220673bf3a4531fb783\",\"decisionTime\":\"2026-01-01T12:00:00Z\",\"evidenceSnapshotHash\":\"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000\",\"externalSnapshots\":{},\"id\":\"urn:manifest:oracle-1\",\"interpretations\":[],\"knowledgeTime\":\"2026-01-01T12:00:00Z\",\"legalTime\":\"2026-01-01\",\"lockfileHash\":\"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000\",\"mode\":\"audit\",\"policies\":{},\"programHash\":\"sha256:53761165015b682383430aa74b59233f973da8e16ffe719420f98edd8b25519d\",\"resolvedEditions\":{},\"semanticHash\":\"sha256:3cf0568970e1a06c5498d2ee5503776286b0db7486adea19f9581089911be5da\",\"semantics\":\"law.core/0.2.1\",\"theoryHash\":\"sha256:53761165015b682383430aa74b59233f973da8e16ffe719420f98edd8b25519d\",\"timezone\":\"UTC\"},\"positions\":[],\"proofGraph\":{\"nodes\":[{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#fr\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#fr\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m0\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m1\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m2\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m3\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m4\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m5\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#procedural\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#procedural_matter\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#procedural\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_adopted\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:ProceduralDecisionAdopted:ecf3ae070b6fea45f81712b543c968f84457703d01a48e0ee9b6564f33a5f615\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#fr\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#procedural\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us\"],\"rule\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#ProceduralDecisionAdopted\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h16351e0bed59b62494f1c5210d0fd5a006de40ee549557096968b0b2c2e81693\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h16351e0bed59b62494f1c5210d0fd5a006de40ee549557096968b0b2c2e81693\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:e6cdd1b41bb6a401a290db8d3f9e0e3e09802f9c184a1edc05d29d0412a6717f\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h16351e0bed59b62494f1c5210d0fd5a006de40ee549557096968b0b2c2e81693\"],\"rule\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h1670ff143db3b3d29021dc7ad7985b349772e84c0b76792a3ee656307d221a85\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h1670ff143db3b3d29021dc7ad7985b349772e84c0b76792a3ee656307d221a85\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:8b78e920fb454ef68cfd4d28faa95e701383a4945549927ddb0e490175215890\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h1670ff143db3b3d29021dc7ad7985b349772e84c0b76792a3ee656307d221a85\"],\"rule\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h2577471a877f419d16417bc8ce7642e21e0eaa2649933f621cead7f558251c22\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h2577471a877f419d16417bc8ce7642e21e0eaa2649933f621cead7f558251c22\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:a2e3e604e9de005e17c81a51ce629be98e8e9e509a506046e0cde52b32321222\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h2577471a877f419d16417bc8ce7642e21e0eaa2649933f621cead7f558251c22\"],\"rule\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h5c5d3b5c9ef348f54b5802f708fcfb08ffdf58f3b19d9f2957124cc18c49ca25\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#RepublicOfChina\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h5c5d3b5c9ef348f54b5802f708fcfb08ffdf58f3b19d9f2957124cc18c49ca25\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#RepublicOfChina\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:4b1a6f6f8748646d22693b4c086f59515bea5071b14cc9f60294942b421440aa\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h5c5d3b5c9ef348f54b5802f708fcfb08ffdf58f3b19d9f2957124cc18c49ca25\"],\"rule\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#RepublicOfChina\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h95b1a57a07a53f49ec8dcbb91c442be4fdf9ca5f19fb2fa7ee84192725768c7a\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h95b1a57a07a53f49ec8dcbb91c442be4fdf9ca5f19fb2fa7ee84192725768c7a\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:ce60c6e3d670f6229c478e6f4fa5860728de789f588132e65e8a1127d110648f\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h95b1a57a07a53f49ec8dcbb91c442be4fdf9ca5f19fb2fa7ee84192725768c7a\"],\"rule\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"literal\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_blocked_by_permanent_member\"},\"truthStatus\":\"NEITHER\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/ProceduralNineFor/query/decision-blocked-procedural\",\"kind\":\"query_evaluation\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]}],\"proofHash\":\"sha256:8a0e82f6b964cfb75284c7ab5a33d2be651d070189489d21e79491b9ef205e85\",\"roots\":[\"urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/ProceduralNineFor/query/decision-blocked-procedural\"]},\"resultHash\":\"sha256:9b2334fae721f0821fdc794f9677fd2e2e9ca11e511d059de4623b785889b3c7\",\"results\":[{\"conflicts\":[],\"evaluationStatus\":\"COMPUTED\",\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:result:same-vote#case/ProceduralNineFor/query/decision-blocked-procedural\",\"judgmentRequests\":[],\"manifest\":\"urn:manifest:oracle-1\",\"missingInputs\":[],\"normativeStatusSupports\":[],\"proof\":\"urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/ProceduralNineFor/query/decision-blocked-procedural\",\"query\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#case/ProceduralNineFor/query/decision-blocked-procedural\",\"resultKind\":\"PROPOSITION\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"target\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_blocked_by_permanent_member\",\"truthStatus\":\"NEITHER\"}],\"schemaVersion\":\"law.core.evaluation/0.2\"}","evaluationSha256":"sha256:69f40ba7bca8da16178dcc56504041865be8a7cb9dc4d17949bf5a72607951c5","request":{"case":{"assertions":[{"contentHash":"sha256:e06e61d7422748fc4a29fea357bbf260d61a6a0e1d22033506728de11ebeecdf","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#procedural","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#procedural_matter"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:835a2784f2e9335ce057e68ca26e6fd46cdefaf893a6668ccc8435093a25ce22","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#fr","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#france","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:fd044c0d27c4272b764622063251f35b52c428f75c82695bea2aaba84010b60d","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:516f618ced41fd2bedcb6bcc72c66e846ac761be34a87ce71e94cbf83d961355","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:aae866ff0556a4168a1ea040f8c1893cc2aab8e62ab1bd16f0c6482671fcbdc6","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:196834658ef37892350f21afb8d650b8d378eab77a316a19c4ba43060e823fae","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:e83f2c95c580a2605896f25cb8f14c403330c50e875b50511f4b0e1a1ac8a59c","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:3357701bb3c195ad49e9202437a3d1a52e5a4f26be5d15c57b4833755bde02b9","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:dbe0ed67e1d2f83bc758fbeece4ca2da754e1046f014484f6ac8b7c8e98016f5","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:7e8a7dc5166e252cf5b9a1ca3062ede63145bac1eb123e1947cbadd900f59928","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:825fcbf9094100876a0401f5b75109de4cd117ce9584f406d35e1fa32104507a","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#su","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#soviet","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#abstains"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"}],"constants":{"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#france":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m0","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m1","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m2","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m3","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m4","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m5","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#soviet":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState","kind":"entity_ref"}},"context":{"decisionTime":"2026-01-01T12:00:00Z","knowledgeTime":"2026-01-01T12:00:00Z","legalTime":"2026-01-01","timezone":"UTC"},"options":{}},"ir":{"irSha256":"sha256:b80968c289f44aa8407d3db4b14414d1a8270bd8ecb49efaf538431149c787a9","kind":"world_ref","nodeCount":713,"packages":[{"artifactHash":"sha256:1d123a11b4c6e20a0c1042d7d0ae2f6cca7396f20ebd75136836d48735a4b835","namespace":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","package":"un.charter","semanticHash":"sha256:b75234dd3b9d08a90304c97ed60d6430f3ce09b4dbce585b52ebf491721efadf"}],"programHash":"sha256:53761165015b682383430aa74b59233f973da8e16ffe719420f98edd8b25519d"},"query":{"kind":"truth","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_blocked_by_permanent_member"},"queryId":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#case/ProceduralNineFor/query/decision-blocked-procedural"},"semanticVersion":"0.2.1"},"requestCanonicalSha256":"sha256:4a8d4b7cf159635e3b5045040d7a80c98a226e03af2576135278e6f4813b05df","verification":{"matched":true,"method":"law ask: attentes du texte, Rust = Python = rejeu"}},"id":"vote-procedural-blocked","kind":"truth","label":"Procedural vote: paragraph 3 does not block it","presentation":{"schemaVersion":"law.answers.presentation/0.1","source":{"requestCanonicalSha256":"sha256:4a8d4b7cf159635e3b5045040d7a80c98a226e03af2576135278e6f4813b05df"},"steps":[{"conclusion":{"literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_blocked_by_permanent_member"},"truthStatus":"NEITHER"},"id":"urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/ProceduralNineFor/query/decision-blocked-procedural","kind":"query_evaluation","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"engine"}],"symbols":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#Decision","kind":"type_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"Decision (of the Security Council or the General Assembly)"}],"name":"Decision","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"France State"}],"name":"FranceState","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[],"symbolKind":"constant"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"The letter of Article 23: the five named States hold a permanent seat"}],"package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","strength":"strict"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#ProceduralDecisionAdopted","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"Article 27, paragraph 2. Decisions of the Security Council on procedural matters shall be made by an affirmative vote of nine members."}],"package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","strength":"strict"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#RepublicOfChina","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"Republic Of China"}],"name":"RepublicOfChina","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[],"symbolKind":"constant"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"Soviet Union"}],"name":"SovietUnion","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[],"symbolKind":"constant"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#State","kind":"type_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"State"}],"name":"State","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"United Kingdom State"}],"name":"UnitedKingdomState","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[],"symbolKind":"constant"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"United States State"}],"name":"UnitedStatesState","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[],"symbolKind":"constant"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#abstains","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the State abstains (Art. 27, para. 3)"}],"name":"abstains","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#abstains/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#Decision"}},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#abstains/arg/s","labels":[],"name":"s","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#State"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the State casts a vote in favour (Art. 18, Art. 27)"}],"name":"casts_vote_for","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#Decision"}},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for/arg/s","labels":[],"name":"s","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#State"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_adopted","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"the Security Council decision is adopted"}],"name":"decision_adopted","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_adopted/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#Decision"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_blocked_by_permanent_member","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"the decision is blocked by a permanent member — by a vote against, or (by the letter) by abstention (Art. 27, para. 3)"}],"name":"decision_blocked_by_permanent_member","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_blocked_by_permanent_member/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#Decision"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"permanent member of the Security Council (Art. 23, para. 1)"}],"name":"permanent_member","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member/arg/s","labels":[],"name":"s","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#State"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"the State holds a permanent seat for voting purposes (letter of Art. 23, or continuity/seat transfer)"}],"name":"permanent_member_seat_held_by","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by/arg/s","labels":[],"name":"s","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#State"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#procedural_matter","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the decision is on a procedural matter (Art. 27, para. 2)"}],"name":"procedural_matter","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#procedural_matter/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#Decision"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"}]},"provenance":{"acts":[{"artifactHash":"sha256:1d123a11b4c6e20a0c1042d7d0ae2f6cca7396f20ebd75136836d48735a4b835","namespace":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","package":"un.charter"}],"caseHash":"sha256:1f67054f049ffdc7e642488912ebfd3e0f3d27a06f383220673bf3a4531fb783","jurisdiction":"International","legalTime":"2026-01-01","mode":"audit","programHash":"sha256:53761165015b682383430aa74b59233f973da8e16ffe719420f98edd8b25519d","resultHash":"sha256:9b2334fae721f0821fdc794f9677fd2e2e9ca11e511d059de4623b785889b3c7","timezone":"UTC"},"request":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:procedural","kind":"entity_ref"}],"facts":[{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#procedural_matter"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#france","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#soviet","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#abstains"}],"kind":"truth","legalTime":"2026-01-01","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_blocked_by_permanent_member"},"sources":[{"contentHash":"sha256:7b43f3150e9a17e3213539187ddf364d08bfc106551b59bb6f2062c9769bb2c4","edition":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UN_CHARTER_EN","fragmentKind":"article","id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UNC_EN_ART23","kind":"fragment","locator":"article/23","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","texts":[{"contentHash":"sha256:04634bcee8d5f914608d8ed6dce1d8bde70766de1ad6f66aded63661b6cceeb7","language":"en","status":"official","text":"Article 23\nThe Security Council shall consist of fifteen Members of the United Nations. The Republic of China, France, the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics, the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, and the United States of America shall be permanent members of the Security Council. The General Assembly shall elect ten other Members of the United Nations to be non-permanent members of the Security Council, due regard being specially paid, in the first instance to the contribution of Members of the United Nations to the maintenance of international peace and security and to the other purposes of the Organization, and also to equitable geographical distribution.\nThe non-permanent members of the Security Council shall be elected for a term of two years. In the first election of the non-permanent members after the increase of the membership of the Security Council from eleven to fifteen, two of the four additional members shall be chosen for a term of one year. A retiring member shall not be eligible for immediate re-election.\nEach member of the Security Council shall have one representative."}]},{"contentHash":"sha256:d76f30a3ec91422c1506becd5504f2054bd298551bdef3717ebfbb411ee4fda6","edition":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UN_CHARTER_EN","fragmentKind":"article","id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UNC_EN_ART27","kind":"fragment","locator":"article/27","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","texts":[{"contentHash":"sha256:d2e1200a16b6cc23e35a408e6f305c6a42aec1ae602e3202d05006d4577ea403","language":"en","status":"official","text":"Article 27\nEach member of the Security Council shall have one vote.\nDecisions of the Security Council on procedural matters shall be made by an affirmative vote of nine members.\nDecisions of the Security Council on all other matters shall be made by an affirmative vote of nine members including the concurring votes of the permanent members; provided that, in decisions under Chapter VI, and under paragraph 3 of Article 52, a party to a dispute shall abstain from voting."}]}],"text":"Procedural vote: paragraph 3 does not block it"},{"answer":{"answer":{"evaluationStatus":"COMPUTED","kind":"TRUTH","missingInputs":[],"truthStatus":"NEITHER"},"evaluation":{"conflicts":[],"issues":[],"manifest":{"artifactHash":"sha256:0767659ce1336a603665167add3678052c57846e4619007a6ccdc6398fcf294e","calendarSnapshot":"","caseHash":"sha256:d95df12017d0aa072cb5bf5e1506fad463a05c883c87659a486ffdbaf4dc5d7a","decisionTime":"2026-01-01T12:00:00Z","evidenceSnapshotHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","externalSnapshots":{},"id":"urn:manifest:oracle-1","interpretations":[],"knowledgeTime":"2026-01-01T12:00:00Z","legalTime":"2026-01-01","lockfileHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","mode":"audit","policies":{},"programHash":"sha256:53761165015b682383430aa74b59233f973da8e16ffe719420f98edd8b25519d","resolvedEditions":{},"semanticHash":"sha256:f471ac863dae5c0222bd0979e799fb42017696c6c07edc3877c8bf7db88daaac","semantics":"law.core/0.2.1","theoryHash":"sha256:53761165015b682383430aa74b59233f973da8e16ffe719420f98edd8b25519d","timezone":"UTC"},"positions":[],"proofGraph":{"nodes":[{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#non-proc"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#is_non_procedural_matter"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#non-proc","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#su"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#abstains"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#su","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h16351e0bed59b62494f1c5210d0fd5a006de40ee549557096968b0b2c2e81693"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h16351e0bed59b62494f1c5210d0fd5a006de40ee549557096968b0b2c2e81693","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:e6cdd1b41bb6a401a290db8d3f9e0e3e09802f9c184a1edc05d29d0412a6717f","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h16351e0bed59b62494f1c5210d0fd5a006de40ee549557096968b0b2c2e81693"],"rule":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h1670ff143db3b3d29021dc7ad7985b349772e84c0b76792a3ee656307d221a85"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h1670ff143db3b3d29021dc7ad7985b349772e84c0b76792a3ee656307d221a85","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:8b78e920fb454ef68cfd4d28faa95e701383a4945549927ddb0e490175215890","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h1670ff143db3b3d29021dc7ad7985b349772e84c0b76792a3ee656307d221a85"],"rule":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_blocked_by_permanent_member"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:NonProceduralDecisionBlockedByPermanentMemberLetter:bf65aceb906673e4044d5f01873bd363ecc08a4dbd3f91a2fa9c1c48b768916e","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:8b78e920fb454ef68cfd4d28faa95e701383a4945549927ddb0e490175215890","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#non-proc","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#su"],"rule":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#NonProceduralDecisionBlockedByPermanentMemberLetter","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h2577471a877f419d16417bc8ce7642e21e0eaa2649933f621cead7f558251c22"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h2577471a877f419d16417bc8ce7642e21e0eaa2649933f621cead7f558251c22","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:a2e3e604e9de005e17c81a51ce629be98e8e9e509a506046e0cde52b32321222","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h2577471a877f419d16417bc8ce7642e21e0eaa2649933f621cead7f558251c22"],"rule":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h5c5d3b5c9ef348f54b5802f708fcfb08ffdf58f3b19d9f2957124cc18c49ca25"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#RepublicOfChina","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h5c5d3b5c9ef348f54b5802f708fcfb08ffdf58f3b19d9f2957124cc18c49ca25","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#RepublicOfChina","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:4b1a6f6f8748646d22693b4c086f59515bea5071b14cc9f60294942b421440aa","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h5c5d3b5c9ef348f54b5802f708fcfb08ffdf58f3b19d9f2957124cc18c49ca25"],"rule":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#RepublicOfChina","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h95b1a57a07a53f49ec8dcbb91c442be4fdf9ca5f19fb2fa7ee84192725768c7a"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h95b1a57a07a53f49ec8dcbb91c442be4fdf9ca5f19fb2fa7ee84192725768c7a","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:ce60c6e3d670f6229c478e6f4fa5860728de789f588132e65e8a1127d110648f","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h95b1a57a07a53f49ec8dcbb91c442be4fdf9ca5f19fb2fa7ee84192725768c7a"],"rule":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_adopted"},"truthStatus":"NEITHER"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/AbstentionLetter/query/decision-adopted-abstention","kind":"query_evaluation","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]}],"proofHash":"sha256:b1fd58dd38871108fd422deec14f97d9b144062c29a7e8f8c3af6e5be2415508","roots":["urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/AbstentionLetter/query/decision-adopted-abstention"]},"resultHash":"sha256:b10f1395f2895d50b70e11a83da4c2f3d5d02d9765f8a8b8b716d90f5ed81ba3","results":[{"conflicts":[],"evaluationStatus":"COMPUTED","evidence":[],"id":"urn:result:same-vote#case/AbstentionLetter/query/decision-adopted-abstention","judgmentRequests":[],"manifest":"urn:manifest:oracle-1","missingInputs":[],"normativeStatusSupports":[],"proof":"urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/AbstentionLetter/query/decision-adopted-abstention","query":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#case/AbstentionLetter/query/decision-adopted-abstention","resultKind":"PROPOSITION","sourceAnchors":[],"target":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_adopted","truthStatus":"NEITHER"}],"schemaVersion":"law.core.evaluation/0.2"},"evaluationStatus":"COMPUTED","issues":[],"judgmentRequests":[],"proofRef":"urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/AbstentionLetter/query/decision-adopted-abstention","provenance":{"acts":[{"artifactHash":"sha256:1d123a11b4c6e20a0c1042d7d0ae2f6cca7396f20ebd75136836d48735a4b835","namespace":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","package":"un.charter"}],"caseHash":"sha256:d95df12017d0aa072cb5bf5e1506fad463a05c883c87659a486ffdbaf4dc5d7a","jurisdiction":"International","legalTime":"2026-01-01","mode":"audit","programHash":"sha256:53761165015b682383430aa74b59233f973da8e16ffe719420f98edd8b25519d","resultHash":"sha256:b10f1395f2895d50b70e11a83da4c2f3d5d02d9765f8a8b8b716d90f5ed81ba3","timezone":"UTC"},"rulesApplied":["urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat","urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#NonProceduralDecisionBlockedByPermanentMemberLetter"]},"execution":{"evaluationBytes":"{\"conflicts\":[],\"issues\":[],\"manifest\":{\"artifactHash\":\"sha256:0767659ce1336a603665167add3678052c57846e4619007a6ccdc6398fcf294e\",\"calendarSnapshot\":\"\",\"caseHash\":\"sha256:d95df12017d0aa072cb5bf5e1506fad463a05c883c87659a486ffdbaf4dc5d7a\",\"decisionTime\":\"2026-01-01T12:00:00Z\",\"evidenceSnapshotHash\":\"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000\",\"externalSnapshots\":{},\"id\":\"urn:manifest:oracle-1\",\"interpretations\":[],\"knowledgeTime\":\"2026-01-01T12:00:00Z\",\"legalTime\":\"2026-01-01\",\"lockfileHash\":\"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000\",\"mode\":\"audit\",\"policies\":{},\"programHash\":\"sha256:53761165015b682383430aa74b59233f973da8e16ffe719420f98edd8b25519d\",\"resolvedEditions\":{},\"semanticHash\":\"sha256:f471ac863dae5c0222bd0979e799fb42017696c6c07edc3877c8bf7db88daaac\",\"semantics\":\"law.core/0.2.1\",\"theoryHash\":\"sha256:53761165015b682383430aa74b59233f973da8e16ffe719420f98edd8b25519d\",\"timezone\":\"UTC\"},\"positions\":[],\"proofGraph\":{\"nodes\":[{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#non-proc\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#is_non_procedural_matter\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#non-proc\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#su\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#abstains\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#su\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h16351e0bed59b62494f1c5210d0fd5a006de40ee549557096968b0b2c2e81693\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h16351e0bed59b62494f1c5210d0fd5a006de40ee549557096968b0b2c2e81693\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:e6cdd1b41bb6a401a290db8d3f9e0e3e09802f9c184a1edc05d29d0412a6717f\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h16351e0bed59b62494f1c5210d0fd5a006de40ee549557096968b0b2c2e81693\"],\"rule\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h1670ff143db3b3d29021dc7ad7985b349772e84c0b76792a3ee656307d221a85\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h1670ff143db3b3d29021dc7ad7985b349772e84c0b76792a3ee656307d221a85\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:8b78e920fb454ef68cfd4d28faa95e701383a4945549927ddb0e490175215890\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h1670ff143db3b3d29021dc7ad7985b349772e84c0b76792a3ee656307d221a85\"],\"rule\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_blocked_by_permanent_member\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:NonProceduralDecisionBlockedByPermanentMemberLetter:bf65aceb906673e4044d5f01873bd363ecc08a4dbd3f91a2fa9c1c48b768916e\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:8b78e920fb454ef68cfd4d28faa95e701383a4945549927ddb0e490175215890\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#non-proc\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#su\"],\"rule\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#NonProceduralDecisionBlockedByPermanentMemberLetter\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h2577471a877f419d16417bc8ce7642e21e0eaa2649933f621cead7f558251c22\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h2577471a877f419d16417bc8ce7642e21e0eaa2649933f621cead7f558251c22\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:a2e3e604e9de005e17c81a51ce629be98e8e9e509a506046e0cde52b32321222\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h2577471a877f419d16417bc8ce7642e21e0eaa2649933f621cead7f558251c22\"],\"rule\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h5c5d3b5c9ef348f54b5802f708fcfb08ffdf58f3b19d9f2957124cc18c49ca25\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#RepublicOfChina\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h5c5d3b5c9ef348f54b5802f708fcfb08ffdf58f3b19d9f2957124cc18c49ca25\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#RepublicOfChina\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:4b1a6f6f8748646d22693b4c086f59515bea5071b14cc9f60294942b421440aa\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h5c5d3b5c9ef348f54b5802f708fcfb08ffdf58f3b19d9f2957124cc18c49ca25\"],\"rule\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#RepublicOfChina\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h95b1a57a07a53f49ec8dcbb91c442be4fdf9ca5f19fb2fa7ee84192725768c7a\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h95b1a57a07a53f49ec8dcbb91c442be4fdf9ca5f19fb2fa7ee84192725768c7a\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:ce60c6e3d670f6229c478e6f4fa5860728de789f588132e65e8a1127d110648f\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h95b1a57a07a53f49ec8dcbb91c442be4fdf9ca5f19fb2fa7ee84192725768c7a\"],\"rule\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"literal\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_adopted\"},\"truthStatus\":\"NEITHER\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/AbstentionLetter/query/decision-adopted-abstention\",\"kind\":\"query_evaluation\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]}],\"proofHash\":\"sha256:b1fd58dd38871108fd422deec14f97d9b144062c29a7e8f8c3af6e5be2415508\",\"roots\":[\"urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/AbstentionLetter/query/decision-adopted-abstention\"]},\"resultHash\":\"sha256:b10f1395f2895d50b70e11a83da4c2f3d5d02d9765f8a8b8b716d90f5ed81ba3\",\"results\":[{\"conflicts\":[],\"evaluationStatus\":\"COMPUTED\",\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:result:same-vote#case/AbstentionLetter/query/decision-adopted-abstention\",\"judgmentRequests\":[],\"manifest\":\"urn:manifest:oracle-1\",\"missingInputs\":[],\"normativeStatusSupports\":[],\"proof\":\"urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/AbstentionLetter/query/decision-adopted-abstention\",\"query\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#case/AbstentionLetter/query/decision-adopted-abstention\",\"resultKind\":\"PROPOSITION\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"target\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_adopted\",\"truthStatus\":\"NEITHER\"}],\"schemaVersion\":\"law.core.evaluation/0.2\"}","evaluationSha256":"sha256:86bcd3b0ae987d160428c92424784426d4f904db5b32ca662c60d07dae9bb874","request":{"case":{"assertions":[{"contentHash":"sha256:e55a70592f54b05444ddecdcbc60a7c5f636167b8c1344529b0b6f41ebf54d35","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#non-proc","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#is_non_procedural_matter"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:835a2784f2e9335ce057e68ca26e6fd46cdefaf893a6668ccc8435093a25ce22","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#fr","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#france","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:fd044c0d27c4272b764622063251f35b52c428f75c82695bea2aaba84010b60d","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:516f618ced41fd2bedcb6bcc72c66e846ac761be34a87ce71e94cbf83d961355","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:aae866ff0556a4168a1ea040f8c1893cc2aab8e62ab1bd16f0c6482671fcbdc6","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:196834658ef37892350f21afb8d650b8d378eab77a316a19c4ba43060e823fae","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:e83f2c95c580a2605896f25cb8f14c403330c50e875b50511f4b0e1a1ac8a59c","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:3357701bb3c195ad49e9202437a3d1a52e5a4f26be5d15c57b4833755bde02b9","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:dbe0ed67e1d2f83bc758fbeece4ca2da754e1046f014484f6ac8b7c8e98016f5","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:7e8a7dc5166e252cf5b9a1ca3062ede63145bac1eb123e1947cbadd900f59928","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:825fcbf9094100876a0401f5b75109de4cd117ce9584f406d35e1fa32104507a","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#su","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#soviet","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#abstains"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"}],"constants":{"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#france":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m0","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m1","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m2","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m3","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m4","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m5","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#soviet":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState","kind":"entity_ref"}},"context":{"decisionTime":"2026-01-01T12:00:00Z","knowledgeTime":"2026-01-01T12:00:00Z","legalTime":"2026-01-01","timezone":"UTC"},"options":{}},"ir":{"irSha256":"sha256:b80968c289f44aa8407d3db4b14414d1a8270bd8ecb49efaf538431149c787a9","kind":"world_ref","nodeCount":713,"packages":[{"artifactHash":"sha256:1d123a11b4c6e20a0c1042d7d0ae2f6cca7396f20ebd75136836d48735a4b835","namespace":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","package":"un.charter","semanticHash":"sha256:b75234dd3b9d08a90304c97ed60d6430f3ce09b4dbce585b52ebf491721efadf"}],"programHash":"sha256:53761165015b682383430aa74b59233f973da8e16ffe719420f98edd8b25519d"},"query":{"kind":"truth","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_adopted"},"queryId":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#case/AbstentionLetter/query/decision-adopted-abstention"},"semanticVersion":"0.2.1"},"requestCanonicalSha256":"sha256:1118dbfdf5da3fe306e76c9297324c4a7d9ae4c48e58e5f6e9d1d7ab9ba4e985","verification":{"matched":true,"method":"law ask: attentes du texte, Rust = Python = rejeu"}},"id":"vote-letter-adopted","kind":"truth","label":"Letter of article 27(3): adoption is not established","presentation":{"schemaVersion":"law.answers.presentation/0.1","source":{"requestCanonicalSha256":"sha256:1118dbfdf5da3fe306e76c9297324c4a7d9ae4c48e58e5f6e9d1d7ab9ba4e985"},"steps":[{"conclusion":{"literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_adopted"},"truthStatus":"NEITHER"},"id":"urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/AbstentionLetter/query/decision-adopted-abstention","kind":"query_evaluation","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"engine"}],"symbols":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#Decision","kind":"type_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"Decision (of the Security Council or the General Assembly)"}],"name":"Decision","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"France State"}],"name":"FranceState","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[],"symbolKind":"constant"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"The letter of Article 23: the five named States hold a permanent seat"}],"package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","strength":"strict"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#NonProceduralDecisionBlockedByPermanentMemberLetter","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"Article 27, paragraph 3 (the letter, negative side). A permanent member that votes against or abstains does not give a concurring vote."}],"package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","strength":"strict"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#RepublicOfChina","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"Republic Of China"}],"name":"RepublicOfChina","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[],"symbolKind":"constant"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"Soviet Union"}],"name":"SovietUnion","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[],"symbolKind":"constant"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#State","kind":"type_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"State"}],"name":"State","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"United Kingdom State"}],"name":"UnitedKingdomState","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[],"symbolKind":"constant"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"United States State"}],"name":"UnitedStatesState","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[],"symbolKind":"constant"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#abstains","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the State abstains (Art. 27, para. 3)"}],"name":"abstains","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#abstains/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#Decision"}},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#abstains/arg/s","labels":[],"name":"s","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#State"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the State casts a vote in favour (Art. 18, Art. 27)"}],"name":"casts_vote_for","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#Decision"}},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for/arg/s","labels":[],"name":"s","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#State"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_adopted","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"the Security Council decision is adopted"}],"name":"decision_adopted","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_adopted/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#Decision"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_blocked_by_permanent_member","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"the decision is blocked by a permanent member — by a vote against, or (by the letter) by abstention (Art. 27, para. 3)"}],"name":"decision_blocked_by_permanent_member","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_blocked_by_permanent_member/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#Decision"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#is_non_procedural_matter","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the decision is not on a procedural matter (Art. 27, para. 3)"}],"name":"is_non_procedural_matter","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#is_non_procedural_matter/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#Decision"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"permanent member of the Security Council (Art. 23, para. 1)"}],"name":"permanent_member","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member/arg/s","labels":[],"name":"s","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#State"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"the State holds a permanent seat for voting purposes (letter of Art. 23, or continuity/seat transfer)"}],"name":"permanent_member_seat_held_by","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by/arg/s","labels":[],"name":"s","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#State"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"}]},"provenance":{"acts":[{"artifactHash":"sha256:1d123a11b4c6e20a0c1042d7d0ae2f6cca7396f20ebd75136836d48735a4b835","namespace":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","package":"un.charter"}],"caseHash":"sha256:d95df12017d0aa072cb5bf5e1506fad463a05c883c87659a486ffdbaf4dc5d7a","jurisdiction":"International","legalTime":"2026-01-01","mode":"audit","programHash":"sha256:53761165015b682383430aa74b59233f973da8e16ffe719420f98edd8b25519d","resultHash":"sha256:b10f1395f2895d50b70e11a83da4c2f3d5d02d9765f8a8b8b716d90f5ed81ba3","timezone":"UTC"},"request":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"}],"facts":[{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#is_non_procedural_matter"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#france","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#soviet","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#abstains"}],"kind":"truth","legalTime":"2026-01-01","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_adopted"},"sources":[{"contentHash":"sha256:7b43f3150e9a17e3213539187ddf364d08bfc106551b59bb6f2062c9769bb2c4","edition":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UN_CHARTER_EN","fragmentKind":"article","id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UNC_EN_ART23","kind":"fragment","locator":"article/23","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","texts":[{"contentHash":"sha256:04634bcee8d5f914608d8ed6dce1d8bde70766de1ad6f66aded63661b6cceeb7","language":"en","status":"official","text":"Article 23\nThe Security Council shall consist of fifteen Members of the United Nations. The Republic of China, France, the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics, the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, and the United States of America shall be permanent members of the Security Council. The General Assembly shall elect ten other Members of the United Nations to be non-permanent members of the Security Council, due regard being specially paid, in the first instance to the contribution of Members of the United Nations to the maintenance of international peace and security and to the other purposes of the Organization, and also to equitable geographical distribution.\nThe non-permanent members of the Security Council shall be elected for a term of two years. In the first election of the non-permanent members after the increase of the membership of the Security Council from eleven to fifteen, two of the four additional members shall be chosen for a term of one year. A retiring member shall not be eligible for immediate re-election.\nEach member of the Security Council shall have one representative."}]},{"contentHash":"sha256:d76f30a3ec91422c1506becd5504f2054bd298551bdef3717ebfbb411ee4fda6","edition":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UN_CHARTER_EN","fragmentKind":"article","id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UNC_EN_ART27","kind":"fragment","locator":"article/27","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","texts":[{"contentHash":"sha256:d2e1200a16b6cc23e35a408e6f305c6a42aec1ae602e3202d05006d4577ea403","language":"en","status":"official","text":"Article 27\nEach member of the Security Council shall have one vote.\nDecisions of the Security Council on procedural matters shall be made by an affirmative vote of nine members.\nDecisions of the Security Council on all other matters shall be made by an affirmative vote of nine members including the concurring votes of the permanent members; provided that, in decisions under Chapter VI, and under paragraph 3 of Article 52, a party to a dispute shall abstain from voting."}]}],"text":"Letter of article 27(3): adoption is not established"},{"answer":{"answer":{"evaluationStatus":"COMPUTED","kind":"TRUTH","missingInputs":[],"truthStatus":"TRUE_ONLY"},"evaluation":{"conflicts":[],"issues":[],"manifest":{"artifactHash":"sha256:0767659ce1336a603665167add3678052c57846e4619007a6ccdc6398fcf294e","calendarSnapshot":"","caseHash":"sha256:d95df12017d0aa072cb5bf5e1506fad463a05c883c87659a486ffdbaf4dc5d7a","decisionTime":"2026-01-01T12:00:00Z","evidenceSnapshotHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","externalSnapshots":{},"id":"urn:manifest:oracle-1","interpretations":[],"knowledgeTime":"2026-01-01T12:00:00Z","legalTime":"2026-01-01","lockfileHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","mode":"audit","policies":{},"programHash":"sha256:53761165015b682383430aa74b59233f973da8e16ffe719420f98edd8b25519d","resolvedEditions":{},"semanticHash":"sha256:f471ac863dae5c0222bd0979e799fb42017696c6c07edc3877c8bf7db88daaac","semantics":"law.core/0.2.1","theoryHash":"sha256:53761165015b682383430aa74b59233f973da8e16ffe719420f98edd8b25519d","timezone":"UTC"},"positions":[],"proofGraph":{"nodes":[{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#non-proc"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#is_non_procedural_matter"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#non-proc","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#su"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#abstains"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#su","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h16351e0bed59b62494f1c5210d0fd5a006de40ee549557096968b0b2c2e81693"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h16351e0bed59b62494f1c5210d0fd5a006de40ee549557096968b0b2c2e81693","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:e6cdd1b41bb6a401a290db8d3f9e0e3e09802f9c184a1edc05d29d0412a6717f","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h16351e0bed59b62494f1c5210d0fd5a006de40ee549557096968b0b2c2e81693"],"rule":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h1670ff143db3b3d29021dc7ad7985b349772e84c0b76792a3ee656307d221a85"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h1670ff143db3b3d29021dc7ad7985b349772e84c0b76792a3ee656307d221a85","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:8b78e920fb454ef68cfd4d28faa95e701383a4945549927ddb0e490175215890","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h1670ff143db3b3d29021dc7ad7985b349772e84c0b76792a3ee656307d221a85"],"rule":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_blocked_by_permanent_member"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:NonProceduralDecisionBlockedByPermanentMemberLetter:bf65aceb906673e4044d5f01873bd363ecc08a4dbd3f91a2fa9c1c48b768916e","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:8b78e920fb454ef68cfd4d28faa95e701383a4945549927ddb0e490175215890","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#non-proc","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#su"],"rule":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#NonProceduralDecisionBlockedByPermanentMemberLetter","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h2577471a877f419d16417bc8ce7642e21e0eaa2649933f621cead7f558251c22"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h2577471a877f419d16417bc8ce7642e21e0eaa2649933f621cead7f558251c22","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:a2e3e604e9de005e17c81a51ce629be98e8e9e509a506046e0cde52b32321222","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h2577471a877f419d16417bc8ce7642e21e0eaa2649933f621cead7f558251c22"],"rule":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h5c5d3b5c9ef348f54b5802f708fcfb08ffdf58f3b19d9f2957124cc18c49ca25"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#RepublicOfChina","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h5c5d3b5c9ef348f54b5802f708fcfb08ffdf58f3b19d9f2957124cc18c49ca25","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#RepublicOfChina","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:4b1a6f6f8748646d22693b4c086f59515bea5071b14cc9f60294942b421440aa","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h5c5d3b5c9ef348f54b5802f708fcfb08ffdf58f3b19d9f2957124cc18c49ca25"],"rule":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#RepublicOfChina","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h95b1a57a07a53f49ec8dcbb91c442be4fdf9ca5f19fb2fa7ee84192725768c7a"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h95b1a57a07a53f49ec8dcbb91c442be4fdf9ca5f19fb2fa7ee84192725768c7a","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:ce60c6e3d670f6229c478e6f4fa5860728de789f588132e65e8a1127d110648f","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h95b1a57a07a53f49ec8dcbb91c442be4fdf9ca5f19fb2fa7ee84192725768c7a"],"rule":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_blocked_by_permanent_member"},"truthStatus":"TRUE_ONLY"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/AbstentionLetter/query/decision-blocked-abstention","kind":"query_evaluation","premises":["urn:proof:apply:NonProceduralDecisionBlockedByPermanentMemberLetter:bf65aceb906673e4044d5f01873bd363ecc08a4dbd3f91a2fa9c1c48b768916e"],"sourceAnchors":[]}],"proofHash":"sha256:4809be5cb9bf60d2534c89dc04ea0239d9b727b2e97b177dc85be8530e875ec2","roots":["urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/AbstentionLetter/query/decision-blocked-abstention"]},"resultHash":"sha256:8caef5da5d50dfce96bf64f0bd1198ee75747019fc984ee77ae14987fbc6e4e1","results":[{"conflicts":[],"evaluationStatus":"COMPUTED","evidence":[],"id":"urn:result:same-vote#case/AbstentionLetter/query/decision-blocked-abstention","judgmentRequests":[],"manifest":"urn:manifest:oracle-1","missingInputs":[],"normativeStatusSupports":[],"proof":"urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/AbstentionLetter/query/decision-blocked-abstention","query":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#case/AbstentionLetter/query/decision-blocked-abstention","resultKind":"PROPOSITION","sourceAnchors":[],"target":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_blocked_by_permanent_member","truthStatus":"TRUE_ONLY"}],"schemaVersion":"law.core.evaluation/0.2"},"evaluationStatus":"COMPUTED","issues":[],"judgmentRequests":[],"proofRef":"urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/AbstentionLetter/query/decision-blocked-abstention","provenance":{"acts":[{"artifactHash":"sha256:1d123a11b4c6e20a0c1042d7d0ae2f6cca7396f20ebd75136836d48735a4b835","namespace":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","package":"un.charter"}],"caseHash":"sha256:d95df12017d0aa072cb5bf5e1506fad463a05c883c87659a486ffdbaf4dc5d7a","jurisdiction":"International","legalTime":"2026-01-01","mode":"audit","programHash":"sha256:53761165015b682383430aa74b59233f973da8e16ffe719420f98edd8b25519d","resultHash":"sha256:8caef5da5d50dfce96bf64f0bd1198ee75747019fc984ee77ae14987fbc6e4e1","timezone":"UTC"},"rulesApplied":["urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat","urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#NonProceduralDecisionBlockedByPermanentMemberLetter"]},"execution":{"evaluationBytes":"{\"conflicts\":[],\"issues\":[],\"manifest\":{\"artifactHash\":\"sha256:0767659ce1336a603665167add3678052c57846e4619007a6ccdc6398fcf294e\",\"calendarSnapshot\":\"\",\"caseHash\":\"sha256:d95df12017d0aa072cb5bf5e1506fad463a05c883c87659a486ffdbaf4dc5d7a\",\"decisionTime\":\"2026-01-01T12:00:00Z\",\"evidenceSnapshotHash\":\"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000\",\"externalSnapshots\":{},\"id\":\"urn:manifest:oracle-1\",\"interpretations\":[],\"knowledgeTime\":\"2026-01-01T12:00:00Z\",\"legalTime\":\"2026-01-01\",\"lockfileHash\":\"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000\",\"mode\":\"audit\",\"policies\":{},\"programHash\":\"sha256:53761165015b682383430aa74b59233f973da8e16ffe719420f98edd8b25519d\",\"resolvedEditions\":{},\"semanticHash\":\"sha256:f471ac863dae5c0222bd0979e799fb42017696c6c07edc3877c8bf7db88daaac\",\"semantics\":\"law.core/0.2.1\",\"theoryHash\":\"sha256:53761165015b682383430aa74b59233f973da8e16ffe719420f98edd8b25519d\",\"timezone\":\"UTC\"},\"positions\":[],\"proofGraph\":{\"nodes\":[{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#non-proc\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#is_non_procedural_matter\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#non-proc\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#su\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#abstains\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#su\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h16351e0bed59b62494f1c5210d0fd5a006de40ee549557096968b0b2c2e81693\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h16351e0bed59b62494f1c5210d0fd5a006de40ee549557096968b0b2c2e81693\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:e6cdd1b41bb6a401a290db8d3f9e0e3e09802f9c184a1edc05d29d0412a6717f\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h16351e0bed59b62494f1c5210d0fd5a006de40ee549557096968b0b2c2e81693\"],\"rule\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h1670ff143db3b3d29021dc7ad7985b349772e84c0b76792a3ee656307d221a85\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h1670ff143db3b3d29021dc7ad7985b349772e84c0b76792a3ee656307d221a85\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:8b78e920fb454ef68cfd4d28faa95e701383a4945549927ddb0e490175215890\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h1670ff143db3b3d29021dc7ad7985b349772e84c0b76792a3ee656307d221a85\"],\"rule\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_blocked_by_permanent_member\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:NonProceduralDecisionBlockedByPermanentMemberLetter:bf65aceb906673e4044d5f01873bd363ecc08a4dbd3f91a2fa9c1c48b768916e\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:8b78e920fb454ef68cfd4d28faa95e701383a4945549927ddb0e490175215890\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#non-proc\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#su\"],\"rule\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#NonProceduralDecisionBlockedByPermanentMemberLetter\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h2577471a877f419d16417bc8ce7642e21e0eaa2649933f621cead7f558251c22\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h2577471a877f419d16417bc8ce7642e21e0eaa2649933f621cead7f558251c22\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:a2e3e604e9de005e17c81a51ce629be98e8e9e509a506046e0cde52b32321222\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h2577471a877f419d16417bc8ce7642e21e0eaa2649933f621cead7f558251c22\"],\"rule\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h5c5d3b5c9ef348f54b5802f708fcfb08ffdf58f3b19d9f2957124cc18c49ca25\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#RepublicOfChina\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h5c5d3b5c9ef348f54b5802f708fcfb08ffdf58f3b19d9f2957124cc18c49ca25\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#RepublicOfChina\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:4b1a6f6f8748646d22693b4c086f59515bea5071b14cc9f60294942b421440aa\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h5c5d3b5c9ef348f54b5802f708fcfb08ffdf58f3b19d9f2957124cc18c49ca25\"],\"rule\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#RepublicOfChina\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h95b1a57a07a53f49ec8dcbb91c442be4fdf9ca5f19fb2fa7ee84192725768c7a\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h95b1a57a07a53f49ec8dcbb91c442be4fdf9ca5f19fb2fa7ee84192725768c7a\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:ce60c6e3d670f6229c478e6f4fa5860728de789f588132e65e8a1127d110648f\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h95b1a57a07a53f49ec8dcbb91c442be4fdf9ca5f19fb2fa7ee84192725768c7a\"],\"rule\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"literal\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_blocked_by_permanent_member\"},\"truthStatus\":\"TRUE_ONLY\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/AbstentionLetter/query/decision-blocked-abstention\",\"kind\":\"query_evaluation\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:NonProceduralDecisionBlockedByPermanentMemberLetter:bf65aceb906673e4044d5f01873bd363ecc08a4dbd3f91a2fa9c1c48b768916e\"],\"sourceAnchors\":[]}],\"proofHash\":\"sha256:4809be5cb9bf60d2534c89dc04ea0239d9b727b2e97b177dc85be8530e875ec2\",\"roots\":[\"urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/AbstentionLetter/query/decision-blocked-abstention\"]},\"resultHash\":\"sha256:8caef5da5d50dfce96bf64f0bd1198ee75747019fc984ee77ae14987fbc6e4e1\",\"results\":[{\"conflicts\":[],\"evaluationStatus\":\"COMPUTED\",\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:result:same-vote#case/AbstentionLetter/query/decision-blocked-abstention\",\"judgmentRequests\":[],\"manifest\":\"urn:manifest:oracle-1\",\"missingInputs\":[],\"normativeStatusSupports\":[],\"proof\":\"urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/AbstentionLetter/query/decision-blocked-abstention\",\"query\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#case/AbstentionLetter/query/decision-blocked-abstention\",\"resultKind\":\"PROPOSITION\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"target\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_blocked_by_permanent_member\",\"truthStatus\":\"TRUE_ONLY\"}],\"schemaVersion\":\"law.core.evaluation/0.2\"}","evaluationSha256":"sha256:d119fae9cff3c8dd9a7ad85a0aa4d6a5011ff87dab40357ad12d0e0292ae9656","request":{"case":{"assertions":[{"contentHash":"sha256:e55a70592f54b05444ddecdcbc60a7c5f636167b8c1344529b0b6f41ebf54d35","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#non-proc","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#is_non_procedural_matter"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:835a2784f2e9335ce057e68ca26e6fd46cdefaf893a6668ccc8435093a25ce22","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#fr","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#france","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:fd044c0d27c4272b764622063251f35b52c428f75c82695bea2aaba84010b60d","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:516f618ced41fd2bedcb6bcc72c66e846ac761be34a87ce71e94cbf83d961355","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:aae866ff0556a4168a1ea040f8c1893cc2aab8e62ab1bd16f0c6482671fcbdc6","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:196834658ef37892350f21afb8d650b8d378eab77a316a19c4ba43060e823fae","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:e83f2c95c580a2605896f25cb8f14c403330c50e875b50511f4b0e1a1ac8a59c","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:3357701bb3c195ad49e9202437a3d1a52e5a4f26be5d15c57b4833755bde02b9","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:dbe0ed67e1d2f83bc758fbeece4ca2da754e1046f014484f6ac8b7c8e98016f5","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:7e8a7dc5166e252cf5b9a1ca3062ede63145bac1eb123e1947cbadd900f59928","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:825fcbf9094100876a0401f5b75109de4cd117ce9584f406d35e1fa32104507a","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#su","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#soviet","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#abstains"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"}],"constants":{"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#france":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m0","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m1","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m2","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m3","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m4","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m5","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#soviet":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState","kind":"entity_ref"}},"context":{"decisionTime":"2026-01-01T12:00:00Z","knowledgeTime":"2026-01-01T12:00:00Z","legalTime":"2026-01-01","timezone":"UTC"},"options":{}},"ir":{"irSha256":"sha256:b80968c289f44aa8407d3db4b14414d1a8270bd8ecb49efaf538431149c787a9","kind":"world_ref","nodeCount":713,"packages":[{"artifactHash":"sha256:1d123a11b4c6e20a0c1042d7d0ae2f6cca7396f20ebd75136836d48735a4b835","namespace":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","package":"un.charter","semanticHash":"sha256:b75234dd3b9d08a90304c97ed60d6430f3ce09b4dbce585b52ebf491721efadf"}],"programHash":"sha256:53761165015b682383430aa74b59233f973da8e16ffe719420f98edd8b25519d"},"query":{"kind":"truth","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_blocked_by_permanent_member"},"queryId":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#case/AbstentionLetter/query/decision-blocked-abstention"},"semanticVersion":"0.2.1"},"requestCanonicalSha256":"sha256:5f364001d490c18fe0bdc9ac735a5223530d4dd91d3f74d0b6920ed5dc927fc8","verification":{"matched":true,"method":"law ask: attentes du texte, Rust = Python = rejeu"}},"id":"vote-letter-blocked","kind":"truth","label":"Letter of article 27(3): the abstention blocks","presentation":{"schemaVersion":"law.answers.presentation/0.1","source":{"requestCanonicalSha256":"sha256:5f364001d490c18fe0bdc9ac735a5223530d4dd91d3f74d0b6920ed5dc927fc8"},"steps":[{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#is_non_procedural_matter"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#non-proc","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#abstains"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#su","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h1670ff143db3b3d29021dc7ad7985b349772e84c0b76792a3ee656307d221a85","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"unavailable","premises":[]},{"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by"},"head":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by"},"id":"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:8b78e920fb454ef68cfd4d28faa95e701383a4945549927ddb0e490175215890","kind":"rule_application","originStatus":"available","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h1670ff143db3b3d29021dc7ad7985b349772e84c0b76792a3ee656307d221a85"],"rule":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat","sourceAnchors":["urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UNC_EN_ART23"],"strength":"strict","substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion","kind":"entity_ref"}},"trust":"engine","variables":[{"id":"v0","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#State"}}]},{"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_blocked_by_permanent_member"},"head":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_blocked_by_permanent_member"},"id":"urn:proof:apply:NonProceduralDecisionBlockedByPermanentMemberLetter:bf65aceb906673e4044d5f01873bd363ecc08a4dbd3f91a2fa9c1c48b768916e","kind":"rule_application","originStatus":"available","premises":["urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:8b78e920fb454ef68cfd4d28faa95e701383a4945549927ddb0e490175215890","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#non-proc","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#su"],"rule":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#NonProceduralDecisionBlockedByPermanentMemberLetter","sourceAnchors":["urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UNC_EN_ART27"],"strength":"strict","substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"}},"trust":"engine","variables":[{"id":"v0","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#Decision"}}]},{"conclusion":{"literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_blocked_by_permanent_member"},"truthStatus":"TRUE_ONLY"},"id":"urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/AbstentionLetter/query/decision-blocked-abstention","kind":"query_evaluation","originStatus":"available","premises":["urn:proof:apply:NonProceduralDecisionBlockedByPermanentMemberLetter:bf65aceb906673e4044d5f01873bd363ecc08a4dbd3f91a2fa9c1c48b768916e"],"trust":"engine"}],"symbols":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#Decision","kind":"type_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"Decision (of the Security Council or the General Assembly)"}],"name":"Decision","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"France State"}],"name":"FranceState","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[],"symbolKind":"constant"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"The letter of Article 23: the five named States hold a permanent seat"}],"package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","strength":"strict"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#NonProceduralDecisionBlockedByPermanentMemberLetter","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"Article 27, paragraph 3 (the letter, negative side). A permanent member that votes against or abstains does not give a concurring vote."}],"package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","strength":"strict"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#RepublicOfChina","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"Republic Of China"}],"name":"RepublicOfChina","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[],"symbolKind":"constant"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"Soviet Union"}],"name":"SovietUnion","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[],"symbolKind":"constant"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#State","kind":"type_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"State"}],"name":"State","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"United Kingdom State"}],"name":"UnitedKingdomState","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[],"symbolKind":"constant"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"United States State"}],"name":"UnitedStatesState","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[],"symbolKind":"constant"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#abstains","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the State abstains (Art. 27, para. 3)"}],"name":"abstains","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#abstains/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#Decision"}},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#abstains/arg/s","labels":[],"name":"s","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#State"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the State casts a vote in favour (Art. 18, Art. 27)"}],"name":"casts_vote_for","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#Decision"}},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for/arg/s","labels":[],"name":"s","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#State"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_blocked_by_permanent_member","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"the decision is blocked by a permanent member — by a vote against, or (by the letter) by abstention (Art. 27, para. 3)"}],"name":"decision_blocked_by_permanent_member","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_blocked_by_permanent_member/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#Decision"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#is_non_procedural_matter","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the decision is not on a procedural matter (Art. 27, para. 3)"}],"name":"is_non_procedural_matter","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#is_non_procedural_matter/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#Decision"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"permanent member of the Security Council (Art. 23, para. 1)"}],"name":"permanent_member","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member/arg/s","labels":[],"name":"s","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#State"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"the State holds a permanent seat for voting purposes (letter of Art. 23, or continuity/seat transfer)"}],"name":"permanent_member_seat_held_by","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by/arg/s","labels":[],"name":"s","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#State"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"}]},"provenance":{"acts":[{"artifactHash":"sha256:1d123a11b4c6e20a0c1042d7d0ae2f6cca7396f20ebd75136836d48735a4b835","namespace":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","package":"un.charter"}],"caseHash":"sha256:d95df12017d0aa072cb5bf5e1506fad463a05c883c87659a486ffdbaf4dc5d7a","jurisdiction":"International","legalTime":"2026-01-01","mode":"audit","programHash":"sha256:53761165015b682383430aa74b59233f973da8e16ffe719420f98edd8b25519d","resultHash":"sha256:8caef5da5d50dfce96bf64f0bd1198ee75747019fc984ee77ae14987fbc6e4e1","timezone":"UTC"},"request":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"}],"facts":[{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#is_non_procedural_matter"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#france","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#soviet","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#abstains"}],"kind":"truth","legalTime":"2026-01-01","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_blocked_by_permanent_member"},"sources":[{"contentHash":"sha256:7b43f3150e9a17e3213539187ddf364d08bfc106551b59bb6f2062c9769bb2c4","edition":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UN_CHARTER_EN","fragmentKind":"article","id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UNC_EN_ART23","kind":"fragment","locator":"article/23","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","texts":[{"contentHash":"sha256:04634bcee8d5f914608d8ed6dce1d8bde70766de1ad6f66aded63661b6cceeb7","language":"en","status":"official","text":"Article 23\nThe Security Council shall consist of fifteen Members of the United Nations. The Republic of China, France, the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics, the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, and the United States of America shall be permanent members of the Security Council. The General Assembly shall elect ten other Members of the United Nations to be non-permanent members of the Security Council, due regard being specially paid, in the first instance to the contribution of Members of the United Nations to the maintenance of international peace and security and to the other purposes of the Organization, and also to equitable geographical distribution.\nThe non-permanent members of the Security Council shall be elected for a term of two years. In the first election of the non-permanent members after the increase of the membership of the Security Council from eleven to fifteen, two of the four additional members shall be chosen for a term of one year. A retiring member shall not be eligible for immediate re-election.\nEach member of the Security Council shall have one representative."}]},{"contentHash":"sha256:d76f30a3ec91422c1506becd5504f2054bd298551bdef3717ebfbb411ee4fda6","edition":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UN_CHARTER_EN","fragmentKind":"article","id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UNC_EN_ART27","kind":"fragment","locator":"article/27","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","texts":[{"contentHash":"sha256:d2e1200a16b6cc23e35a408e6f305c6a42aec1ae602e3202d05006d4577ea403","language":"en","status":"official","text":"Article 27\nEach member of the Security Council shall have one vote.\nDecisions of the Security Council on procedural matters shall be made by an affirmative vote of nine members.\nDecisions of the Security Council on all other matters shall be made by an affirmative vote of nine members including the concurring votes of the permanent members; provided that, in decisions under Chapter VI, and under paragraph 3 of Article 52, a party to a dispute shall abstain from voting."}]}],"text":"Letter of article 27(3): the abstention blocks"},{"answer":{"answer":{"evaluationStatus":"COMPUTED","kind":"TRUTH","missingInputs":[],"truthStatus":"TRUE_ONLY"},"evaluation":{"conflicts":[],"issues":[],"manifest":{"artifactHash":"sha256:0767659ce1336a603665167add3678052c57846e4619007a6ccdc6398fcf294e","calendarSnapshot":"","caseHash":"sha256:8e5d71abbfd792294bdd5da63086d2d19838c2fe6281263555240e04de8bef08","decisionTime":"2026-01-01T12:00:00Z","evidenceSnapshotHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","externalSnapshots":{},"id":"urn:manifest:oracle-1","interpretations":["urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#AbstentionDoesNotBlockReading"],"knowledgeTime":"2026-01-01T12:00:00Z","legalTime":"2026-01-01","lockfileHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","mode":"audit","policies":{},"programHash":"sha256:53761165015b682383430aa74b59233f973da8e16ffe719420f98edd8b25519d","resolvedEditions":{},"semanticHash":"sha256:ab92b9171a48f4c582ea05158c7d1a89d620e9c7843747928710365c477c97e1","semantics":"law.core/0.2.1","theoryHash":"sha256:53761165015b682383430aa74b59233f973da8e16ffe719420f98edd8b25519d","timezone":"UTC"},"positions":[],"proofGraph":{"nodes":[{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#fr"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#fr","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m0","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m1","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m2","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m3","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m4","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m5","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#non-proc"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#is_non_procedural_matter"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#non-proc","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#su"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#abstains"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#su","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_adopted"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:NonProceduralDecisionAdoptedDespiteAbstention:3544c26849871a80ce5cbfa955cd476259192610287c691e959f558c5bbcb46c","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#fr","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#non-proc","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us"],"rule":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#NonProceduralDecisionAdoptedDespiteAbstention","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h16351e0bed59b62494f1c5210d0fd5a006de40ee549557096968b0b2c2e81693"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h16351e0bed59b62494f1c5210d0fd5a006de40ee549557096968b0b2c2e81693","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:e6cdd1b41bb6a401a290db8d3f9e0e3e09802f9c184a1edc05d29d0412a6717f","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h16351e0bed59b62494f1c5210d0fd5a006de40ee549557096968b0b2c2e81693"],"rule":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h1670ff143db3b3d29021dc7ad7985b349772e84c0b76792a3ee656307d221a85"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h1670ff143db3b3d29021dc7ad7985b349772e84c0b76792a3ee656307d221a85","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:8b78e920fb454ef68cfd4d28faa95e701383a4945549927ddb0e490175215890","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h1670ff143db3b3d29021dc7ad7985b349772e84c0b76792a3ee656307d221a85"],"rule":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_blocked_by_permanent_member"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:NonProceduralDecisionBlockedByPermanentMemberLetter:bf65aceb906673e4044d5f01873bd363ecc08a4dbd3f91a2fa9c1c48b768916e","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:8b78e920fb454ef68cfd4d28faa95e701383a4945549927ddb0e490175215890","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#non-proc","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#su"],"rule":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#NonProceduralDecisionBlockedByPermanentMemberLetter","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h2577471a877f419d16417bc8ce7642e21e0eaa2649933f621cead7f558251c22"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h2577471a877f419d16417bc8ce7642e21e0eaa2649933f621cead7f558251c22","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:a2e3e604e9de005e17c81a51ce629be98e8e9e509a506046e0cde52b32321222","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h2577471a877f419d16417bc8ce7642e21e0eaa2649933f621cead7f558251c22"],"rule":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h5c5d3b5c9ef348f54b5802f708fcfb08ffdf58f3b19d9f2957124cc18c49ca25"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#RepublicOfChina","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h5c5d3b5c9ef348f54b5802f708fcfb08ffdf58f3b19d9f2957124cc18c49ca25","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#RepublicOfChina","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:4b1a6f6f8748646d22693b4c086f59515bea5071b14cc9f60294942b421440aa","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h5c5d3b5c9ef348f54b5802f708fcfb08ffdf58f3b19d9f2957124cc18c49ca25"],"rule":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#RepublicOfChina","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h95b1a57a07a53f49ec8dcbb91c442be4fdf9ca5f19fb2fa7ee84192725768c7a"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h95b1a57a07a53f49ec8dcbb91c442be4fdf9ca5f19fb2fa7ee84192725768c7a","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:ce60c6e3d670f6229c478e6f4fa5860728de789f588132e65e8a1127d110648f","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h95b1a57a07a53f49ec8dcbb91c442be4fdf9ca5f19fb2fa7ee84192725768c7a"],"rule":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"selected":["urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#AbstentionDoesNotBlockReading"]},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:interpretation-selection","kind":"interpretation_selection","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_adopted"},"truthStatus":"TRUE_ONLY"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/AbstentionPractice/query/decision-adopted-abstention","kind":"query_evaluation","premises":["urn:proof:apply:NonProceduralDecisionAdoptedDespiteAbstention:3544c26849871a80ce5cbfa955cd476259192610287c691e959f558c5bbcb46c"],"sourceAnchors":[]}],"proofHash":"sha256:bf22d927d6f57da05fd4f4b34e8a2afb025040e5c3e114d87b7451926565ea57","roots":["urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/AbstentionPractice/query/decision-adopted-abstention"]},"resultHash":"sha256:aa6d1930d4ad35d4a11a2e6f3b4f45cd09ab173c262dec3074d24d9a86f13ae7","results":[{"conflicts":[],"evaluationStatus":"COMPUTED","evidence":[],"id":"urn:result:same-vote#case/AbstentionPractice/query/decision-adopted-abstention","judgmentRequests":[],"manifest":"urn:manifest:oracle-1","missingInputs":[],"normativeStatusSupports":[],"proof":"urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/AbstentionPractice/query/decision-adopted-abstention","query":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#case/AbstentionPractice/query/decision-adopted-abstention","resultKind":"PROPOSITION","sourceAnchors":[],"target":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_adopted","truthStatus":"TRUE_ONLY"}],"schemaVersion":"law.core.evaluation/0.2"},"evaluationStatus":"COMPUTED","issues":[],"judgmentRequests":[],"proofRef":"urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/AbstentionPractice/query/decision-adopted-abstention","provenance":{"acts":[{"artifactHash":"sha256:1d123a11b4c6e20a0c1042d7d0ae2f6cca7396f20ebd75136836d48735a4b835","namespace":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","package":"un.charter"}],"caseHash":"sha256:8e5d71abbfd792294bdd5da63086d2d19838c2fe6281263555240e04de8bef08","jurisdiction":"International","legalTime":"2026-01-01","mode":"audit","programHash":"sha256:53761165015b682383430aa74b59233f973da8e16ffe719420f98edd8b25519d","resultHash":"sha256:aa6d1930d4ad35d4a11a2e6f3b4f45cd09ab173c262dec3074d24d9a86f13ae7","timezone":"UTC"},"rulesApplied":["urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat","urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#NonProceduralDecisionAdoptedDespiteAbstention","urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#NonProceduralDecisionBlockedByPermanentMemberLetter"]},"execution":{"evaluationBytes":"{\"conflicts\":[],\"issues\":[],\"manifest\":{\"artifactHash\":\"sha256:0767659ce1336a603665167add3678052c57846e4619007a6ccdc6398fcf294e\",\"calendarSnapshot\":\"\",\"caseHash\":\"sha256:8e5d71abbfd792294bdd5da63086d2d19838c2fe6281263555240e04de8bef08\",\"decisionTime\":\"2026-01-01T12:00:00Z\",\"evidenceSnapshotHash\":\"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000\",\"externalSnapshots\":{},\"id\":\"urn:manifest:oracle-1\",\"interpretations\":[\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#AbstentionDoesNotBlockReading\"],\"knowledgeTime\":\"2026-01-01T12:00:00Z\",\"legalTime\":\"2026-01-01\",\"lockfileHash\":\"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000\",\"mode\":\"audit\",\"policies\":{},\"programHash\":\"sha256:53761165015b682383430aa74b59233f973da8e16ffe719420f98edd8b25519d\",\"resolvedEditions\":{},\"semanticHash\":\"sha256:ab92b9171a48f4c582ea05158c7d1a89d620e9c7843747928710365c477c97e1\",\"semantics\":\"law.core/0.2.1\",\"theoryHash\":\"sha256:53761165015b682383430aa74b59233f973da8e16ffe719420f98edd8b25519d\",\"timezone\":\"UTC\"},\"positions\":[],\"proofGraph\":{\"nodes\":[{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#fr\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#fr\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m0\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m1\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m2\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m3\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m4\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m5\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#non-proc\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#is_non_procedural_matter\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#non-proc\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#su\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#abstains\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#su\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_adopted\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:NonProceduralDecisionAdoptedDespiteAbstention:3544c26849871a80ce5cbfa955cd476259192610287c691e959f558c5bbcb46c\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#fr\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#non-proc\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us\"],\"rule\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#NonProceduralDecisionAdoptedDespiteAbstention\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h16351e0bed59b62494f1c5210d0fd5a006de40ee549557096968b0b2c2e81693\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h16351e0bed59b62494f1c5210d0fd5a006de40ee549557096968b0b2c2e81693\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:e6cdd1b41bb6a401a290db8d3f9e0e3e09802f9c184a1edc05d29d0412a6717f\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h16351e0bed59b62494f1c5210d0fd5a006de40ee549557096968b0b2c2e81693\"],\"rule\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h1670ff143db3b3d29021dc7ad7985b349772e84c0b76792a3ee656307d221a85\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h1670ff143db3b3d29021dc7ad7985b349772e84c0b76792a3ee656307d221a85\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:8b78e920fb454ef68cfd4d28faa95e701383a4945549927ddb0e490175215890\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h1670ff143db3b3d29021dc7ad7985b349772e84c0b76792a3ee656307d221a85\"],\"rule\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_blocked_by_permanent_member\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:NonProceduralDecisionBlockedByPermanentMemberLetter:bf65aceb906673e4044d5f01873bd363ecc08a4dbd3f91a2fa9c1c48b768916e\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:8b78e920fb454ef68cfd4d28faa95e701383a4945549927ddb0e490175215890\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#non-proc\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#su\"],\"rule\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#NonProceduralDecisionBlockedByPermanentMemberLetter\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h2577471a877f419d16417bc8ce7642e21e0eaa2649933f621cead7f558251c22\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h2577471a877f419d16417bc8ce7642e21e0eaa2649933f621cead7f558251c22\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:a2e3e604e9de005e17c81a51ce629be98e8e9e509a506046e0cde52b32321222\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h2577471a877f419d16417bc8ce7642e21e0eaa2649933f621cead7f558251c22\"],\"rule\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h5c5d3b5c9ef348f54b5802f708fcfb08ffdf58f3b19d9f2957124cc18c49ca25\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#RepublicOfChina\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h5c5d3b5c9ef348f54b5802f708fcfb08ffdf58f3b19d9f2957124cc18c49ca25\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#RepublicOfChina\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:4b1a6f6f8748646d22693b4c086f59515bea5071b14cc9f60294942b421440aa\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h5c5d3b5c9ef348f54b5802f708fcfb08ffdf58f3b19d9f2957124cc18c49ca25\"],\"rule\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#RepublicOfChina\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h95b1a57a07a53f49ec8dcbb91c442be4fdf9ca5f19fb2fa7ee84192725768c7a\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h95b1a57a07a53f49ec8dcbb91c442be4fdf9ca5f19fb2fa7ee84192725768c7a\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:ce60c6e3d670f6229c478e6f4fa5860728de789f588132e65e8a1127d110648f\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h95b1a57a07a53f49ec8dcbb91c442be4fdf9ca5f19fb2fa7ee84192725768c7a\"],\"rule\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"selected\":[\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#AbstentionDoesNotBlockReading\"]},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:interpretation-selection\",\"kind\":\"interpretation_selection\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"literal\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_adopted\"},\"truthStatus\":\"TRUE_ONLY\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/AbstentionPractice/query/decision-adopted-abstention\",\"kind\":\"query_evaluation\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:NonProceduralDecisionAdoptedDespiteAbstention:3544c26849871a80ce5cbfa955cd476259192610287c691e959f558c5bbcb46c\"],\"sourceAnchors\":[]}],\"proofHash\":\"sha256:bf22d927d6f57da05fd4f4b34e8a2afb025040e5c3e114d87b7451926565ea57\",\"roots\":[\"urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/AbstentionPractice/query/decision-adopted-abstention\"]},\"resultHash\":\"sha256:aa6d1930d4ad35d4a11a2e6f3b4f45cd09ab173c262dec3074d24d9a86f13ae7\",\"results\":[{\"conflicts\":[],\"evaluationStatus\":\"COMPUTED\",\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:result:same-vote#case/AbstentionPractice/query/decision-adopted-abstention\",\"judgmentRequests\":[],\"manifest\":\"urn:manifest:oracle-1\",\"missingInputs\":[],\"normativeStatusSupports\":[],\"proof\":\"urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/AbstentionPractice/query/decision-adopted-abstention\",\"query\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#case/AbstentionPractice/query/decision-adopted-abstention\",\"resultKind\":\"PROPOSITION\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"target\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_adopted\",\"truthStatus\":\"TRUE_ONLY\"}],\"schemaVersion\":\"law.core.evaluation/0.2\"}","evaluationSha256":"sha256:50b43f2ff785972646e8a07e19a1eef0abee47a5820be27bff8f2e5368c4802a","request":{"case":{"assertions":[{"contentHash":"sha256:e55a70592f54b05444ddecdcbc60a7c5f636167b8c1344529b0b6f41ebf54d35","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#non-proc","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#is_non_procedural_matter"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:835a2784f2e9335ce057e68ca26e6fd46cdefaf893a6668ccc8435093a25ce22","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#fr","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#france","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:fd044c0d27c4272b764622063251f35b52c428f75c82695bea2aaba84010b60d","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:516f618ced41fd2bedcb6bcc72c66e846ac761be34a87ce71e94cbf83d961355","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:aae866ff0556a4168a1ea040f8c1893cc2aab8e62ab1bd16f0c6482671fcbdc6","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:196834658ef37892350f21afb8d650b8d378eab77a316a19c4ba43060e823fae","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:e83f2c95c580a2605896f25cb8f14c403330c50e875b50511f4b0e1a1ac8a59c","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:3357701bb3c195ad49e9202437a3d1a52e5a4f26be5d15c57b4833755bde02b9","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:dbe0ed67e1d2f83bc758fbeece4ca2da754e1046f014484f6ac8b7c8e98016f5","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:7e8a7dc5166e252cf5b9a1ca3062ede63145bac1eb123e1947cbadd900f59928","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:825fcbf9094100876a0401f5b75109de4cd117ce9584f406d35e1fa32104507a","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#su","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#soviet","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#abstains"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"}],"constants":{"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#france":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m0","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m1","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m2","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m3","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m4","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m5","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#soviet":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState","kind":"entity_ref"}},"context":{"decisionTime":"2026-01-01T12:00:00Z","knowledgeTime":"2026-01-01T12:00:00Z","legalTime":"2026-01-01","timezone":"UTC"},"options":{"selectedInterpretations":["urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#AbstentionDoesNotBlockReading"]}},"ir":{"irSha256":"sha256:b80968c289f44aa8407d3db4b14414d1a8270bd8ecb49efaf538431149c787a9","kind":"world_ref","nodeCount":713,"packages":[{"artifactHash":"sha256:1d123a11b4c6e20a0c1042d7d0ae2f6cca7396f20ebd75136836d48735a4b835","namespace":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","package":"un.charter","semanticHash":"sha256:b75234dd3b9d08a90304c97ed60d6430f3ce09b4dbce585b52ebf491721efadf"}],"programHash":"sha256:53761165015b682383430aa74b59233f973da8e16ffe719420f98edd8b25519d"},"query":{"kind":"truth","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_adopted"},"queryId":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#case/AbstentionPractice/query/decision-adopted-abstention"},"semanticVersion":"0.2.1"},"requestCanonicalSha256":"sha256:5ee578f448e32fe1c291fa306c76f582dacf536db3981f5834b3c5326f0e42ea","verification":{"matched":true,"method":"law ask: attentes du texte, Rust = Python = rejeu"}},"id":"vote-practice-adopted","kind":"truth","label":"Practice: the decision is adopted","presentation":{"schemaVersion":"law.answers.presentation/0.1","source":{"requestCanonicalSha256":"sha256:5ee578f448e32fe1c291fa306c76f582dacf536db3981f5834b3c5326f0e42ea"},"steps":[{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#fr","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m0","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m1","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m2","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m3","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m4","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m5","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#is_non_procedural_matter"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#non-proc","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_adopted"},"head":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_adopted"},"id":"urn:proof:apply:NonProceduralDecisionAdoptedDespiteAbstention:3544c26849871a80ce5cbfa955cd476259192610287c691e959f558c5bbcb46c","kind":"rule_application","originStatus":"available","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#fr","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#non-proc","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us"],"rule":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#NonProceduralDecisionAdoptedDespiteAbstention","sourceAnchors":["urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UNC_EN_ART27"],"strength":"strict","substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"}},"trust":"engine","variables":[{"id":"v0","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#Decision"}}]},{"conclusion":{"literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_adopted"},"truthStatus":"TRUE_ONLY"},"id":"urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/AbstentionPractice/query/decision-adopted-abstention","kind":"query_evaluation","originStatus":"available","premises":["urn:proof:apply:NonProceduralDecisionAdoptedDespiteAbstention:3544c26849871a80ce5cbfa955cd476259192610287c691e959f558c5bbcb46c"],"trust":"engine"}],"symbols":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#AbstentionDoesNotBlockReading","kind":"interpretation","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"A permanent member's abstention is not a veto: only a vote AGAINST blocks a non-procedural decision (practice since 1946, Namibia 1971)"}],"package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#Decision","kind":"type_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"Decision (of the Security Council or the General Assembly)"}],"name":"Decision","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"France State"}],"name":"FranceState","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[],"symbolKind":"constant"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"The letter of Article 23: the five named States hold a permanent seat"}],"package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","strength":"strict"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#NonProceduralDecisionAdoptedDespiteAbstention","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"Council practice (since 1946), blessed by the International Court of Justice (Namibia advisory opinion, 1971, para. 22): a permanent member's abstention does not block the decision."}],"package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","strength":"strict"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#NonProceduralDecisionBlockedByPermanentMemberLetter","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"Article 27, paragraph 3 (the letter, negative side). A permanent member that votes against or abstains does not give a concurring vote."}],"package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","strength":"strict"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#RepublicOfChina","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"Republic Of China"}],"name":"RepublicOfChina","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[],"symbolKind":"constant"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"Soviet Union"}],"name":"SovietUnion","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[],"symbolKind":"constant"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#State","kind":"type_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"State"}],"name":"State","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"United Kingdom State"}],"name":"UnitedKingdomState","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[],"symbolKind":"constant"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"United States State"}],"name":"UnitedStatesState","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[],"symbolKind":"constant"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#abstains","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the State abstains (Art. 27, para. 3)"}],"name":"abstains","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#abstains/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#Decision"}},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#abstains/arg/s","labels":[],"name":"s","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#State"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the State casts a vote in favour (Art. 18, Art. 27)"}],"name":"casts_vote_for","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#Decision"}},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for/arg/s","labels":[],"name":"s","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#State"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_adopted","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"the Security Council decision is adopted"}],"name":"decision_adopted","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_adopted/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#Decision"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_blocked_by_permanent_member","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"the decision is blocked by a permanent member — by a vote against, or (by the letter) by abstention (Art. 27, para. 3)"}],"name":"decision_blocked_by_permanent_member","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_blocked_by_permanent_member/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#Decision"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#is_non_procedural_matter","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the decision is not on a procedural matter (Art. 27, para. 3)"}],"name":"is_non_procedural_matter","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#is_non_procedural_matter/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#Decision"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"permanent member of the Security Council (Art. 23, para. 1)"}],"name":"permanent_member","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member/arg/s","labels":[],"name":"s","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#State"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"the State holds a permanent seat for voting purposes (letter of Art. 23, or continuity/seat transfer)"}],"name":"permanent_member_seat_held_by","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by/arg/s","labels":[],"name":"s","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#State"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"}]},"provenance":{"acts":[{"artifactHash":"sha256:1d123a11b4c6e20a0c1042d7d0ae2f6cca7396f20ebd75136836d48735a4b835","namespace":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","package":"un.charter"}],"caseHash":"sha256:8e5d71abbfd792294bdd5da63086d2d19838c2fe6281263555240e04de8bef08","jurisdiction":"International","legalTime":"2026-01-01","mode":"audit","programHash":"sha256:53761165015b682383430aa74b59233f973da8e16ffe719420f98edd8b25519d","resultHash":"sha256:aa6d1930d4ad35d4a11a2e6f3b4f45cd09ab173c262dec3074d24d9a86f13ae7","timezone":"UTC"},"request":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"}],"facts":[{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#is_non_procedural_matter"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#france","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#soviet","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#abstains"}],"kind":"truth","legalTime":"2026-01-01","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_adopted"},"sources":[{"contentHash":"sha256:7b43f3150e9a17e3213539187ddf364d08bfc106551b59bb6f2062c9769bb2c4","edition":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UN_CHARTER_EN","fragmentKind":"article","id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UNC_EN_ART23","kind":"fragment","locator":"article/23","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","texts":[{"contentHash":"sha256:04634bcee8d5f914608d8ed6dce1d8bde70766de1ad6f66aded63661b6cceeb7","language":"en","status":"official","text":"Article 23\nThe Security Council shall consist of fifteen Members of the United Nations. The Republic of China, France, the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics, the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, and the United States of America shall be permanent members of the Security Council. The General Assembly shall elect ten other Members of the United Nations to be non-permanent members of the Security Council, due regard being specially paid, in the first instance to the contribution of Members of the United Nations to the maintenance of international peace and security and to the other purposes of the Organization, and also to equitable geographical distribution.\nThe non-permanent members of the Security Council shall be elected for a term of two years. In the first election of the non-permanent members after the increase of the membership of the Security Council from eleven to fifteen, two of the four additional members shall be chosen for a term of one year. A retiring member shall not be eligible for immediate re-election.\nEach member of the Security Council shall have one representative."}]},{"contentHash":"sha256:d76f30a3ec91422c1506becd5504f2054bd298551bdef3717ebfbb411ee4fda6","edition":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UN_CHARTER_EN","fragmentKind":"article","id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UNC_EN_ART27","kind":"fragment","locator":"article/27","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","texts":[{"contentHash":"sha256:d2e1200a16b6cc23e35a408e6f305c6a42aec1ae602e3202d05006d4577ea403","language":"en","status":"official","text":"Article 27\nEach member of the Security Council shall have one vote.\nDecisions of the Security Council on procedural matters shall be made by an affirmative vote of nine members.\nDecisions of the Security Council on all other matters shall be made by an affirmative vote of nine members including the concurring votes of the permanent members; provided that, in decisions under Chapter VI, and under paragraph 3 of Article 52, a party to a dispute shall abstain from voting."}]}],"text":"Practice: the decision is adopted"},{"answer":{"answer":{"evaluationStatus":"COMPUTED","kind":"TRUTH","missingInputs":[],"truthStatus":"TRUE_ONLY"},"evaluation":{"conflicts":[],"issues":[],"manifest":{"artifactHash":"sha256:0767659ce1336a603665167add3678052c57846e4619007a6ccdc6398fcf294e","calendarSnapshot":"","caseHash":"sha256:8e5d71abbfd792294bdd5da63086d2d19838c2fe6281263555240e04de8bef08","decisionTime":"2026-01-01T12:00:00Z","evidenceSnapshotHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","externalSnapshots":{},"id":"urn:manifest:oracle-1","interpretations":["urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#AbstentionDoesNotBlockReading"],"knowledgeTime":"2026-01-01T12:00:00Z","legalTime":"2026-01-01","lockfileHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","mode":"audit","policies":{},"programHash":"sha256:53761165015b682383430aa74b59233f973da8e16ffe719420f98edd8b25519d","resolvedEditions":{},"semanticHash":"sha256:ab92b9171a48f4c582ea05158c7d1a89d620e9c7843747928710365c477c97e1","semantics":"law.core/0.2.1","theoryHash":"sha256:53761165015b682383430aa74b59233f973da8e16ffe719420f98edd8b25519d","timezone":"UTC"},"positions":[],"proofGraph":{"nodes":[{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#fr"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#fr","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m0","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m1","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m2","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m3","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m4","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m5","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#non-proc"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#is_non_procedural_matter"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#non-proc","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#su"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#abstains"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#su","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_adopted"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:NonProceduralDecisionAdoptedDespiteAbstention:3544c26849871a80ce5cbfa955cd476259192610287c691e959f558c5bbcb46c","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#fr","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#non-proc","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us"],"rule":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#NonProceduralDecisionAdoptedDespiteAbstention","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h16351e0bed59b62494f1c5210d0fd5a006de40ee549557096968b0b2c2e81693"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h16351e0bed59b62494f1c5210d0fd5a006de40ee549557096968b0b2c2e81693","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:e6cdd1b41bb6a401a290db8d3f9e0e3e09802f9c184a1edc05d29d0412a6717f","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h16351e0bed59b62494f1c5210d0fd5a006de40ee549557096968b0b2c2e81693"],"rule":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h1670ff143db3b3d29021dc7ad7985b349772e84c0b76792a3ee656307d221a85"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h1670ff143db3b3d29021dc7ad7985b349772e84c0b76792a3ee656307d221a85","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:8b78e920fb454ef68cfd4d28faa95e701383a4945549927ddb0e490175215890","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h1670ff143db3b3d29021dc7ad7985b349772e84c0b76792a3ee656307d221a85"],"rule":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_blocked_by_permanent_member"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:NonProceduralDecisionBlockedByPermanentMemberLetter:bf65aceb906673e4044d5f01873bd363ecc08a4dbd3f91a2fa9c1c48b768916e","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:8b78e920fb454ef68cfd4d28faa95e701383a4945549927ddb0e490175215890","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#non-proc","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#su"],"rule":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#NonProceduralDecisionBlockedByPermanentMemberLetter","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h2577471a877f419d16417bc8ce7642e21e0eaa2649933f621cead7f558251c22"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h2577471a877f419d16417bc8ce7642e21e0eaa2649933f621cead7f558251c22","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:a2e3e604e9de005e17c81a51ce629be98e8e9e509a506046e0cde52b32321222","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h2577471a877f419d16417bc8ce7642e21e0eaa2649933f621cead7f558251c22"],"rule":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h5c5d3b5c9ef348f54b5802f708fcfb08ffdf58f3b19d9f2957124cc18c49ca25"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#RepublicOfChina","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h5c5d3b5c9ef348f54b5802f708fcfb08ffdf58f3b19d9f2957124cc18c49ca25","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#RepublicOfChina","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:4b1a6f6f8748646d22693b4c086f59515bea5071b14cc9f60294942b421440aa","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h5c5d3b5c9ef348f54b5802f708fcfb08ffdf58f3b19d9f2957124cc18c49ca25"],"rule":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#RepublicOfChina","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h95b1a57a07a53f49ec8dcbb91c442be4fdf9ca5f19fb2fa7ee84192725768c7a"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h95b1a57a07a53f49ec8dcbb91c442be4fdf9ca5f19fb2fa7ee84192725768c7a","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:ce60c6e3d670f6229c478e6f4fa5860728de789f588132e65e8a1127d110648f","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h95b1a57a07a53f49ec8dcbb91c442be4fdf9ca5f19fb2fa7ee84192725768c7a"],"rule":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"selected":["urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#AbstentionDoesNotBlockReading"]},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:interpretation-selection","kind":"interpretation_selection","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_blocked_by_permanent_member"},"truthStatus":"TRUE_ONLY"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/AbstentionPractice/query/decision-blocked-abstention","kind":"query_evaluation","premises":["urn:proof:apply:NonProceduralDecisionBlockedByPermanentMemberLetter:bf65aceb906673e4044d5f01873bd363ecc08a4dbd3f91a2fa9c1c48b768916e"],"sourceAnchors":[]}],"proofHash":"sha256:65a06cfc06fb3bcb6f69202cac9f94967edd5da4dd8c9f9e65c414cb2d2ed32e","roots":["urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/AbstentionPractice/query/decision-blocked-abstention"]},"resultHash":"sha256:d5604a27015cb03cf9c4ad9ce53a1752eb89899c54ecc30799a909ebf5b36d3a","results":[{"conflicts":[],"evaluationStatus":"COMPUTED","evidence":[],"id":"urn:result:same-vote#case/AbstentionPractice/query/decision-blocked-abstention","judgmentRequests":[],"manifest":"urn:manifest:oracle-1","missingInputs":[],"normativeStatusSupports":[],"proof":"urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/AbstentionPractice/query/decision-blocked-abstention","query":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#case/AbstentionPractice/query/decision-blocked-abstention","resultKind":"PROPOSITION","sourceAnchors":[],"target":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_blocked_by_permanent_member","truthStatus":"TRUE_ONLY"}],"schemaVersion":"law.core.evaluation/0.2"},"evaluationStatus":"COMPUTED","issues":[],"judgmentRequests":[],"proofRef":"urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/AbstentionPractice/query/decision-blocked-abstention","provenance":{"acts":[{"artifactHash":"sha256:1d123a11b4c6e20a0c1042d7d0ae2f6cca7396f20ebd75136836d48735a4b835","namespace":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","package":"un.charter"}],"caseHash":"sha256:8e5d71abbfd792294bdd5da63086d2d19838c2fe6281263555240e04de8bef08","jurisdiction":"International","legalTime":"2026-01-01","mode":"audit","programHash":"sha256:53761165015b682383430aa74b59233f973da8e16ffe719420f98edd8b25519d","resultHash":"sha256:d5604a27015cb03cf9c4ad9ce53a1752eb89899c54ecc30799a909ebf5b36d3a","timezone":"UTC"},"rulesApplied":["urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat","urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#NonProceduralDecisionAdoptedDespiteAbstention","urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#NonProceduralDecisionBlockedByPermanentMemberLetter"]},"execution":{"evaluationBytes":"{\"conflicts\":[],\"issues\":[],\"manifest\":{\"artifactHash\":\"sha256:0767659ce1336a603665167add3678052c57846e4619007a6ccdc6398fcf294e\",\"calendarSnapshot\":\"\",\"caseHash\":\"sha256:8e5d71abbfd792294bdd5da63086d2d19838c2fe6281263555240e04de8bef08\",\"decisionTime\":\"2026-01-01T12:00:00Z\",\"evidenceSnapshotHash\":\"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000\",\"externalSnapshots\":{},\"id\":\"urn:manifest:oracle-1\",\"interpretations\":[\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#AbstentionDoesNotBlockReading\"],\"knowledgeTime\":\"2026-01-01T12:00:00Z\",\"legalTime\":\"2026-01-01\",\"lockfileHash\":\"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000\",\"mode\":\"audit\",\"policies\":{},\"programHash\":\"sha256:53761165015b682383430aa74b59233f973da8e16ffe719420f98edd8b25519d\",\"resolvedEditions\":{},\"semanticHash\":\"sha256:ab92b9171a48f4c582ea05158c7d1a89d620e9c7843747928710365c477c97e1\",\"semantics\":\"law.core/0.2.1\",\"theoryHash\":\"sha256:53761165015b682383430aa74b59233f973da8e16ffe719420f98edd8b25519d\",\"timezone\":\"UTC\"},\"positions\":[],\"proofGraph\":{\"nodes\":[{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#fr\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#fr\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m0\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m1\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m2\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m3\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m4\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m5\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#non-proc\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#is_non_procedural_matter\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#non-proc\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#su\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#abstains\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#su\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_adopted\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:NonProceduralDecisionAdoptedDespiteAbstention:3544c26849871a80ce5cbfa955cd476259192610287c691e959f558c5bbcb46c\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#fr\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#non-proc\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us\"],\"rule\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#NonProceduralDecisionAdoptedDespiteAbstention\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h16351e0bed59b62494f1c5210d0fd5a006de40ee549557096968b0b2c2e81693\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h16351e0bed59b62494f1c5210d0fd5a006de40ee549557096968b0b2c2e81693\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:e6cdd1b41bb6a401a290db8d3f9e0e3e09802f9c184a1edc05d29d0412a6717f\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h16351e0bed59b62494f1c5210d0fd5a006de40ee549557096968b0b2c2e81693\"],\"rule\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h1670ff143db3b3d29021dc7ad7985b349772e84c0b76792a3ee656307d221a85\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h1670ff143db3b3d29021dc7ad7985b349772e84c0b76792a3ee656307d221a85\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:8b78e920fb454ef68cfd4d28faa95e701383a4945549927ddb0e490175215890\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h1670ff143db3b3d29021dc7ad7985b349772e84c0b76792a3ee656307d221a85\"],\"rule\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_blocked_by_permanent_member\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:NonProceduralDecisionBlockedByPermanentMemberLetter:bf65aceb906673e4044d5f01873bd363ecc08a4dbd3f91a2fa9c1c48b768916e\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:8b78e920fb454ef68cfd4d28faa95e701383a4945549927ddb0e490175215890\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#non-proc\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#su\"],\"rule\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#NonProceduralDecisionBlockedByPermanentMemberLetter\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h2577471a877f419d16417bc8ce7642e21e0eaa2649933f621cead7f558251c22\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h2577471a877f419d16417bc8ce7642e21e0eaa2649933f621cead7f558251c22\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:a2e3e604e9de005e17c81a51ce629be98e8e9e509a506046e0cde52b32321222\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h2577471a877f419d16417bc8ce7642e21e0eaa2649933f621cead7f558251c22\"],\"rule\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h5c5d3b5c9ef348f54b5802f708fcfb08ffdf58f3b19d9f2957124cc18c49ca25\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#RepublicOfChina\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h5c5d3b5c9ef348f54b5802f708fcfb08ffdf58f3b19d9f2957124cc18c49ca25\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#RepublicOfChina\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:4b1a6f6f8748646d22693b4c086f59515bea5071b14cc9f60294942b421440aa\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h5c5d3b5c9ef348f54b5802f708fcfb08ffdf58f3b19d9f2957124cc18c49ca25\"],\"rule\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#RepublicOfChina\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h95b1a57a07a53f49ec8dcbb91c442be4fdf9ca5f19fb2fa7ee84192725768c7a\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h95b1a57a07a53f49ec8dcbb91c442be4fdf9ca5f19fb2fa7ee84192725768c7a\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:ce60c6e3d670f6229c478e6f4fa5860728de789f588132e65e8a1127d110648f\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h95b1a57a07a53f49ec8dcbb91c442be4fdf9ca5f19fb2fa7ee84192725768c7a\"],\"rule\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"selected\":[\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#AbstentionDoesNotBlockReading\"]},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:interpretation-selection\",\"kind\":\"interpretation_selection\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"literal\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_blocked_by_permanent_member\"},\"truthStatus\":\"TRUE_ONLY\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/AbstentionPractice/query/decision-blocked-abstention\",\"kind\":\"query_evaluation\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:NonProceduralDecisionBlockedByPermanentMemberLetter:bf65aceb906673e4044d5f01873bd363ecc08a4dbd3f91a2fa9c1c48b768916e\"],\"sourceAnchors\":[]}],\"proofHash\":\"sha256:65a06cfc06fb3bcb6f69202cac9f94967edd5da4dd8c9f9e65c414cb2d2ed32e\",\"roots\":[\"urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/AbstentionPractice/query/decision-blocked-abstention\"]},\"resultHash\":\"sha256:d5604a27015cb03cf9c4ad9ce53a1752eb89899c54ecc30799a909ebf5b36d3a\",\"results\":[{\"conflicts\":[],\"evaluationStatus\":\"COMPUTED\",\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:result:same-vote#case/AbstentionPractice/query/decision-blocked-abstention\",\"judgmentRequests\":[],\"manifest\":\"urn:manifest:oracle-1\",\"missingInputs\":[],\"normativeStatusSupports\":[],\"proof\":\"urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/AbstentionPractice/query/decision-blocked-abstention\",\"query\":\"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#case/AbstentionPractice/query/decision-blocked-abstention\",\"resultKind\":\"PROPOSITION\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"target\":\"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_blocked_by_permanent_member\",\"truthStatus\":\"TRUE_ONLY\"}],\"schemaVersion\":\"law.core.evaluation/0.2\"}","evaluationSha256":"sha256:8d15f67ad4c1a28066325de1408222b9c2d5c692c69495b6450be91703e00b05","request":{"case":{"assertions":[{"contentHash":"sha256:e55a70592f54b05444ddecdcbc60a7c5f636167b8c1344529b0b6f41ebf54d35","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#non-proc","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#is_non_procedural_matter"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:835a2784f2e9335ce057e68ca26e6fd46cdefaf893a6668ccc8435093a25ce22","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#fr","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#france","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:fd044c0d27c4272b764622063251f35b52c428f75c82695bea2aaba84010b60d","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:516f618ced41fd2bedcb6bcc72c66e846ac761be34a87ce71e94cbf83d961355","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:aae866ff0556a4168a1ea040f8c1893cc2aab8e62ab1bd16f0c6482671fcbdc6","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:196834658ef37892350f21afb8d650b8d378eab77a316a19c4ba43060e823fae","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:e83f2c95c580a2605896f25cb8f14c403330c50e875b50511f4b0e1a1ac8a59c","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:3357701bb3c195ad49e9202437a3d1a52e5a4f26be5d15c57b4833755bde02b9","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:dbe0ed67e1d2f83bc758fbeece4ca2da754e1046f014484f6ac8b7c8e98016f5","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:7e8a7dc5166e252cf5b9a1ca3062ede63145bac1eb123e1947cbadd900f59928","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"},{"contentHash":"sha256:825fcbf9094100876a0401f5b75109de4cd117ce9584f406d35e1fa32104507a","evidence":[],"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#su","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#soviet","kind":"const_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#abstains"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote"}],"constants":{"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#france":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m0","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m1","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m2","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m3","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m4","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:m5","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#soviet":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState","kind":"entity_ref"},"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState","kind":"entity_ref"}},"context":{"decisionTime":"2026-01-01T12:00:00Z","knowledgeTime":"2026-01-01T12:00:00Z","legalTime":"2026-01-01","timezone":"UTC"},"options":{"selectedInterpretations":["urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#AbstentionDoesNotBlockReading"]}},"ir":{"irSha256":"sha256:b80968c289f44aa8407d3db4b14414d1a8270bd8ecb49efaf538431149c787a9","kind":"world_ref","nodeCount":713,"packages":[{"artifactHash":"sha256:1d123a11b4c6e20a0c1042d7d0ae2f6cca7396f20ebd75136836d48735a4b835","namespace":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","package":"un.charter","semanticHash":"sha256:b75234dd3b9d08a90304c97ed60d6430f3ce09b4dbce585b52ebf491721efadf"}],"programHash":"sha256:53761165015b682383430aa74b59233f973da8e16ffe719420f98edd8b25519d"},"query":{"kind":"truth","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_blocked_by_permanent_member"},"queryId":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#case/AbstentionPractice/query/decision-blocked-abstention"},"semanticVersion":"0.2.1"},"requestCanonicalSha256":"sha256:17ae78e327756eb2ee11025db0e7016027074fdbcf60a8b35d13a06c618ea3ee","verification":{"matched":true,"method":"law ask: attentes du texte, Rust = Python = rejeu"}},"id":"vote-practice-blocked","kind":"truth","label":"Practice: the letter still blocks","presentation":{"schemaVersion":"law.answers.presentation/0.1","source":{"requestCanonicalSha256":"sha256:17ae78e327756eb2ee11025db0e7016027074fdbcf60a8b35d13a06c618ea3ee"},"steps":[{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#is_non_procedural_matter"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#non-proc","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#abstains"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#su","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h1670ff143db3b3d29021dc7ad7985b349772e84c0b76792a3ee656307d221a85","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"unavailable","premises":[]},{"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by"},"head":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by"},"id":"urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:8b78e920fb454ef68cfd4d28faa95e701383a4945549927ddb0e490175215890","kind":"rule_application","originStatus":"available","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#assert-h1670ff143db3b3d29021dc7ad7985b349772e84c0b76792a3ee656307d221a85"],"rule":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat","sourceAnchors":["urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UNC_EN_ART23"],"strength":"strict","substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion","kind":"entity_ref"}},"trust":"engine","variables":[{"id":"v0","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#State"}}]},{"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_blocked_by_permanent_member"},"head":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_blocked_by_permanent_member"},"id":"urn:proof:apply:NonProceduralDecisionBlockedByPermanentMemberLetter:bf65aceb906673e4044d5f01873bd363ecc08a4dbd3f91a2fa9c1c48b768916e","kind":"rule_application","originStatus":"available","premises":["urn:proof:apply:LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat:8b78e920fb454ef68cfd4d28faa95e701383a4945549927ddb0e490175215890","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#non-proc","urn:proof:assert:urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#su"],"rule":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#NonProceduralDecisionBlockedByPermanentMemberLetter","sourceAnchors":["urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UNC_EN_ART27"],"strength":"strict","substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"}},"trust":"engine","variables":[{"id":"v0","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#Decision"}}]},{"conclusion":{"literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_blocked_by_permanent_member"},"truthStatus":"TRUE_ONLY"},"id":"urn:proof:query:same-vote#case/AbstentionPractice/query/decision-blocked-abstention","kind":"query_evaluation","originStatus":"available","premises":["urn:proof:apply:NonProceduralDecisionBlockedByPermanentMemberLetter:bf65aceb906673e4044d5f01873bd363ecc08a4dbd3f91a2fa9c1c48b768916e"],"trust":"engine"}],"symbols":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#AbstentionDoesNotBlockReading","kind":"interpretation","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"A permanent member's abstention is not a veto: only a vote AGAINST blocks a non-procedural decision (practice since 1946, Namibia 1971)"}],"package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#Decision","kind":"type_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"Decision (of the Security Council or the General Assembly)"}],"name":"Decision","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#FranceState","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"France State"}],"name":"FranceState","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[],"symbolKind":"constant"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#LiteralPermanentMemberHoldsSeat","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"The letter of Article 23: the five named States hold a permanent seat"}],"package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","strength":"strict"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#NonProceduralDecisionAdoptedDespiteAbstention","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"Council practice (since 1946), blessed by the International Court of Justice (Namibia advisory opinion, 1971, para. 22): a permanent member's abstention does not block the decision."}],"package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","strength":"strict"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#NonProceduralDecisionBlockedByPermanentMemberLetter","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"Article 27, paragraph 3 (the letter, negative side). A permanent member that votes against or abstains does not give a concurring vote."}],"package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","strength":"strict"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#RepublicOfChina","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"Republic Of China"}],"name":"RepublicOfChina","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[],"symbolKind":"constant"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#SovietUnion","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"Soviet Union"}],"name":"SovietUnion","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[],"symbolKind":"constant"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#State","kind":"type_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"State"}],"name":"State","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedKingdomState","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"United Kingdom State"}],"name":"UnitedKingdomState","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[],"symbolKind":"constant"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UnitedStatesState","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"United States State"}],"name":"UnitedStatesState","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[],"symbolKind":"constant"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#abstains","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the State abstains (Art. 27, para. 3)"}],"name":"abstains","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#abstains/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#Decision"}},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#abstains/arg/s","labels":[],"name":"s","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#State"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the State casts a vote in favour (Art. 18, Art. 27)"}],"name":"casts_vote_for","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#Decision"}},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for/arg/s","labels":[],"name":"s","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#State"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_adopted","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"the Security Council decision is adopted"}],"name":"decision_adopted","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_adopted/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#Decision"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_blocked_by_permanent_member","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"the decision is blocked by a permanent member — by a vote against, or (by the letter) by abstention (Art. 27, para. 3)"}],"name":"decision_blocked_by_permanent_member","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_blocked_by_permanent_member/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#Decision"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#is_non_procedural_matter","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the decision is not on a procedural matter (Art. 27, para. 3)"}],"name":"is_non_procedural_matter","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#is_non_procedural_matter/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#Decision"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"permanent member of the Security Council (Art. 23, para. 1)"}],"name":"permanent_member","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member/arg/s","labels":[],"name":"s","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#State"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"the State holds a permanent seat for voting purposes (letter of Art. 23, or continuity/seat transfer)"}],"name":"permanent_member_seat_held_by","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","parameters":[{"id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#permanent_member_seat_held_by/arg/s","labels":[],"name":"s","type":{"name":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#State"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"}]},"provenance":{"acts":[{"artifactHash":"sha256:1d123a11b4c6e20a0c1042d7d0ae2f6cca7396f20ebd75136836d48735a4b835","namespace":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","package":"un.charter"}],"caseHash":"sha256:8e5d71abbfd792294bdd5da63086d2d19838c2fe6281263555240e04de8bef08","jurisdiction":"International","legalTime":"2026-01-01","mode":"audit","programHash":"sha256:53761165015b682383430aa74b59233f973da8e16ffe719420f98edd8b25519d","resultHash":"sha256:d5604a27015cb03cf9c4ad9ce53a1752eb89899c54ecc30799a909ebf5b36d3a","timezone":"UTC"},"request":{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote:abstention","kind":"entity_ref"}],"facts":[{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#is_non_procedural_matter"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#france","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#uk","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#us","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m0","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m1","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m2","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m3","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m4","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#m5","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#casts_vote_for"},{"args":[{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#d","kind":"const_ref"},{"id":"urn:law:examples:un-charter:same-vote#soviet","kind":"const_ref"}],"negated":false,"origin":"case_input","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#abstains"}],"kind":"truth","legalTime":"2026-01-01","predicate":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#decision_blocked_by_permanent_member"},"sources":[{"contentHash":"sha256:7b43f3150e9a17e3213539187ddf364d08bfc106551b59bb6f2062c9769bb2c4","edition":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UN_CHARTER_EN","fragmentKind":"article","id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UNC_EN_ART23","kind":"fragment","locator":"article/23","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","texts":[{"contentHash":"sha256:04634bcee8d5f914608d8ed6dce1d8bde70766de1ad6f66aded63661b6cceeb7","language":"en","status":"official","text":"Article 23\nThe Security Council shall consist of fifteen Members of the United Nations. The Republic of China, France, the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics, the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, and the United States of America shall be permanent members of the Security Council. The General Assembly shall elect ten other Members of the United Nations to be non-permanent members of the Security Council, due regard being specially paid, in the first instance to the contribution of Members of the United Nations to the maintenance of international peace and security and to the other purposes of the Organization, and also to equitable geographical distribution.\nThe non-permanent members of the Security Council shall be elected for a term of two years. In the first election of the non-permanent members after the increase of the membership of the Security Council from eleven to fifteen, two of the four additional members shall be chosen for a term of one year. A retiring member shall not be eligible for immediate re-election.\nEach member of the Security Council shall have one representative."}]},{"contentHash":"sha256:d76f30a3ec91422c1506becd5504f2054bd298551bdef3717ebfbb411ee4fda6","edition":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UN_CHARTER_EN","fragmentKind":"article","id":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter#UNC_EN_ART27","kind":"fragment","locator":"article/27","package":"urn:un:corpus:clir:charter","texts":[{"contentHash":"sha256:d2e1200a16b6cc23e35a408e6f305c6a42aec1ae602e3202d05006d4577ea403","language":"en","status":"official","text":"Article 27\nEach member of the Security Council shall have one vote.\nDecisions of the Security Council on procedural matters shall be made by an affirmative vote of nine members.\nDecisions of the Security Council on all other matters shall be made by an affirmative vote of nine members including the concurring votes of the permanent members; provided that, in decisions under Chapter VI, and under paragraph 3 of Article 52, a party to a dispute shall abstain from voting."}]}],"text":"Practice: the letter still blocks"}],"language":"en","question":{"origin":"user","text":"Nine votes in favour: is a procedural decision adopted, and does a permanent member's abstention block a non-procedural one?"},"schemaVersion":"law.answers.document/0.1"}