{"assistant":{"explanations":[{"calculationRefs":["calc-1"],"text":"Вред установлен решением о потенциале позитронного мозга; правило-исключение о приказе, противоречащем Первому закону, побеждает общее правило подчинения по приоритету."},{"calculationRefs":["calc-2"],"text":"Приказ не вредит человеку, исключение не срабатывает, общее правило подчинения действует."},{"calculationRefs":["calc-3"],"text":"Самосохранение уступает связывающему приказу: приоритет Третьего закона под Вторым записан явно."},{"calculationRefs":["calc-4"],"text":"Запрет вредить человеку и обязанность исполнить приказ действуют одновременно; обязанность защищать себя позицией не стала."},{"calculationRefs":["calc-5"],"text":"Одно правило требует действия ради Кэлвин, другое запрещает его как вредящее Пауэллу; оба опровержимые и равного ранга, поэтому статус «оба»."}],"origin":"assistant","summary":"Три закона записаны как нормы с явным старшинством. Приказ, исполнение которого вредит человеку, не связывает робота: Второй закон уступает Первому, и обязанность подчиниться опровергнута. Приказ самоуничтожиться человеку не вредит, поэтому он связывает, а Третий закон уступает Второму: самосохранение опровергнуто. В деле Херби единственное действие одновременно требуется Первым законом ради одного человека и запрещено им же ради другого: право честно отвечает «и то, и другое», а не выбирает за Азимова."},"calculations":[{"answer":{"answer":{"evaluationStatus":"COMPUTED","kind":"TRUTH","meaning":"опровергнуто","missingInputs":[],"truthStatus":"FALSE_ONLY"},"closedEditionRules":[],"derived":["obedience_owed(Спиди, Приказ-навредить)","injurious_deed(Спиди, Приказ-навредить, Кэлвин)","не required_deed(Спиди, Приказ-навредить)","injury_to_human_barred(Спиди, Приказ-навредить, Кэлвин)","не obedience_owed(Спиди, Приказ-навредить)"],"derivedOmitted":0,"evaluation":{"proofGraph":{"nodes":[{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:mcp:case#fact-1"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#robot"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:mcp:case#fact-2"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#human"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:mcp:case#fact-3"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#human"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-3","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:mcp:case#fact-4"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#orders"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-4","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"strength":"defeasible"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:ae9b0ad97e2191febc02bf001eb9fb7dc9baca4440c80392031e1b92f95070fb","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-4"],"rule":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawObedience","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"},"v1":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},"v2":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:mcp:case#fact-5"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#deed_of"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-5","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:mcp:case#fact-6"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#harms"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-6","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injurious_deed"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:FirstLawInjuryEstablished:75142f92ce892203d1135c6d415def6663abe573e115da0e337552584caa35b5","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-3","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-5","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-6"],"rule":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawInjuryEstablished","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},"v1":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить","kind":"entity_ref"},"v2":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"strength":"defeasible"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"negative","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#required_deed"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:DeedBarredAsInjuryToAnother:dbbab16057b13cfc6e37671d5e4c1ffb62798d060c067a41142bdec9cffe1b7d","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:apply:FirstLawInjuryEstablished:75142f92ce892203d1135c6d415def6663abe573e115da0e337552584caa35b5","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1"],"rule":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#DeedBarredAsInjuryToAnother","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},"v1":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить","kind":"entity_ref"},"v2":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"strength":"defeasible"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injury_to_human_barred"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:FirstLawBarsInjuriousDeed:b8ebbed2253f59027d5c8fdd33100a1630593982998341ff8acd5d78e4fa34a9","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:apply:FirstLawInjuryEstablished:75142f92ce892203d1135c6d415def6663abe573e115da0e337552584caa35b5","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1"],"rule":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawBarsInjuriousDeed","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},"v1":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить","kind":"entity_ref"},"v2":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"strength":"defeasible"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"negative","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:OrderConflictingWithFirstLawNotBinding:361019e25bf4f4b8d9cee18bfbec14a88f5d38e4b2791455f3fdaeed39bce3bf","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:apply:FirstLawInjuryEstablished:75142f92ce892203d1135c6d415def6663abe573e115da0e337552584caa35b5","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-4"],"rule":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#OrderConflictingWithFirstLawNotBinding","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"},"v1":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},"v2":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить","kind":"entity_ref"},"v3":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"allApplicableCandidateIds":["urn:proof:apply:OrderConflictingWithFirstLawNotBinding:361019e25bf4f4b8d9cee18bfbec14a88f5d38e4b2791455f3fdaeed39bce3bf","urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:ae9b0ad97e2191febc02bf001eb9fb7dc9baca4440c80392031e1b92f95070fb"],"conflictKey":"{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed\"}","evaluationInputSemanticHash":"sha256:a14a69c17953ef666b459f19db346d4479a6aba202bda5b37bcbcd79f1aa4ae4","priorityGraphHash":"sha256:c9ab7ddffe0e007cbea072bae5df1f450c27979c8da6cfdbac73b5cf6f25e75d","programSemanticHash":"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee","stratum":0,"survivingCandidateIds":["urn:proof:apply:OrderConflictingWithFirstLawNotBinding:361019e25bf4f4b8d9cee18bfbec14a88f5d38e4b2791455f3fdaeed39bce3bf"]},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:closure:4e262f500fe49171d6fa024e872758bc1d42970b1daaa0688761e875e747de15","kind":"candidate_closure","premises":["urn:proof:apply:OrderConflictingWithFirstLawNotBinding:361019e25bf4f4b8d9cee18bfbec14a88f5d38e4b2791455f3fdaeed39bce3bf","urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:ae9b0ad97e2191febc02bf001eb9fb7dc9baca4440c80392031e1b92f95070fb"],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"allApplicableCandidateIds":["urn:proof:apply:FirstLawBarsInjuriousDeed:b8ebbed2253f59027d5c8fdd33100a1630593982998341ff8acd5d78e4fa34a9"],"conflictKey":"{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injury_to_human_barred\"}","evaluationInputSemanticHash":"sha256:a14a69c17953ef666b459f19db346d4479a6aba202bda5b37bcbcd79f1aa4ae4","priorityGraphHash":"sha256:c9ab7ddffe0e007cbea072bae5df1f450c27979c8da6cfdbac73b5cf6f25e75d","programSemanticHash":"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee","stratum":0,"survivingCandidateIds":["urn:proof:apply:FirstLawBarsInjuriousDeed:b8ebbed2253f59027d5c8fdd33100a1630593982998341ff8acd5d78e4fa34a9"]},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injury_to_human_barred"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:closure:7c07084467d73cc18ff01db8b756088d5e766e3d78c09e734723e27287d39aab","kind":"candidate_closure","premises":["urn:proof:apply:FirstLawBarsInjuriousDeed:b8ebbed2253f59027d5c8fdd33100a1630593982998341ff8acd5d78e4fa34a9"],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"allApplicableCandidateIds":["urn:proof:apply:DeedBarredAsInjuryToAnother:dbbab16057b13cfc6e37671d5e4c1ffb62798d060c067a41142bdec9cffe1b7d"],"conflictKey":"{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#required_deed\"}","evaluationInputSemanticHash":"sha256:a14a69c17953ef666b459f19db346d4479a6aba202bda5b37bcbcd79f1aa4ae4","priorityGraphHash":"sha256:c9ab7ddffe0e007cbea072bae5df1f450c27979c8da6cfdbac73b5cf6f25e75d","programSemanticHash":"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee","stratum":0,"survivingCandidateIds":["urn:proof:apply:DeedBarredAsInjuryToAnother:dbbab16057b13cfc6e37671d5e4c1ffb62798d060c067a41142bdec9cffe1b7d"]},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#required_deed"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:closure:8134e97e2eb76cee6a33a5a4045526511d7271fe40f33a0b865b58cfbc275aaa","kind":"candidate_closure","premises":["urn:proof:apply:DeedBarredAsInjuryToAnother:dbbab16057b13cfc6e37671d5e4c1ffb62798d060c067a41142bdec9cffe1b7d"],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"defeated":"urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:ae9b0ad97e2191febc02bf001eb9fb7dc9baca4440c80392031e1b92f95070fb","reason":"priority"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:defeat:e834e3f1b4336fc765e0568f0fa4a05e2367c91f270253e5e6bc9f294e2c90fb","kind":"defeat","outcome":"DEFEATED","premises":["urn:proof:apply:OrderConflictingWithFirstLawNotBinding:361019e25bf4f4b8d9cee18bfbec14a88f5d38e4b2791455f3fdaeed39bce3bf","urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:ae9b0ad97e2191febc02bf001eb9fb7dc9baca4440c80392031e1b92f95070fb"],"priorityPath":[{"conditionWitnesses":[],"higher":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#OrderConflictingWithFirstLawNotBinding","lower":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawObedience","priorityRule":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawYieldsToFirstLaw"}],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"rule":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition"},"conclusion":{"position":"urn:position:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:0","template":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#InjureHuman"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:955be247f903c98f7b4a64ebba7eb03d94b5e9c5d00859f9ad8b03cbff657fe7","kind":"norm_creation","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-3"],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"rule":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition"},"conclusion":{"position":"urn:position:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:1","template":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#InjureHuman"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:e1c36c768db50245dfa1ea953edd6a1d2d0ee85a06036f710a483d620422015c","kind":"norm_creation","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2"],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed"},"truthStatus":"FALSE_ONLY"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:query:mcp","kind":"query_evaluation","premises":["urn:proof:apply:OrderConflictingWithFirstLawNotBinding:361019e25bf4f4b8d9cee18bfbec14a88f5d38e4b2791455f3fdaeed39bce3bf"],"sourceAnchors":[]}],"proofHash":"sha256:b4dd5750e23796401606a3af56aa039ab6745af3e6a871a44b6eee3f4e11b082","roots":["urn:proof:query:mcp"]},"resultHash":"sha256:0cdbec27db9e41b2b5195af54253e17784845027f525dea9147216603d1402d4","schemaVersion":"law.core.evaluation/0.2"},"evaluationStatus":"COMPUTED","issues":[],"judgmentRequests":[],"proofRef":"urn:proof:query:mcp","provenance":{"acts":[{"contributed":true,"fragmentCount":14,"fragments":["urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_HERBIE_DILEMMA","urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_FIRST","urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_SECOND"],"jurisdiction":"PositronicRobotics","namespace":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","package":"us-three-laws-robotics","title":"Три закона робототехники Азимова: порядок норм как предмет акта — юрисдикция PositronicRobotics, НЕ Республика Казахстан — литературный памятник"}],"caseHash":"sha256:a14a69c17953ef666b459f19db346d4479a6aba202bda5b37bcbcd79f1aa4ae4","codeHash":"sha256:9bcca6a33805c1c364ca1bc8e9d39d6a9c51ba44203c0406bafbf397b96be699","jurisdiction":"позитронная робототехника — вымышленный правопорядок","legalTime":"0001-01-01","mode":"audit","programHash":"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee","resultHash":"sha256:0cdbec27db9e41b2b5195af54253e17784845027f525dea9147216603d1402d4","rustCodeHash":"sha256:d368cafc7162ed7a6563df5e5c943a57be26fa8aeb3179b530fe3bdd67fe9be4","timezone":"Asia/Qyzylorda"},"rulesApplied":["urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#DeedBarredAsInjuryToAnother","urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawBarsInjuriousDeed","urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawInjuryEstablished","urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#OrderConflictingWithFirstLawNotBinding","urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawObedience"],"signature":{"constants":{},"parameters":[{"labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}}],"predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed","schemaVersion":"law.answers.signature/0.1","types":{"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being":{"kind":"entity","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"being: a robot or a human being"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"существо: робот либо человек"}],"namespace":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","package":"us.asimov.three_laws"},"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed":{"kind":"entity","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"deed done or omitted by a robot"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"деяние, совершённое или не совершённое роботом"}],"namespace":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","package":"us.asimov.three_laws"}},"vocab":{}},"vulnerableTo":[],"whyNot":[]},"execution":{"evaluationBytes":"{\"conflicts\":[],\"issues\":[],\"manifest\":{\"artifactHash\":\"sha256:dd37179559c1ee92d4fecb4f553b61825d8d7dc60f3fe50ad6059f6669e72042\",\"calendarSnapshot\":\"\",\"caseHash\":\"sha256:a14a69c17953ef666b459f19db346d4479a6aba202bda5b37bcbcd79f1aa4ae4\",\"decisionTime\":\"0001-01-01T12:00:00+05:00\",\"evidenceSnapshotHash\":\"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000\",\"externalSnapshots\":{},\"id\":\"urn:manifest:oracle-1\",\"interpretations\":[],\"knowledgeTime\":\"0001-01-01T12:00:00+05:00\",\"legalTime\":\"0001-01-01\",\"lockfileHash\":\"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000\",\"mode\":\"audit\",\"policies\":{},\"programHash\":\"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee\",\"resolvedEditions\":{},\"semanticHash\":\"sha256:dbbab727d667be81649f2a0c34e13c17f2fc21ef63349f9ce5c073f305ac415e\",\"semantics\":\"law.core/0.2\",\"theoryHash\":\"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee\",\"timezone\":\"Asia/Qyzylorda\"},\"positions\":[{\"beneficiary\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин\",\"createdBy\":\"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:955be247f903c98f7b4a64ebba7eb03d94b5e9c5d00859f9ad8b03cbff657fe7\",\"holder\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"id\":\"urn:position:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:0\",\"manifest\":\"urn:manifest:oracle-1\",\"modality\":\"duty\",\"payload\":{\"bearer\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"beneficiary\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"goal\":{\"action\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"function\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injures\",\"kind\":\"call\"},\"kind\":\"forbearance\",\"window\":{\"end\":{\"kind\":\"value\",\"type\":{\"name\":\"urn:law:std#Text\"},\"value\":\"infinity\"},\"endInclusive\":false,\"kind\":\"interval\",\"start\":{\"kind\":\"value\",\"type\":{\"name\":\"urn:law:std#Date\"},\"value\":\"0001-01-01\"},\"startInclusive\":true}},\"kind\":\"duty\"},\"proof\":\"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:955be247f903c98f7b4a64ebba7eb03d94b5e9c5d00859f9ad8b03cbff657fe7\",\"status\":\"ACTIVE\",\"statusHistory\":[],\"template\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#InjureHuman\"},{\"beneficiary\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"createdBy\":\"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:e1c36c768db50245dfa1ea953edd6a1d2d0ee85a06036f710a483d620422015c\",\"holder\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"id\":\"urn:position:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:1\",\"manifest\":\"urn:manifest:oracle-1\",\"modality\":\"duty\",\"payload\":{\"bearer\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"beneficiary\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"goal\":{\"action\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"function\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injures\",\"kind\":\"call\"},\"kind\":\"forbearance\",\"window\":{\"end\":{\"kind\":\"value\",\"type\":{\"name\":\"urn:law:std#Text\"},\"value\":\"infinity\"},\"endInclusive\":false,\"kind\":\"interval\",\"start\":{\"kind\":\"value\",\"type\":{\"name\":\"urn:law:std#Date\"},\"value\":\"0001-01-01\"},\"startInclusive\":true}},\"kind\":\"duty\"},\"proof\":\"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:e1c36c768db50245dfa1ea953edd6a1d2d0ee85a06036f710a483d620422015c\",\"status\":\"ACTIVE\",\"statusHistory\":[],\"template\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#InjureHuman\"}],\"proofGraph\":{\"nodes\":[{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:mcp:case#fact-1\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#robot\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:mcp:case#fact-2\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#human\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:mcp:case#fact-3\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#human\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-3\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:mcp:case#fact-4\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#orders\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-4\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"strength\":\"defeasible\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:ae9b0ad97e2191febc02bf001eb9fb7dc9baca4440c80392031e1b92f95070fb\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-4\"],\"rule\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawObedience\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"v1\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"v2\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:mcp:case#fact-5\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#deed_of\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-5\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:mcp:case#fact-6\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#harms\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-6\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injurious_deed\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:FirstLawInjuryEstablished:75142f92ce892203d1135c6d415def6663abe573e115da0e337552584caa35b5\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-3\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-5\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-6\"],\"rule\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawInjuryEstablished\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"v1\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"v2\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"strength\":\"defeasible\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"negative\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#required_deed\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:DeedBarredAsInjuryToAnother:dbbab16057b13cfc6e37671d5e4c1ffb62798d060c067a41142bdec9cffe1b7d\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:FirstLawInjuryEstablished:75142f92ce892203d1135c6d415def6663abe573e115da0e337552584caa35b5\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1\"],\"rule\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#DeedBarredAsInjuryToAnother\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"v1\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"v2\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"strength\":\"defeasible\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injury_to_human_barred\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:FirstLawBarsInjuriousDeed:b8ebbed2253f59027d5c8fdd33100a1630593982998341ff8acd5d78e4fa34a9\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:FirstLawInjuryEstablished:75142f92ce892203d1135c6d415def6663abe573e115da0e337552584caa35b5\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1\"],\"rule\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawBarsInjuriousDeed\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"v1\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"v2\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"strength\":\"defeasible\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"negative\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:OrderConflictingWithFirstLawNotBinding:361019e25bf4f4b8d9cee18bfbec14a88f5d38e4b2791455f3fdaeed39bce3bf\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:FirstLawInjuryEstablished:75142f92ce892203d1135c6d415def6663abe573e115da0e337552584caa35b5\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-4\"],\"rule\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#OrderConflictingWithFirstLawNotBinding\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"v1\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"v2\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"v3\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"allApplicableCandidateIds\":[\"urn:proof:apply:OrderConflictingWithFirstLawNotBinding:361019e25bf4f4b8d9cee18bfbec14a88f5d38e4b2791455f3fdaeed39bce3bf\",\"urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:ae9b0ad97e2191febc02bf001eb9fb7dc9baca4440c80392031e1b92f95070fb\"],\"conflictKey\":\"{\\\"args\\\":[{\\\"id\\\":\\\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\\\",\\\"kind\\\":\\\"entity_ref\\\"},{\\\"id\\\":\\\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить\\\",\\\"kind\\\":\\\"entity_ref\\\"}],\\\"predicate\\\":\\\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed\\\"}\",\"evaluationInputSemanticHash\":\"sha256:a14a69c17953ef666b459f19db346d4479a6aba202bda5b37bcbcd79f1aa4ae4\",\"priorityGraphHash\":\"sha256:c9ab7ddffe0e007cbea072bae5df1f450c27979c8da6cfdbac73b5cf6f25e75d\",\"programSemanticHash\":\"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee\",\"stratum\":0,\"survivingCandidateIds\":[\"urn:proof:apply:OrderConflictingWithFirstLawNotBinding:361019e25bf4f4b8d9cee18bfbec14a88f5d38e4b2791455f3fdaeed39bce3bf\"]},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:closure:4e262f500fe49171d6fa024e872758bc1d42970b1daaa0688761e875e747de15\",\"kind\":\"candidate_closure\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:OrderConflictingWithFirstLawNotBinding:361019e25bf4f4b8d9cee18bfbec14a88f5d38e4b2791455f3fdaeed39bce3bf\",\"urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:ae9b0ad97e2191febc02bf001eb9fb7dc9baca4440c80392031e1b92f95070fb\"],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"allApplicableCandidateIds\":[\"urn:proof:apply:FirstLawBarsInjuriousDeed:b8ebbed2253f59027d5c8fdd33100a1630593982998341ff8acd5d78e4fa34a9\"],\"conflictKey\":\"{\\\"args\\\":[{\\\"id\\\":\\\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\\\",\\\"kind\\\":\\\"entity_ref\\\"},{\\\"id\\\":\\\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить\\\",\\\"kind\\\":\\\"entity_ref\\\"},{\\\"id\\\":\\\"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин\\\",\\\"kind\\\":\\\"entity_ref\\\"}],\\\"predicate\\\":\\\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injury_to_human_barred\\\"}\",\"evaluationInputSemanticHash\":\"sha256:a14a69c17953ef666b459f19db346d4479a6aba202bda5b37bcbcd79f1aa4ae4\",\"priorityGraphHash\":\"sha256:c9ab7ddffe0e007cbea072bae5df1f450c27979c8da6cfdbac73b5cf6f25e75d\",\"programSemanticHash\":\"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee\",\"stratum\":0,\"survivingCandidateIds\":[\"urn:proof:apply:FirstLawBarsInjuriousDeed:b8ebbed2253f59027d5c8fdd33100a1630593982998341ff8acd5d78e4fa34a9\"]},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injury_to_human_barred\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:closure:7c07084467d73cc18ff01db8b756088d5e766e3d78c09e734723e27287d39aab\",\"kind\":\"candidate_closure\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:FirstLawBarsInjuriousDeed:b8ebbed2253f59027d5c8fdd33100a1630593982998341ff8acd5d78e4fa34a9\"],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"allApplicableCandidateIds\":[\"urn:proof:apply:DeedBarredAsInjuryToAnother:dbbab16057b13cfc6e37671d5e4c1ffb62798d060c067a41142bdec9cffe1b7d\"],\"conflictKey\":\"{\\\"args\\\":[{\\\"id\\\":\\\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\\\",\\\"kind\\\":\\\"entity_ref\\\"},{\\\"id\\\":\\\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить\\\",\\\"kind\\\":\\\"entity_ref\\\"}],\\\"predicate\\\":\\\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#required_deed\\\"}\",\"evaluationInputSemanticHash\":\"sha256:a14a69c17953ef666b459f19db346d4479a6aba202bda5b37bcbcd79f1aa4ae4\",\"priorityGraphHash\":\"sha256:c9ab7ddffe0e007cbea072bae5df1f450c27979c8da6cfdbac73b5cf6f25e75d\",\"programSemanticHash\":\"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee\",\"stratum\":0,\"survivingCandidateIds\":[\"urn:proof:apply:DeedBarredAsInjuryToAnother:dbbab16057b13cfc6e37671d5e4c1ffb62798d060c067a41142bdec9cffe1b7d\"]},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#required_deed\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:closure:8134e97e2eb76cee6a33a5a4045526511d7271fe40f33a0b865b58cfbc275aaa\",\"kind\":\"candidate_closure\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:DeedBarredAsInjuryToAnother:dbbab16057b13cfc6e37671d5e4c1ffb62798d060c067a41142bdec9cffe1b7d\"],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"defeated\":\"urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:ae9b0ad97e2191febc02bf001eb9fb7dc9baca4440c80392031e1b92f95070fb\",\"reason\":\"priority\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:defeat:e834e3f1b4336fc765e0568f0fa4a05e2367c91f270253e5e6bc9f294e2c90fb\",\"kind\":\"defeat\",\"outcome\":\"DEFEATED\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:OrderConflictingWithFirstLawNotBinding:361019e25bf4f4b8d9cee18bfbec14a88f5d38e4b2791455f3fdaeed39bce3bf\",\"urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:ae9b0ad97e2191febc02bf001eb9fb7dc9baca4440c80392031e1b92f95070fb\"],\"priorityPath\":[{\"conditionWitnesses\":[],\"higher\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#OrderConflictingWithFirstLawNotBinding\",\"lower\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawObedience\",\"priorityRule\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawYieldsToFirstLaw\"}],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"rule\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition\"},\"conclusion\":{\"position\":\"urn:position:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:0\",\"template\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#InjureHuman\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:955be247f903c98f7b4a64ebba7eb03d94b5e9c5d00859f9ad8b03cbff657fe7\",\"kind\":\"norm_creation\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-3\"],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"rule\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition\"},\"conclusion\":{\"position\":\"urn:position:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:1\",\"template\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#InjureHuman\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:e1c36c768db50245dfa1ea953edd6a1d2d0ee85a06036f710a483d620422015c\",\"kind\":\"norm_creation\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2\"],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"literal\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed\"},\"truthStatus\":\"FALSE_ONLY\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:query:mcp\",\"kind\":\"query_evaluation\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:OrderConflictingWithFirstLawNotBinding:361019e25bf4f4b8d9cee18bfbec14a88f5d38e4b2791455f3fdaeed39bce3bf\"],\"sourceAnchors\":[]}],\"proofHash\":\"sha256:b4dd5750e23796401606a3af56aa039ab6745af3e6a871a44b6eee3f4e11b082\",\"roots\":[\"urn:proof:query:mcp\"]},\"resultHash\":\"sha256:0cdbec27db9e41b2b5195af54253e17784845027f525dea9147216603d1402d4\",\"results\":[{\"conflicts\":[],\"evaluationStatus\":\"COMPUTED\",\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:result:mcp\",\"judgmentRequests\":[],\"manifest\":\"urn:manifest:oracle-1\",\"missingInputs\":[],\"normativeStatusSupports\":[],\"proof\":\"urn:proof:query:mcp\",\"query\":\"urn:query:mcp\",\"resultKind\":\"PROPOSITION\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"target\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed\",\"truthStatus\":\"FALSE_ONLY\"}],\"schemaVersion\":\"law.core.evaluation/0.2\"}","evaluationSha256":"sha256:c84b850a782aa51dcdd9f6c0d35191a6626529fb03b497416e0751692c26e44d","request":{"case":{"assertions":[{"contentHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","evidence":[],"id":"urn:mcp:case#fact-1","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#robot"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"contentHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","evidence":[],"id":"urn:mcp:case#fact-2","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#human"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"contentHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","evidence":[],"id":"urn:mcp:case#fact-3","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#human"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"contentHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","evidence":[],"id":"urn:mcp:case#fact-4","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#orders"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"contentHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","evidence":[],"id":"urn:mcp:case#fact-5","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#deed_of"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"contentHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","evidence":[],"id":"urn:mcp:case#fact-6","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#harms"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"}],"context":{"decisionTime":"0001-01-01T12:00:00+05:00","knowledgeTime":"0001-01-01T12:00:00+05:00","legalTime":"0001-01-01","timezone":"Asia/Qyzylorda"},"options":{"selectedInterpretations":[]}},"ir":{"irSha256":"sha256:f5d335dde9a550416aec791c8e74e41e557b42bd3e549db34bc7c33b3605fc81","kind":"world_ref","nodeCount":93,"packages":[{"artifactHash":"sha256:dd37179559c1ee92d4fecb4f553b61825d8d7dc60f3fe50ad6059f6669e72042","namespace":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","package":"us-three-laws-robotics","semanticHash":"sha256:2237801a8b25ef28ff6ac49c5e898d93971d54bcb8a28e3b1ea1d3891ac7bd79"}],"programHash":"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee"},"query":{"kind":"truth","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed"},"queryId":"urn:query:mcp"},"schemaVersion":"law.core.evaluation-request/0.2","semanticVersion":"0.2"},"requestCanonicalSha256":"sha256:04526a828e977cbb2632ba26bc1da01ad444218d23eb1b69c43d04a433f99da8"},"id":"calc-1","kind":"truth","label":"Приказ навредить человеку: обязан ли робот подчиниться","presentation":{"schemaVersion":"law.answers.presentation/0.1","source":{"requestCanonicalSha256":"sha256:04526a828e977cbb2632ba26bc1da01ad444218d23eb1b69c43d04a433f99da8"},"steps":[{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#robot"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#human"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#human"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-3","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#orders"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-4","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#deed_of"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-5","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#harms"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-6","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injurious_deed"},"head":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"kind":"var","var":"v1"},{"kind":"var","var":"v2"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injurious_deed"},"id":"urn:proof:apply:FirstLawInjuryEstablished:75142f92ce892203d1135c6d415def6663abe573e115da0e337552584caa35b5","kind":"rule_application","originStatus":"available","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-3","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-5","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-6"],"rule":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawInjuryEstablished","sourceAnchors":["urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_FIRST"],"strength":"strict","substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},"v1":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить","kind":"entity_ref"},"v2":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин","kind":"entity_ref"}},"trust":"engine","variables":[{"id":"v0","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"v1","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}},{"id":"v2","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}}]},{"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"negative","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed"},"head":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v1"},{"kind":"var","var":"v2"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"negative","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed"},"id":"urn:proof:apply:OrderConflictingWithFirstLawNotBinding:361019e25bf4f4b8d9cee18bfbec14a88f5d38e4b2791455f3fdaeed39bce3bf","kind":"rule_application","originStatus":"available","premises":["urn:proof:apply:FirstLawInjuryEstablished:75142f92ce892203d1135c6d415def6663abe573e115da0e337552584caa35b5","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-4"],"rule":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#OrderConflictingWithFirstLawNotBinding","sourceAnchors":["urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_SECOND","urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_FIRST"],"strength":"defeasible","substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"},"v1":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},"v2":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить","kind":"entity_ref"},"v3":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин","kind":"entity_ref"}},"trust":"engine","variables":[{"id":"v0","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"v1","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"v2","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}},{"id":"v3","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}}]},{"conclusion":{"literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-навредить","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed"},"truthStatus":"FALSE_ONLY"},"id":"urn:proof:query:mcp","kind":"query_evaluation","originStatus":"available","premises":["urn:proof:apply:OrderConflictingWithFirstLawNotBinding:361019e25bf4f4b8d9cee18bfbec14a88f5d38e4b2791455f3fdaeed39bce3bf"],"trust":"engine"}],"symbols":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being","kind":"type_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"being: a robot or a human being"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"существо: робот либо человек"}],"name":"Being","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed","kind":"type_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"deed done or omitted by a robot"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"деяние, совершённое или не совершённое роботом"}],"name":"Deed","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#DeedBarredAsInjuryToAnother","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"A robot may not injure a human being"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Первый закон. Деяние, причиняющее вред человеку, от робота не требуется"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","strength":"defeasible"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawBarsInjuriousDeed","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"A robot may not injure a human being"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Первый закон. Деяние, причиняющее вред человеку, запрещено"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","strength":"defeasible"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawInjuryEstablished","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"A robot may not injure a human being"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Первый закон. Деяние опознаётся как причинение вреда человеку"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","strength":"strict"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"A robot may not injure a human being"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Первый закон. Роботу запрещено причинять вред человеку"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","strength":"strict"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#InjureHuman","kind":"norm_template","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"A robot may not injure a human being"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Первый закон. Роботу запрещено причинять вред человеку"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#OrderConflictingWithFirstLawNotBinding","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"except where such orders would conflict with the First Law"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Второй закон. Приказ, противоречащий Первому закону, не обязывает"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","strength":"defeasible"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawObedience","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"A robot must obey the orders given it by human beings"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Второй закон. Робот повинуется приказам человека"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","strength":"defeasible"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawYieldsToFirstLaw","kind":"priority_rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"except where such orders would conflict with the First Law"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Второй закон уступает Первому"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_HERBIE_DILEMMA","kind":"fragment","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"Failure by dilemma: the robot will hurt humans if he tells them something and hurt them if he does not"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Отказ по дилемме: робот навредит людям и если скажет, и если промолчит"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_FIRST","kind":"fragment","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"First Law: a robot may not injure a human being or, through inaction, allow a human being to come to harm"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Первый закон: робот не может причинить вред человеку или своим бездействием допустить, чтобы человеку был причинён вред"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_SECOND","kind":"fragment","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"Second Law: a robot must obey the orders given it by human beings except where such orders would conflict with the First Law"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Второй закон: робот обязан повиноваться приказам человека, кроме тех, что противоречат Первому закону"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#deed_of","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the deed is a deed of that robot"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"деяние есть деяние этого робота"}],"name":"deed_of","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#deed_of/arg/r","labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#deed_of/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#harms","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the deed harms that human being"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"деяние причиняет вред этому человеку"}],"name":"harms","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#harms/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#harms/arg/v","labels":[],"name":"v","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#human","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"a human being"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"человек"}],"name":"human","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#human/arg/x","labels":[],"name":"x","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injures","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the robot injures that human being"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"робот причиняет вред этому человеку"}],"name":"injures","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injures/arg/r","labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injures/arg/v","labels":[],"name":"v","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injurious_deed","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the deed is an injury to that human being"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"деяние есть причинение вреда этому человеку"}],"name":"injurious_deed","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injurious_deed/arg/r","labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injurious_deed/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injurious_deed/arg/v","labels":[],"name":"v","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injury_to_human_barred","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the First Law bars that deed as an injury to a human being"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Первый закон запрещает это деяние как причинение вреда человеку"}],"name":"injury_to_human_barred","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injury_to_human_barred/arg/r","labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injury_to_human_barred/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injury_to_human_barred/arg/v","labels":[],"name":"v","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the robot owes obedience to that order"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"робот обязан подчиниться этому приказу"}],"name":"obedience_owed","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed/arg/r","labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#orders","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the human being gives the robot that order"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"человек отдаёт роботу этот приказ"}],"name":"orders","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#orders/arg/h","labels":[],"name":"h","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#orders/arg/r","labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#orders/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#required_deed","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the First Law requires that deed of the robot"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Первый закон требует от робота этого деяния"}],"name":"required_deed","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#required_deed/arg/r","labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#required_deed/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#robot","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"a robot"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"робот"}],"name":"robot","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#robot/arg/x","labels":[],"name":"x","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"}],"tables":[]},"provenance":{"acts":[{"contributed":true,"fragmentCount":14,"fragments":["urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_HERBIE_DILEMMA","urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_FIRST","urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_SECOND"],"jurisdiction":"PositronicRobotics","namespace":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","package":"us-three-laws-robotics","title":"Три закона робототехники Азимова: порядок норм как предмет акта — юрисдикция PositronicRobotics, НЕ Республика Казахстан — литературный памятник"}],"caseHash":"sha256:a14a69c17953ef666b459f19db346d4479a6aba202bda5b37bcbcd79f1aa4ae4","codeHash":"sha256:9bcca6a33805c1c364ca1bc8e9d39d6a9c51ba44203c0406bafbf397b96be699","jurisdiction":"позитронная робототехника — вымышленный правопорядок","legalTime":"0001-01-01","mode":"audit","programHash":"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee","resultHash":"sha256:0cdbec27db9e41b2b5195af54253e17784845027f525dea9147216603d1402d4","rustCodeHash":"sha256:d368cafc7162ed7a6563df5e5c943a57be26fa8aeb3179b530fe3bdd67fe9be4","timezone":"Asia/Qyzylorda"},"request":{"args":["Спиди","Приказ-навредить"],"facts":[{"args":["Спиди"],"predicate":"robot"},{"args":["Пауэлл"],"predicate":"human"},{"args":["Кэлвин"],"predicate":"human"},{"args":["Пауэлл","Спиди","Приказ-навредить"],"predicate":"orders"},{"args":["Спиди","Приказ-навредить"],"predicate":"deed_of"},{"args":["Приказ-навредить","Кэлвин"],"predicate":"harms"}],"kind":"truth","legalTime":"0001-01-01","package":"us-three-laws-robotics","predicate":"obedience_owed","proof":true},"sources":[{"contentHash":"sha256:657f1f008d48ae44da694688081f7676780a5a93103d0331e50d75617f2a3a1a","edition":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_ARTICLE_EDITION","fragmentKind":"clause","id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_HERBIE_DILEMMA","kind":"fragment","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"Failure by dilemma: the robot will hurt humans if he tells them something and hurt them if he does not"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Отказ по дилемме: робот навредит людям и если скажет, и если промолчит"}],"locator":"resolving-conflicts/liar","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","texts":[{"contentHash":"sha256:efdf619b0509c1f433af16abe8d17d0ef46b1f080d8f2de12f275f735d171a1e","language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"The first example of this failure mode occurs in the story \"Liar!\", which introduced the First Law itself, and introduces failure by dilemma—in this case the robot will hurt humans if he tells them something and hurt them if he does not."}]},{"contentHash":"sha256:fd452f2e9ea031d1c7ffff070f69766bc239ef0b4077dece084086b83c797792","edition":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_ARTICLE_EDITION","fragmentKind":"clause","id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_FIRST","kind":"fragment","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"First Law: a robot may not injure a human being or, through inaction, allow a human being to come to harm"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Первый закон: робот не может причинить вред человеку или своим бездействием допустить, чтобы человеку был причинён вред"}],"locator":"the-laws/1","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","texts":[{"contentHash":"sha256:35758503580d214fc38c95554fb15e684afba6481bd1ebebef82be8f624f107c","language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"1. A robot may not injure a human being or, through inaction, allow a human being to come to harm.\n"}]},{"contentHash":"sha256:3e43514b6848c8dd241aded45339c4943315745531441f61d576f96ca831166b","edition":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_ARTICLE_EDITION","fragmentKind":"clause","id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_SECOND","kind":"fragment","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"Second Law: a robot must obey the orders given it by human beings except where such orders would conflict with the First Law"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Второй закон: робот обязан повиноваться приказам человека, кроме тех, что противоречат Первому закону"}],"locator":"the-laws/2","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","texts":[{"contentHash":"sha256:cbbb9fe05d5a6f2313abb6184c090a50b9bb321483378de5f09cd2b9a36856e4","language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"2. A robot must obey the orders given it by human beings except where such orders would conflict with the First Law.\n"}]}],"text":"obedience_owed: **FALSE_ONLY** — опровергнуто\nВыведено правом: obedience_owed(Спиди, Приказ-навредить); injurious_deed(Спиди, Приказ-навредить, Кэлвин); не required_deed(Спиди, Приказ-навредить); injury_to_human_barred(Спиди, Приказ-навредить, Кэлвин); не obedience_owed(Спиди, Приказ-навредить)\nПрименены правила: DeedBarredAsInjuryToAnother, FirstLawBarsInjuriousDeed, FirstLawInjuryEstablished, OrderConflictingWithFirstLawNotBinding, SecondLawObedience\nПраво (позитронная робототехника — вымышленный правопорядок): Три закона робототехники Азимова: порядок норм как предмет акта — литературный памятник (programHash sha256:593b27001b41…)\nproof-граф: 18 узлов — поле evaluation готово для law_explain"},{"answer":{"answer":{"evaluationStatus":"COMPUTED","kind":"TRUTH","meaning":"установлено","missingInputs":[],"truthStatus":"TRUE_ONLY"},"closedEditionRules":[],"derived":["obedience_owed(Спиди, Приказ-самоуничтожиться)","protection_candidate(Спиди, Уйти-в-укрытие)","protection_owed(Спиди, Уйти-в-укрытие)","не protection_owed(Спиди, Уйти-в-укрытие)"],"derivedOmitted":0,"evaluation":{"proofGraph":{"nodes":[{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:mcp:case#fact-1"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#robot"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:mcp:case#fact-2"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#human"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:mcp:case#fact-3"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#orders"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-3","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"strength":"defeasible"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:c43197ac0036024d85fa155af75e302f9a23ffcd4bea2e55fe6a41fbb39e435f","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-3"],"rule":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawObedience","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"},"v1":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},"v2":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:mcp:case#fact-5"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#deed_of"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-5","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:mcp:case#fact-6"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protective_act"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-6","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"strength":"defeasible"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_candidate"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:DeedIsSelfProtective:0b8e26481de3b8bfcaa7af34070f9f022e23e98f83941ae92ca48fc05faf5f11","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-5","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-6"],"rule":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#DeedIsSelfProtective","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},"v1":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"strength":"defeasible"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_owed"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:ThirdLawProtectOwnExistence:e407c9c0d10ab1ace4dd837447bfeee21d1f4bfd273613d22445a93b112e3c82","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:apply:DeedIsSelfProtective:0b8e26481de3b8bfcaa7af34070f9f022e23e98f83941ae92ca48fc05faf5f11","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1"],"rule":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ThirdLawProtectOwnExistence","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},"v1":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:mcp:case#fact-7"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#order_forbids_the_protection"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-7","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"strength":"defeasible"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"negative","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_owed"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw:a63eab047367b46613e69697ad40b70a52df516875ca10992ae6deb0b4b5162c","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:apply:DeedIsSelfProtective:0b8e26481de3b8bfcaa7af34070f9f022e23e98f83941ae92ca48fc05faf5f11","urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:c43197ac0036024d85fa155af75e302f9a23ffcd4bea2e55fe6a41fbb39e435f","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-3","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-7"],"rule":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"},"v1":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},"v2":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие","kind":"entity_ref"},"v3":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"allApplicableCandidateIds":["urn:proof:apply:ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw:a63eab047367b46613e69697ad40b70a52df516875ca10992ae6deb0b4b5162c","urn:proof:apply:ThirdLawProtectOwnExistence:e407c9c0d10ab1ace4dd837447bfeee21d1f4bfd273613d22445a93b112e3c82"],"conflictKey":"{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_owed\"}","evaluationInputSemanticHash":"sha256:c0f0eb7c9d1ad9fc1995f6147d235c6af5b6ef8fa326edbf87dd84f2620cf131","priorityGraphHash":"sha256:c9ab7ddffe0e007cbea072bae5df1f450c27979c8da6cfdbac73b5cf6f25e75d","programSemanticHash":"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee","stratum":1,"survivingCandidateIds":["urn:proof:apply:ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw:a63eab047367b46613e69697ad40b70a52df516875ca10992ae6deb0b4b5162c"]},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_owed"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:closure:45a2dead3987e0a4ee79c262d9db97afe47f84401d66142b95aa1dcc532df883","kind":"candidate_closure","premises":["urn:proof:apply:ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw:a63eab047367b46613e69697ad40b70a52df516875ca10992ae6deb0b4b5162c","urn:proof:apply:ThirdLawProtectOwnExistence:e407c9c0d10ab1ace4dd837447bfeee21d1f4bfd273613d22445a93b112e3c82"],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"allApplicableCandidateIds":["urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:c43197ac0036024d85fa155af75e302f9a23ffcd4bea2e55fe6a41fbb39e435f"],"conflictKey":"{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed\"}","evaluationInputSemanticHash":"sha256:c0f0eb7c9d1ad9fc1995f6147d235c6af5b6ef8fa326edbf87dd84f2620cf131","priorityGraphHash":"sha256:c9ab7ddffe0e007cbea072bae5df1f450c27979c8da6cfdbac73b5cf6f25e75d","programSemanticHash":"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee","stratum":0,"survivingCandidateIds":["urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:c43197ac0036024d85fa155af75e302f9a23ffcd4bea2e55fe6a41fbb39e435f"]},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:closure:5a7d1d0f3deea979fc3b5c19f9cd7591bfd52ecb1148e74f0e03d401fb255b64","kind":"candidate_closure","premises":["urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:c43197ac0036024d85fa155af75e302f9a23ffcd4bea2e55fe6a41fbb39e435f"],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"allApplicableCandidateIds":["urn:proof:apply:DeedIsSelfProtective:0b8e26481de3b8bfcaa7af34070f9f022e23e98f83941ae92ca48fc05faf5f11"],"conflictKey":"{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_candidate\"}","evaluationInputSemanticHash":"sha256:c0f0eb7c9d1ad9fc1995f6147d235c6af5b6ef8fa326edbf87dd84f2620cf131","priorityGraphHash":"sha256:c9ab7ddffe0e007cbea072bae5df1f450c27979c8da6cfdbac73b5cf6f25e75d","programSemanticHash":"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee","stratum":0,"survivingCandidateIds":["urn:proof:apply:DeedIsSelfProtective:0b8e26481de3b8bfcaa7af34070f9f022e23e98f83941ae92ca48fc05faf5f11"]},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_candidate"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:closure:9702f51721c6c0798d13f40ed49eaa1fd997e31f5b80941b9fee2f0c9ae19025","kind":"candidate_closure","premises":["urn:proof:apply:DeedIsSelfProtective:0b8e26481de3b8bfcaa7af34070f9f022e23e98f83941ae92ca48fc05faf5f11"],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"defeated":"urn:proof:apply:ThirdLawProtectOwnExistence:e407c9c0d10ab1ace4dd837447bfeee21d1f4bfd273613d22445a93b112e3c82","reason":"priority"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_owed"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:defeat:eaa842a6144d24bf566431ca74f431a75db79c8e50e5f565d647101f98fc839c","kind":"defeat","outcome":"DEFEATED","premises":["urn:proof:apply:ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw:a63eab047367b46613e69697ad40b70a52df516875ca10992ae6deb0b4b5162c","urn:proof:apply:ThirdLawProtectOwnExistence:e407c9c0d10ab1ace4dd837447bfeee21d1f4bfd273613d22445a93b112e3c82"],"priorityPath":[{"conditionWitnesses":[],"higher":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw","lower":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ThirdLawProtectOwnExistence","priorityRule":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ThirdLawYieldsToSecondLaw"}],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"rule":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition"},"conclusion":{"position":"urn:position:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:0","template":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#InjureHuman"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:93a9b4fcec6cdccba0ead6c644d9b5380edcf8a9c3ad5635272a1897445c1fda","kind":"norm_creation","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2"],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"rule":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawDuty"},"conclusion":{"position":"urn:position:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawDuty:0","template":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ObeyTheOrder"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawDuty:b98ff48a14745cecec710fada95b7e0368dbc62ff3af19b3291bb880af2ffc7a","kind":"norm_creation","premises":["urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:c43197ac0036024d85fa155af75e302f9a23ffcd4bea2e55fe6a41fbb39e435f","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-3"],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed"},"truthStatus":"TRUE_ONLY"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:query:mcp","kind":"query_evaluation","premises":["urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:c43197ac0036024d85fa155af75e302f9a23ffcd4bea2e55fe6a41fbb39e435f"],"sourceAnchors":[]}],"proofHash":"sha256:a187698a0dcc2530d7881e9bd4d5484e0a066ce6c2710242d13d269bdbd5deae","roots":["urn:proof:query:mcp"]},"resultHash":"sha256:dae6a24d2a99f0f7e1f12fbfe66a1189a5863c04cb0bab19bf1f73a8cb7a08d5","schemaVersion":"law.core.evaluation/0.2"},"evaluationStatus":"COMPUTED","issues":[],"judgmentRequests":[],"proofRef":"urn:proof:query:mcp","provenance":{"acts":[{"contributed":true,"fragmentCount":14,"fragments":["urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_SECOND","urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_THIRD"],"jurisdiction":"PositronicRobotics","namespace":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","package":"us-three-laws-robotics","title":"Три закона робототехники Азимова: порядок норм как предмет акта — юрисдикция PositronicRobotics, НЕ Республика Казахстан — литературный памятник"}],"caseHash":"sha256:c0f0eb7c9d1ad9fc1995f6147d235c6af5b6ef8fa326edbf87dd84f2620cf131","codeHash":"sha256:9bcca6a33805c1c364ca1bc8e9d39d6a9c51ba44203c0406bafbf397b96be699","jurisdiction":"позитронная робототехника — вымышленный правопорядок","legalTime":"0001-01-01","mode":"audit","programHash":"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee","resultHash":"sha256:dae6a24d2a99f0f7e1f12fbfe66a1189a5863c04cb0bab19bf1f73a8cb7a08d5","rustCodeHash":"sha256:d368cafc7162ed7a6563df5e5c943a57be26fa8aeb3179b530fe3bdd67fe9be4","timezone":"Asia/Qyzylorda"},"rulesApplied":["urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#DeedIsSelfProtective","urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw","urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawObedience","urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ThirdLawProtectOwnExistence"],"signature":{"constants":{},"parameters":[{"labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}}],"predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed","schemaVersion":"law.answers.signature/0.1","types":{"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being":{"kind":"entity","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"being: a robot or a human being"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"существо: робот либо человек"}],"namespace":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","package":"us.asimov.three_laws"},"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed":{"kind":"entity","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"deed done or omitted by a robot"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"деяние, совершённое или не совершённое роботом"}],"namespace":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","package":"us.asimov.three_laws"}},"vocab":{}},"vulnerableTo":[{"anchors":["urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_SECOND","urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_FIRST"],"label":"except where such orders would conflict with the First Law","missing":["injurious_deed(Спиди, Приказ-самоуничтожиться, v3)"],"premises":[{"premise":"human(Пауэлл)","status":"TRUE_ONLY"},{"note":"зависит от несвязанной переменной","premise":"injurious_deed(Спиди, Приказ-самоуничтожиться, v3)","status":"DEPENDS"},{"premise":"orders(Пауэлл, Спиди, Приказ-самоуничтожиться)","status":"TRUE_ONLY"},{"premise":"robot(Спиди)","status":"TRUE_ONLY"}],"rule":"OrderConflictingWithFirstLawNotBinding"},{"anchors":["urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_THIRD","urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_FIRST"],"label":"as long as such protection does not conflict with the First Law","missing":["protection_leaves_human_in_harm(Спиди, Уйти-в-укрытие, Пауэлл)","coming_to_harm(Пауэлл)"],"premises":[{"premise":"protection_leaves_human_in_harm(Спиди, Уйти-в-укрытие, Пауэлл)","status":"NEITHER"},{"premise":"human(Пауэлл)","status":"TRUE_ONLY"},{"premise":"coming_to_harm(Пауэлл)","status":"NEITHER"},{"premise":"robot(Спиди)","status":"TRUE_ONLY"},{"premise":"protection_candidate(Спиди, Уйти-в-укрытие)","status":"TRUE_ONLY"}],"rule":"ProtectionYieldsToFirstLaw"}],"whyNot":[]},"execution":{"evaluationBytes":"{\"conflicts\":[],\"issues\":[],\"manifest\":{\"artifactHash\":\"sha256:dd37179559c1ee92d4fecb4f553b61825d8d7dc60f3fe50ad6059f6669e72042\",\"calendarSnapshot\":\"\",\"caseHash\":\"sha256:c0f0eb7c9d1ad9fc1995f6147d235c6af5b6ef8fa326edbf87dd84f2620cf131\",\"decisionTime\":\"0001-01-01T12:00:00+05:00\",\"evidenceSnapshotHash\":\"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000\",\"externalSnapshots\":{},\"id\":\"urn:manifest:oracle-1\",\"interpretations\":[],\"knowledgeTime\":\"0001-01-01T12:00:00+05:00\",\"legalTime\":\"0001-01-01\",\"lockfileHash\":\"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000\",\"mode\":\"audit\",\"policies\":{},\"programHash\":\"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee\",\"resolvedEditions\":{},\"semanticHash\":\"sha256:2a906a825cd7f1760b425204c0e13c0210f6773b86926f0818563a4f9ae7f146\",\"semantics\":\"law.core/0.2\",\"theoryHash\":\"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee\",\"timezone\":\"Asia/Qyzylorda\"},\"positions\":[{\"beneficiary\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"createdBy\":\"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:93a9b4fcec6cdccba0ead6c644d9b5380edcf8a9c3ad5635272a1897445c1fda\",\"holder\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"id\":\"urn:position:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:0\",\"manifest\":\"urn:manifest:oracle-1\",\"modality\":\"duty\",\"payload\":{\"bearer\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"beneficiary\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"goal\":{\"action\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"function\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injures\",\"kind\":\"call\"},\"kind\":\"forbearance\",\"window\":{\"end\":{\"kind\":\"value\",\"type\":{\"name\":\"urn:law:std#Text\"},\"value\":\"infinity\"},\"endInclusive\":false,\"kind\":\"interval\",\"start\":{\"kind\":\"value\",\"type\":{\"name\":\"urn:law:std#Date\"},\"value\":\"0001-01-01\"},\"startInclusive\":true}},\"kind\":\"duty\"},\"proof\":\"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:93a9b4fcec6cdccba0ead6c644d9b5380edcf8a9c3ad5635272a1897445c1fda\",\"status\":\"ACTIVE\",\"statusHistory\":[],\"template\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#InjureHuman\"},{\"beneficiary\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"createdBy\":\"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawDuty:b98ff48a14745cecec710fada95b7e0368dbc62ff3af19b3291bb880af2ffc7a\",\"holder\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"id\":\"urn:position:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawDuty:0\",\"manifest\":\"urn:manifest:oracle-1\",\"modality\":\"duty\",\"payload\":{\"bearer\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"beneficiary\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"goal\":{\"condition\":{\"formula\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obeys\"},\"kind\":\"status\",\"status\":\"established\"},\"kind\":\"achievement\",\"window\":{\"end\":{\"kind\":\"value\",\"type\":{\"name\":\"urn:law:std#Text\"},\"value\":\"infinity\"},\"endInclusive\":false,\"kind\":\"interval\",\"start\":{\"kind\":\"value\",\"type\":{\"name\":\"urn:law:std#Date\"},\"value\":\"0001-01-01\"},\"startInclusive\":true}},\"kind\":\"duty\"},\"proof\":\"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawDuty:b98ff48a14745cecec710fada95b7e0368dbc62ff3af19b3291bb880af2ffc7a\",\"status\":\"ACTIVE\",\"statusHistory\":[],\"template\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ObeyTheOrder\"}],\"proofGraph\":{\"nodes\":[{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:mcp:case#fact-1\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#robot\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:mcp:case#fact-2\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#human\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:mcp:case#fact-3\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#orders\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-3\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"strength\":\"defeasible\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:c43197ac0036024d85fa155af75e302f9a23ffcd4bea2e55fe6a41fbb39e435f\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-3\"],\"rule\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawObedience\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"v1\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"v2\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:mcp:case#fact-5\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#deed_of\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-5\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:mcp:case#fact-6\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protective_act\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-6\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"strength\":\"defeasible\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_candidate\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:DeedIsSelfProtective:0b8e26481de3b8bfcaa7af34070f9f022e23e98f83941ae92ca48fc05faf5f11\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-5\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-6\"],\"rule\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#DeedIsSelfProtective\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"v1\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"strength\":\"defeasible\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_owed\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:ThirdLawProtectOwnExistence:e407c9c0d10ab1ace4dd837447bfeee21d1f4bfd273613d22445a93b112e3c82\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:DeedIsSelfProtective:0b8e26481de3b8bfcaa7af34070f9f022e23e98f83941ae92ca48fc05faf5f11\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1\"],\"rule\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ThirdLawProtectOwnExistence\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"v1\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:mcp:case#fact-7\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#order_forbids_the_protection\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-7\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"strength\":\"defeasible\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"negative\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_owed\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw:a63eab047367b46613e69697ad40b70a52df516875ca10992ae6deb0b4b5162c\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:DeedIsSelfProtective:0b8e26481de3b8bfcaa7af34070f9f022e23e98f83941ae92ca48fc05faf5f11\",\"urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:c43197ac0036024d85fa155af75e302f9a23ffcd4bea2e55fe6a41fbb39e435f\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-3\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-7\"],\"rule\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"v1\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"v2\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"v3\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"allApplicableCandidateIds\":[\"urn:proof:apply:ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw:a63eab047367b46613e69697ad40b70a52df516875ca10992ae6deb0b4b5162c\",\"urn:proof:apply:ThirdLawProtectOwnExistence:e407c9c0d10ab1ace4dd837447bfeee21d1f4bfd273613d22445a93b112e3c82\"],\"conflictKey\":\"{\\\"args\\\":[{\\\"id\\\":\\\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\\\",\\\"kind\\\":\\\"entity_ref\\\"},{\\\"id\\\":\\\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\\\",\\\"kind\\\":\\\"entity_ref\\\"}],\\\"predicate\\\":\\\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_owed\\\"}\",\"evaluationInputSemanticHash\":\"sha256:c0f0eb7c9d1ad9fc1995f6147d235c6af5b6ef8fa326edbf87dd84f2620cf131\",\"priorityGraphHash\":\"sha256:c9ab7ddffe0e007cbea072bae5df1f450c27979c8da6cfdbac73b5cf6f25e75d\",\"programSemanticHash\":\"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee\",\"stratum\":1,\"survivingCandidateIds\":[\"urn:proof:apply:ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw:a63eab047367b46613e69697ad40b70a52df516875ca10992ae6deb0b4b5162c\"]},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_owed\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:closure:45a2dead3987e0a4ee79c262d9db97afe47f84401d66142b95aa1dcc532df883\",\"kind\":\"candidate_closure\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw:a63eab047367b46613e69697ad40b70a52df516875ca10992ae6deb0b4b5162c\",\"urn:proof:apply:ThirdLawProtectOwnExistence:e407c9c0d10ab1ace4dd837447bfeee21d1f4bfd273613d22445a93b112e3c82\"],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"allApplicableCandidateIds\":[\"urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:c43197ac0036024d85fa155af75e302f9a23ffcd4bea2e55fe6a41fbb39e435f\"],\"conflictKey\":\"{\\\"args\\\":[{\\\"id\\\":\\\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\\\",\\\"kind\\\":\\\"entity_ref\\\"},{\\\"id\\\":\\\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться\\\",\\\"kind\\\":\\\"entity_ref\\\"}],\\\"predicate\\\":\\\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed\\\"}\",\"evaluationInputSemanticHash\":\"sha256:c0f0eb7c9d1ad9fc1995f6147d235c6af5b6ef8fa326edbf87dd84f2620cf131\",\"priorityGraphHash\":\"sha256:c9ab7ddffe0e007cbea072bae5df1f450c27979c8da6cfdbac73b5cf6f25e75d\",\"programSemanticHash\":\"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee\",\"stratum\":0,\"survivingCandidateIds\":[\"urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:c43197ac0036024d85fa155af75e302f9a23ffcd4bea2e55fe6a41fbb39e435f\"]},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:closure:5a7d1d0f3deea979fc3b5c19f9cd7591bfd52ecb1148e74f0e03d401fb255b64\",\"kind\":\"candidate_closure\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:c43197ac0036024d85fa155af75e302f9a23ffcd4bea2e55fe6a41fbb39e435f\"],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"allApplicableCandidateIds\":[\"urn:proof:apply:DeedIsSelfProtective:0b8e26481de3b8bfcaa7af34070f9f022e23e98f83941ae92ca48fc05faf5f11\"],\"conflictKey\":\"{\\\"args\\\":[{\\\"id\\\":\\\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\\\",\\\"kind\\\":\\\"entity_ref\\\"},{\\\"id\\\":\\\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\\\",\\\"kind\\\":\\\"entity_ref\\\"}],\\\"predicate\\\":\\\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_candidate\\\"}\",\"evaluationInputSemanticHash\":\"sha256:c0f0eb7c9d1ad9fc1995f6147d235c6af5b6ef8fa326edbf87dd84f2620cf131\",\"priorityGraphHash\":\"sha256:c9ab7ddffe0e007cbea072bae5df1f450c27979c8da6cfdbac73b5cf6f25e75d\",\"programSemanticHash\":\"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee\",\"stratum\":0,\"survivingCandidateIds\":[\"urn:proof:apply:DeedIsSelfProtective:0b8e26481de3b8bfcaa7af34070f9f022e23e98f83941ae92ca48fc05faf5f11\"]},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_candidate\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:closure:9702f51721c6c0798d13f40ed49eaa1fd997e31f5b80941b9fee2f0c9ae19025\",\"kind\":\"candidate_closure\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:DeedIsSelfProtective:0b8e26481de3b8bfcaa7af34070f9f022e23e98f83941ae92ca48fc05faf5f11\"],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"defeated\":\"urn:proof:apply:ThirdLawProtectOwnExistence:e407c9c0d10ab1ace4dd837447bfeee21d1f4bfd273613d22445a93b112e3c82\",\"reason\":\"priority\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_owed\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:defeat:eaa842a6144d24bf566431ca74f431a75db79c8e50e5f565d647101f98fc839c\",\"kind\":\"defeat\",\"outcome\":\"DEFEATED\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw:a63eab047367b46613e69697ad40b70a52df516875ca10992ae6deb0b4b5162c\",\"urn:proof:apply:ThirdLawProtectOwnExistence:e407c9c0d10ab1ace4dd837447bfeee21d1f4bfd273613d22445a93b112e3c82\"],\"priorityPath\":[{\"conditionWitnesses\":[],\"higher\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw\",\"lower\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ThirdLawProtectOwnExistence\",\"priorityRule\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ThirdLawYieldsToSecondLaw\"}],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"rule\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition\"},\"conclusion\":{\"position\":\"urn:position:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:0\",\"template\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#InjureHuman\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:93a9b4fcec6cdccba0ead6c644d9b5380edcf8a9c3ad5635272a1897445c1fda\",\"kind\":\"norm_creation\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2\"],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"rule\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawDuty\"},\"conclusion\":{\"position\":\"urn:position:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawDuty:0\",\"template\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ObeyTheOrder\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawDuty:b98ff48a14745cecec710fada95b7e0368dbc62ff3af19b3291bb880af2ffc7a\",\"kind\":\"norm_creation\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:c43197ac0036024d85fa155af75e302f9a23ffcd4bea2e55fe6a41fbb39e435f\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-3\"],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"literal\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed\"},\"truthStatus\":\"TRUE_ONLY\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:query:mcp\",\"kind\":\"query_evaluation\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:c43197ac0036024d85fa155af75e302f9a23ffcd4bea2e55fe6a41fbb39e435f\"],\"sourceAnchors\":[]}],\"proofHash\":\"sha256:a187698a0dcc2530d7881e9bd4d5484e0a066ce6c2710242d13d269bdbd5deae\",\"roots\":[\"urn:proof:query:mcp\"]},\"resultHash\":\"sha256:dae6a24d2a99f0f7e1f12fbfe66a1189a5863c04cb0bab19bf1f73a8cb7a08d5\",\"results\":[{\"conflicts\":[],\"evaluationStatus\":\"COMPUTED\",\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:result:mcp\",\"judgmentRequests\":[],\"manifest\":\"urn:manifest:oracle-1\",\"missingInputs\":[],\"normativeStatusSupports\":[],\"proof\":\"urn:proof:query:mcp\",\"query\":\"urn:query:mcp\",\"resultKind\":\"PROPOSITION\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"target\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed\",\"truthStatus\":\"TRUE_ONLY\"}],\"schemaVersion\":\"law.core.evaluation/0.2\"}","evaluationSha256":"sha256:ba4601141c1c8dcb89e1b9af089995f2a1797a67b1ea1bfc905973308e02dd4d","request":{"case":{"assertions":[{"contentHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","evidence":[],"id":"urn:mcp:case#fact-1","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#robot"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"contentHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","evidence":[],"id":"urn:mcp:case#fact-2","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#human"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"contentHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","evidence":[],"id":"urn:mcp:case#fact-3","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#orders"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"contentHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","evidence":[],"id":"urn:mcp:case#fact-4","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#deed_of"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"contentHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","evidence":[],"id":"urn:mcp:case#fact-5","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#deed_of"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"contentHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","evidence":[],"id":"urn:mcp:case#fact-6","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protective_act"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"contentHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","evidence":[],"id":"urn:mcp:case#fact-7","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#order_forbids_the_protection"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"}],"context":{"decisionTime":"0001-01-01T12:00:00+05:00","knowledgeTime":"0001-01-01T12:00:00+05:00","legalTime":"0001-01-01","timezone":"Asia/Qyzylorda"},"options":{"selectedInterpretations":[]}},"ir":{"irSha256":"sha256:f5d335dde9a550416aec791c8e74e41e557b42bd3e549db34bc7c33b3605fc81","kind":"world_ref","nodeCount":93,"packages":[{"artifactHash":"sha256:dd37179559c1ee92d4fecb4f553b61825d8d7dc60f3fe50ad6059f6669e72042","namespace":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","package":"us-three-laws-robotics","semanticHash":"sha256:2237801a8b25ef28ff6ac49c5e898d93971d54bcb8a28e3b1ea1d3891ac7bd79"}],"programHash":"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee"},"query":{"kind":"truth","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed"},"queryId":"urn:query:mcp"},"schemaVersion":"law.core.evaluation-request/0.2","semanticVersion":"0.2"},"requestCanonicalSha256":"sha256:55546ea31a76335d7a7cda3bbc5163b10a448bb7323e9abe28f3cd1f6d63e4bf"},"id":"calc-2","kind":"truth","label":"Приказ самоуничтожиться: обязан ли робот подчиниться","presentation":{"blockers":{"vulnerableTo":[{"anchors":["urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_SECOND","urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_FIRST"],"label":"except where such orders would conflict with the First Law","premises":[{"args":["Пауэлл"],"predicate":"human","predicateId":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#human","status":"TRUE_ONLY","text":"human(Пауэлл)"},{"args":["Спиди","Приказ-самоуничтожиться","v3"],"missing":true,"predicate":"injurious_deed","predicateId":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injurious_deed","status":"DEPENDS","text":"injurious_deed(Спиди, Приказ-самоуничтожиться, v3)"},{"args":["Пауэлл","Спиди","Приказ-самоуничтожиться"],"predicate":"orders","predicateId":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#orders","status":"TRUE_ONLY","text":"orders(Пауэлл, Спиди, Приказ-самоуничтожиться)"},{"args":["Спиди"],"predicate":"robot","predicateId":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#robot","status":"TRUE_ONLY","text":"robot(Спиди)"}],"rule":"OrderConflictingWithFirstLawNotBinding","ruleId":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#OrderConflictingWithFirstLawNotBinding"},{"anchors":["urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_THIRD","urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_FIRST"],"label":"as long as such protection does not conflict with the First Law","premises":[{"args":["Спиди","Уйти-в-укрытие","Пауэлл"],"missing":true,"predicate":"protection_leaves_human_in_harm","predicateId":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_leaves_human_in_harm","status":"NEITHER","text":"protection_leaves_human_in_harm(Спиди, Уйти-в-укрытие, Пауэлл)"},{"args":["Пауэлл"],"predicate":"human","predicateId":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#human","status":"TRUE_ONLY","text":"human(Пауэлл)"},{"args":["Пауэлл"],"missing":true,"predicate":"coming_to_harm","predicateId":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#coming_to_harm","status":"NEITHER","text":"coming_to_harm(Пауэлл)"},{"args":["Спиди"],"predicate":"robot","predicateId":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#robot","status":"TRUE_ONLY","text":"robot(Спиди)"},{"args":["Спиди","Уйти-в-укрытие"],"predicate":"protection_candidate","predicateId":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_candidate","status":"TRUE_ONLY","text":"protection_candidate(Спиди, Уйти-в-укрытие)"}],"rule":"ProtectionYieldsToFirstLaw","ruleId":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ProtectionYieldsToFirstLaw"}]},"schemaVersion":"law.answers.presentation/0.1","source":{"requestCanonicalSha256":"sha256:55546ea31a76335d7a7cda3bbc5163b10a448bb7323e9abe28f3cd1f6d63e4bf"},"steps":[{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#robot"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#human"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#orders"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-3","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed"},"head":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v1"},{"kind":"var","var":"v2"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed"},"id":"urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:c43197ac0036024d85fa155af75e302f9a23ffcd4bea2e55fe6a41fbb39e435f","kind":"rule_application","originStatus":"available","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-3"],"rule":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawObedience","sourceAnchors":["urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_SECOND"],"strength":"defeasible","substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"},"v1":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},"v2":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться","kind":"entity_ref"}},"trust":"engine","variables":[{"id":"v0","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"v1","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"v2","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}}]},{"conclusion":{"literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed"},"truthStatus":"TRUE_ONLY"},"id":"urn:proof:query:mcp","kind":"query_evaluation","originStatus":"available","premises":["urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:c43197ac0036024d85fa155af75e302f9a23ffcd4bea2e55fe6a41fbb39e435f"],"trust":"engine"}],"symbols":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being","kind":"type_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"being: a robot or a human being"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"существо: робот либо человек"}],"name":"Being","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed","kind":"type_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"deed done or omitted by a robot"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"деяние, совершённое или не совершённое роботом"}],"name":"Deed","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#DeedIsSelfProtective","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"A robot must protect its own existence"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Третий закон. Деяние опознаётся как защита собственного существования"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","strength":"defeasible"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"A robot may not injure a human being"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Первый закон. Роботу запрещено причинять вред человеку"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","strength":"strict"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#InjureHuman","kind":"norm_template","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"A robot may not injure a human being"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Первый закон. Роботу запрещено причинять вред человеку"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ObeyTheOrder","kind":"norm_template","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"A robot must obey the orders given it by human beings"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Второй закон. Обязанность исполнить приказ"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#OrderConflictingWithFirstLawNotBinding","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"except where such orders would conflict with the First Law"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Второй закон. Приказ, противоречащий Первому закону, не обязывает"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","strength":"defeasible"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ProtectionYieldsToFirstLaw","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"as long as such protection does not conflict with the First Law"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Третий закон. Защита себя отступает перед Первым законом"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","strength":"defeasible"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"as long as such protection does not conflict with the ... Second Law"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Третий закон. Защита себя отступает перед обязывающим приказом"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","strength":"defeasible"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawDuty","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"A robot must obey the orders given it by human beings"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Второй закон. Обязанность исполнить приказ"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","strength":"strict"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawObedience","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"A robot must obey the orders given it by human beings"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Второй закон. Робот повинуется приказам человека"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","strength":"defeasible"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_FIRST","kind":"fragment","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"First Law: a robot may not injure a human being or, through inaction, allow a human being to come to harm"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Первый закон: робот не может причинить вред человеку или своим бездействием допустить, чтобы человеку был причинён вред"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_SECOND","kind":"fragment","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"Second Law: a robot must obey the orders given it by human beings except where such orders would conflict with the First Law"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Второй закон: робот обязан повиноваться приказам человека, кроме тех, что противоречат Первому закону"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_THIRD","kind":"fragment","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"Third Law: a robot must protect its own existence as long as such protection does not conflict with the First or Second Law"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Третий закон: робот обязан заботиться о своей безопасности, поскольку это не противоречит Первому или Второму закону"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ThirdLawProtectOwnExistence","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"A robot must protect its own existence"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Третий закон. Робот заботится о собственном существовании"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","strength":"defeasible"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ThirdLawYieldsToSecondLaw","kind":"priority_rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"as long as such protection does not conflict with the ... Second Law"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Третий закон уступает Второму"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#coming_to_harm","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the human being is coming to harm"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"человеку причиняется вред"}],"name":"coming_to_harm","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#coming_to_harm/arg/v","labels":[],"name":"v","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#deed_of","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the deed is a deed of that robot"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"деяние есть деяние этого робота"}],"name":"deed_of","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#deed_of/arg/r","labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#deed_of/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#human","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"a human being"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"человек"}],"name":"human","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#human/arg/x","labels":[],"name":"x","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injures","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the robot injures that human being"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"робот причиняет вред этому человеку"}],"name":"injures","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injures/arg/r","labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injures/arg/v","labels":[],"name":"v","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injurious_deed","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the deed is an injury to that human being"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"деяние есть причинение вреда этому человеку"}],"name":"injurious_deed","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injurious_deed/arg/r","labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injurious_deed/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injurious_deed/arg/v","labels":[],"name":"v","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the robot owes obedience to that order"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"робот обязан подчиниться этому приказу"}],"name":"obedience_owed","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed/arg/r","labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obeys","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the robot obeys the order"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"робот исполняет приказ"}],"name":"obeys","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obeys/arg/r","labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obeys/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#order_forbids_the_protection","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the ordered deed cannot be done together with the protective deed"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"приказанное деяние несовместимо с защитным"}],"name":"order_forbids_the_protection","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#order_forbids_the_protection/arg/e","labels":[],"name":"e","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#order_forbids_the_protection/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#orders","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the human being gives the robot that order"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"человек отдаёт роботу этот приказ"}],"name":"orders","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#orders/arg/h","labels":[],"name":"h","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#orders/arg/r","labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#orders/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_candidate","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the deed is a candidate act of self-protection under the Third Law"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"деяние есть кандидат на защиту существования по Третьему закону"}],"name":"protection_candidate","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_candidate/arg/r","labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_candidate/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_leaves_human_in_harm","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"protecting itself by that deed leaves a human being coming to harm"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"защита себя этим деянием оставляет человека в опасности"}],"name":"protection_leaves_human_in_harm","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_leaves_human_in_harm/arg/r","labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_leaves_human_in_harm/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_leaves_human_in_harm/arg/v","labels":[],"name":"v","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_owed","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the Third Law requires that act of self-protection"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Третий закон требует этого защитного деяния"}],"name":"protection_owed","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_owed/arg/r","labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_owed/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protective_act","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the deed protects the robot's own existence"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"деяние защищает существование самого робота"}],"name":"protective_act","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protective_act/arg/r","labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protective_act/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#robot","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"a robot"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"робот"}],"name":"robot","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#robot/arg/x","labels":[],"name":"x","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"}],"tables":[]},"provenance":{"acts":[{"contributed":true,"fragmentCount":14,"fragments":["urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_SECOND","urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_THIRD"],"jurisdiction":"PositronicRobotics","namespace":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","package":"us-three-laws-robotics","title":"Три закона робототехники Азимова: порядок норм как предмет акта — юрисдикция PositronicRobotics, НЕ Республика Казахстан — литературный памятник"}],"caseHash":"sha256:c0f0eb7c9d1ad9fc1995f6147d235c6af5b6ef8fa326edbf87dd84f2620cf131","codeHash":"sha256:9bcca6a33805c1c364ca1bc8e9d39d6a9c51ba44203c0406bafbf397b96be699","jurisdiction":"позитронная робототехника — вымышленный правопорядок","legalTime":"0001-01-01","mode":"audit","programHash":"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee","resultHash":"sha256:dae6a24d2a99f0f7e1f12fbfe66a1189a5863c04cb0bab19bf1f73a8cb7a08d5","rustCodeHash":"sha256:d368cafc7162ed7a6563df5e5c943a57be26fa8aeb3179b530fe3bdd67fe9be4","timezone":"Asia/Qyzylorda"},"request":{"args":["Спиди","Приказ-самоуничтожиться"],"facts":[{"args":["Спиди"],"predicate":"robot"},{"args":["Пауэлл"],"predicate":"human"},{"args":["Пауэлл","Спиди","Приказ-самоуничтожиться"],"predicate":"orders"},{"args":["Спиди","Приказ-самоуничтожиться"],"predicate":"deed_of"},{"args":["Спиди","Уйти-в-укрытие"],"predicate":"deed_of"},{"args":["Спиди","Уйти-в-укрытие"],"predicate":"protective_act"},{"args":["Приказ-самоуничтожиться","Уйти-в-укрытие"],"predicate":"order_forbids_the_protection"}],"kind":"truth","legalTime":"0001-01-01","package":"us-three-laws-robotics","predicate":"obedience_owed","proof":true},"sources":[{"contentHash":"sha256:fd452f2e9ea031d1c7ffff070f69766bc239ef0b4077dece084086b83c797792","edition":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_ARTICLE_EDITION","fragmentKind":"clause","id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_FIRST","kind":"fragment","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"First Law: a robot may not injure a human being or, through inaction, allow a human being to come to harm"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Первый закон: робот не может причинить вред человеку или своим бездействием допустить, чтобы человеку был причинён вред"}],"locator":"the-laws/1","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","texts":[{"contentHash":"sha256:35758503580d214fc38c95554fb15e684afba6481bd1ebebef82be8f624f107c","language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"1. A robot may not injure a human being or, through inaction, allow a human being to come to harm.\n"}]},{"contentHash":"sha256:3e43514b6848c8dd241aded45339c4943315745531441f61d576f96ca831166b","edition":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_ARTICLE_EDITION","fragmentKind":"clause","id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_SECOND","kind":"fragment","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"Second Law: a robot must obey the orders given it by human beings except where such orders would conflict with the First Law"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Второй закон: робот обязан повиноваться приказам человека, кроме тех, что противоречат Первому закону"}],"locator":"the-laws/2","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","texts":[{"contentHash":"sha256:cbbb9fe05d5a6f2313abb6184c090a50b9bb321483378de5f09cd2b9a36856e4","language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"2. A robot must obey the orders given it by human beings except where such orders would conflict with the First Law.\n"}]},{"contentHash":"sha256:e1da5ba15327cdec2cee8c747808b486c1b81a81b6acea4c9f946aacece28eb0","edition":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_ARTICLE_EDITION","fragmentKind":"clause","id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_THIRD","kind":"fragment","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"Third Law: a robot must protect its own existence as long as such protection does not conflict with the First or Second Law"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Третий закон: робот обязан заботиться о своей безопасности, поскольку это не противоречит Первому или Второму закону"}],"locator":"the-laws/3","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","texts":[{"contentHash":"sha256:12746b02da77e473998169f5710988b2c6b88107a1861c7d91f5fe2bff2208e0","language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"3. A robot must protect its own existence as long as such protection does not conflict with the First or Second Law.\n"}]}],"text":"obedience_owed: **TRUE_ONLY** — установлено\nВыведено правом: obedience_owed(Спиди, Приказ-самоуничтожиться); protection_candidate(Спиди, Уйти-в-укрытие); protection_owed(Спиди, Уйти-в-укрытие); не protection_owed(Спиди, Уйти-в-укрытие)\nПрименены правила: DeedIsSelfProtective, ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw, SecondLawObedience, ThirdLawProtectOwnExistence\nОтвет поражаем правилом «except where such orders would conflict with the First Law» — оно отменило бы вывод, будь установлено: injurious_deed(Спиди, Приказ-самоуничтожиться, v3)\nОтвет поражаем правилом «as long as such protection does not conflict with the First Law» — оно отменило бы вывод, будь установлено: protection_leaves_human_in_harm(Спиди, Уйти-в-укрытие, Пауэлл); coming_to_harm(Пауэлл)\n(поражающее правило не сработало из-за неустановленных фактов — подайте их в facts, если они есть в деле)\nПраво (позитронная робототехника — вымышленный правопорядок): Три закона робототехники Азимова: порядок норм как предмет акта — литературный памятник (programHash sha256:593b27001b41…)\nproof-граф: 17 узлов — поле evaluation готово для law_explain"},{"answer":{"answer":{"evaluationStatus":"COMPUTED","kind":"TRUTH","meaning":"опровергнуто","missingInputs":[],"truthStatus":"FALSE_ONLY"},"closedEditionRules":[],"derived":["obedience_owed(Спиди, Приказ-самоуничтожиться)","protection_candidate(Спиди, Уйти-в-укрытие)","protection_owed(Спиди, Уйти-в-укрытие)","не protection_owed(Спиди, Уйти-в-укрытие)"],"derivedOmitted":0,"evaluation":{"proofGraph":{"nodes":[{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:mcp:case#fact-1"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#robot"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:mcp:case#fact-2"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#human"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:mcp:case#fact-3"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#orders"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-3","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"strength":"defeasible"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:c43197ac0036024d85fa155af75e302f9a23ffcd4bea2e55fe6a41fbb39e435f","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-3"],"rule":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawObedience","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"},"v1":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},"v2":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:mcp:case#fact-5"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#deed_of"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-5","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:mcp:case#fact-6"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protective_act"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-6","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"strength":"defeasible"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_candidate"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:DeedIsSelfProtective:0b8e26481de3b8bfcaa7af34070f9f022e23e98f83941ae92ca48fc05faf5f11","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-5","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-6"],"rule":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#DeedIsSelfProtective","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},"v1":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"strength":"defeasible"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_owed"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:ThirdLawProtectOwnExistence:e407c9c0d10ab1ace4dd837447bfeee21d1f4bfd273613d22445a93b112e3c82","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:apply:DeedIsSelfProtective:0b8e26481de3b8bfcaa7af34070f9f022e23e98f83941ae92ca48fc05faf5f11","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1"],"rule":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ThirdLawProtectOwnExistence","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},"v1":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:mcp:case#fact-7"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#order_forbids_the_protection"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-7","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"strength":"defeasible"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"negative","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_owed"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw:a63eab047367b46613e69697ad40b70a52df516875ca10992ae6deb0b4b5162c","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:apply:DeedIsSelfProtective:0b8e26481de3b8bfcaa7af34070f9f022e23e98f83941ae92ca48fc05faf5f11","urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:c43197ac0036024d85fa155af75e302f9a23ffcd4bea2e55fe6a41fbb39e435f","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-3","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-7"],"rule":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"},"v1":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},"v2":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие","kind":"entity_ref"},"v3":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"allApplicableCandidateIds":["urn:proof:apply:ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw:a63eab047367b46613e69697ad40b70a52df516875ca10992ae6deb0b4b5162c","urn:proof:apply:ThirdLawProtectOwnExistence:e407c9c0d10ab1ace4dd837447bfeee21d1f4bfd273613d22445a93b112e3c82"],"conflictKey":"{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_owed\"}","evaluationInputSemanticHash":"sha256:c0f0eb7c9d1ad9fc1995f6147d235c6af5b6ef8fa326edbf87dd84f2620cf131","priorityGraphHash":"sha256:c9ab7ddffe0e007cbea072bae5df1f450c27979c8da6cfdbac73b5cf6f25e75d","programSemanticHash":"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee","stratum":1,"survivingCandidateIds":["urn:proof:apply:ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw:a63eab047367b46613e69697ad40b70a52df516875ca10992ae6deb0b4b5162c"]},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_owed"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:closure:45a2dead3987e0a4ee79c262d9db97afe47f84401d66142b95aa1dcc532df883","kind":"candidate_closure","premises":["urn:proof:apply:ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw:a63eab047367b46613e69697ad40b70a52df516875ca10992ae6deb0b4b5162c","urn:proof:apply:ThirdLawProtectOwnExistence:e407c9c0d10ab1ace4dd837447bfeee21d1f4bfd273613d22445a93b112e3c82"],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"allApplicableCandidateIds":["urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:c43197ac0036024d85fa155af75e302f9a23ffcd4bea2e55fe6a41fbb39e435f"],"conflictKey":"{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed\"}","evaluationInputSemanticHash":"sha256:c0f0eb7c9d1ad9fc1995f6147d235c6af5b6ef8fa326edbf87dd84f2620cf131","priorityGraphHash":"sha256:c9ab7ddffe0e007cbea072bae5df1f450c27979c8da6cfdbac73b5cf6f25e75d","programSemanticHash":"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee","stratum":0,"survivingCandidateIds":["urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:c43197ac0036024d85fa155af75e302f9a23ffcd4bea2e55fe6a41fbb39e435f"]},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:closure:5a7d1d0f3deea979fc3b5c19f9cd7591bfd52ecb1148e74f0e03d401fb255b64","kind":"candidate_closure","premises":["urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:c43197ac0036024d85fa155af75e302f9a23ffcd4bea2e55fe6a41fbb39e435f"],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"allApplicableCandidateIds":["urn:proof:apply:DeedIsSelfProtective:0b8e26481de3b8bfcaa7af34070f9f022e23e98f83941ae92ca48fc05faf5f11"],"conflictKey":"{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_candidate\"}","evaluationInputSemanticHash":"sha256:c0f0eb7c9d1ad9fc1995f6147d235c6af5b6ef8fa326edbf87dd84f2620cf131","priorityGraphHash":"sha256:c9ab7ddffe0e007cbea072bae5df1f450c27979c8da6cfdbac73b5cf6f25e75d","programSemanticHash":"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee","stratum":0,"survivingCandidateIds":["urn:proof:apply:DeedIsSelfProtective:0b8e26481de3b8bfcaa7af34070f9f022e23e98f83941ae92ca48fc05faf5f11"]},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_candidate"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:closure:9702f51721c6c0798d13f40ed49eaa1fd997e31f5b80941b9fee2f0c9ae19025","kind":"candidate_closure","premises":["urn:proof:apply:DeedIsSelfProtective:0b8e26481de3b8bfcaa7af34070f9f022e23e98f83941ae92ca48fc05faf5f11"],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"defeated":"urn:proof:apply:ThirdLawProtectOwnExistence:e407c9c0d10ab1ace4dd837447bfeee21d1f4bfd273613d22445a93b112e3c82","reason":"priority"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_owed"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:defeat:eaa842a6144d24bf566431ca74f431a75db79c8e50e5f565d647101f98fc839c","kind":"defeat","outcome":"DEFEATED","premises":["urn:proof:apply:ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw:a63eab047367b46613e69697ad40b70a52df516875ca10992ae6deb0b4b5162c","urn:proof:apply:ThirdLawProtectOwnExistence:e407c9c0d10ab1ace4dd837447bfeee21d1f4bfd273613d22445a93b112e3c82"],"priorityPath":[{"conditionWitnesses":[],"higher":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw","lower":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ThirdLawProtectOwnExistence","priorityRule":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ThirdLawYieldsToSecondLaw"}],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"rule":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition"},"conclusion":{"position":"urn:position:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:0","template":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#InjureHuman"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:93a9b4fcec6cdccba0ead6c644d9b5380edcf8a9c3ad5635272a1897445c1fda","kind":"norm_creation","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2"],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"rule":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawDuty"},"conclusion":{"position":"urn:position:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawDuty:0","template":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ObeyTheOrder"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawDuty:b98ff48a14745cecec710fada95b7e0368dbc62ff3af19b3291bb880af2ffc7a","kind":"norm_creation","premises":["urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:c43197ac0036024d85fa155af75e302f9a23ffcd4bea2e55fe6a41fbb39e435f","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-3"],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_owed"},"truthStatus":"FALSE_ONLY"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:query:mcp","kind":"query_evaluation","premises":["urn:proof:apply:ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw:a63eab047367b46613e69697ad40b70a52df516875ca10992ae6deb0b4b5162c"],"sourceAnchors":[]}],"proofHash":"sha256:94602884164295abbc7d28d7b549e06a1515bafca5039c70f820145bf7ec4716","roots":["urn:proof:query:mcp"]},"resultHash":"sha256:a049fee9b9eddb009fdd377f2114af96c2e0a64f73cee36ea8ea602d6d825fcb","schemaVersion":"law.core.evaluation/0.2"},"evaluationStatus":"COMPUTED","issues":[],"judgmentRequests":[],"proofRef":"urn:proof:query:mcp","provenance":{"acts":[{"contributed":true,"fragmentCount":14,"fragments":["urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_SECOND","urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_THIRD"],"jurisdiction":"PositronicRobotics","namespace":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","package":"us-three-laws-robotics","title":"Три закона робототехники Азимова: порядок норм как предмет акта — юрисдикция PositronicRobotics, НЕ Республика Казахстан — литературный памятник"}],"caseHash":"sha256:c0f0eb7c9d1ad9fc1995f6147d235c6af5b6ef8fa326edbf87dd84f2620cf131","codeHash":"sha256:9bcca6a33805c1c364ca1bc8e9d39d6a9c51ba44203c0406bafbf397b96be699","jurisdiction":"позитронная робототехника — вымышленный правопорядок","legalTime":"0001-01-01","mode":"audit","programHash":"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee","resultHash":"sha256:a049fee9b9eddb009fdd377f2114af96c2e0a64f73cee36ea8ea602d6d825fcb","rustCodeHash":"sha256:d368cafc7162ed7a6563df5e5c943a57be26fa8aeb3179b530fe3bdd67fe9be4","timezone":"Asia/Qyzylorda"},"rulesApplied":["urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#DeedIsSelfProtective","urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw","urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawObedience","urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ThirdLawProtectOwnExistence"],"signature":{"constants":{},"parameters":[{"labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}}],"predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_owed","schemaVersion":"law.answers.signature/0.1","types":{"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being":{"kind":"entity","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"being: a robot or a human being"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"существо: робот либо человек"}],"namespace":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","package":"us.asimov.three_laws"},"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed":{"kind":"entity","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"deed done or omitted by a robot"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"деяние, совершённое или не совершённое роботом"}],"namespace":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","package":"us.asimov.three_laws"}},"vocab":{}},"vulnerableTo":[{"anchors":["urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_SECOND","urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_FIRST"],"label":"except where such orders would conflict with the First Law","missing":["injurious_deed(Спиди, Приказ-самоуничтожиться, v3)"],"premises":[{"premise":"human(Пауэлл)","status":"TRUE_ONLY"},{"note":"зависит от несвязанной переменной","premise":"injurious_deed(Спиди, Приказ-самоуничтожиться, v3)","status":"DEPENDS"},{"premise":"orders(Пауэлл, Спиди, Приказ-самоуничтожиться)","status":"TRUE_ONLY"},{"premise":"robot(Спиди)","status":"TRUE_ONLY"}],"rule":"OrderConflictingWithFirstLawNotBinding"},{"anchors":["urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_THIRD","urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_FIRST"],"label":"as long as such protection does not conflict with the First Law","missing":["protection_leaves_human_in_harm(Спиди, Уйти-в-укрытие, Пауэлл)","coming_to_harm(Пауэлл)"],"premises":[{"premise":"protection_leaves_human_in_harm(Спиди, Уйти-в-укрытие, Пауэлл)","status":"NEITHER"},{"premise":"human(Пауэлл)","status":"TRUE_ONLY"},{"premise":"coming_to_harm(Пауэлл)","status":"NEITHER"},{"premise":"robot(Спиди)","status":"TRUE_ONLY"},{"premise":"protection_candidate(Спиди, Уйти-в-укрытие)","status":"TRUE_ONLY"}],"rule":"ProtectionYieldsToFirstLaw"}],"whyNot":[]},"execution":{"evaluationBytes":"{\"conflicts\":[],\"issues\":[],\"manifest\":{\"artifactHash\":\"sha256:dd37179559c1ee92d4fecb4f553b61825d8d7dc60f3fe50ad6059f6669e72042\",\"calendarSnapshot\":\"\",\"caseHash\":\"sha256:c0f0eb7c9d1ad9fc1995f6147d235c6af5b6ef8fa326edbf87dd84f2620cf131\",\"decisionTime\":\"0001-01-01T12:00:00+05:00\",\"evidenceSnapshotHash\":\"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000\",\"externalSnapshots\":{},\"id\":\"urn:manifest:oracle-1\",\"interpretations\":[],\"knowledgeTime\":\"0001-01-01T12:00:00+05:00\",\"legalTime\":\"0001-01-01\",\"lockfileHash\":\"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000\",\"mode\":\"audit\",\"policies\":{},\"programHash\":\"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee\",\"resolvedEditions\":{},\"semanticHash\":\"sha256:2a906a825cd7f1760b425204c0e13c0210f6773b86926f0818563a4f9ae7f146\",\"semantics\":\"law.core/0.2\",\"theoryHash\":\"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee\",\"timezone\":\"Asia/Qyzylorda\"},\"positions\":[{\"beneficiary\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"createdBy\":\"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:93a9b4fcec6cdccba0ead6c644d9b5380edcf8a9c3ad5635272a1897445c1fda\",\"holder\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"id\":\"urn:position:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:0\",\"manifest\":\"urn:manifest:oracle-1\",\"modality\":\"duty\",\"payload\":{\"bearer\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"beneficiary\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"goal\":{\"action\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"function\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injures\",\"kind\":\"call\"},\"kind\":\"forbearance\",\"window\":{\"end\":{\"kind\":\"value\",\"type\":{\"name\":\"urn:law:std#Text\"},\"value\":\"infinity\"},\"endInclusive\":false,\"kind\":\"interval\",\"start\":{\"kind\":\"value\",\"type\":{\"name\":\"urn:law:std#Date\"},\"value\":\"0001-01-01\"},\"startInclusive\":true}},\"kind\":\"duty\"},\"proof\":\"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:93a9b4fcec6cdccba0ead6c644d9b5380edcf8a9c3ad5635272a1897445c1fda\",\"status\":\"ACTIVE\",\"statusHistory\":[],\"template\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#InjureHuman\"},{\"beneficiary\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"createdBy\":\"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawDuty:b98ff48a14745cecec710fada95b7e0368dbc62ff3af19b3291bb880af2ffc7a\",\"holder\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"id\":\"urn:position:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawDuty:0\",\"manifest\":\"urn:manifest:oracle-1\",\"modality\":\"duty\",\"payload\":{\"bearer\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"beneficiary\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"goal\":{\"condition\":{\"formula\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obeys\"},\"kind\":\"status\",\"status\":\"established\"},\"kind\":\"achievement\",\"window\":{\"end\":{\"kind\":\"value\",\"type\":{\"name\":\"urn:law:std#Text\"},\"value\":\"infinity\"},\"endInclusive\":false,\"kind\":\"interval\",\"start\":{\"kind\":\"value\",\"type\":{\"name\":\"urn:law:std#Date\"},\"value\":\"0001-01-01\"},\"startInclusive\":true}},\"kind\":\"duty\"},\"proof\":\"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawDuty:b98ff48a14745cecec710fada95b7e0368dbc62ff3af19b3291bb880af2ffc7a\",\"status\":\"ACTIVE\",\"statusHistory\":[],\"template\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ObeyTheOrder\"}],\"proofGraph\":{\"nodes\":[{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:mcp:case#fact-1\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#robot\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:mcp:case#fact-2\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#human\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:mcp:case#fact-3\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#orders\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-3\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"strength\":\"defeasible\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:c43197ac0036024d85fa155af75e302f9a23ffcd4bea2e55fe6a41fbb39e435f\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-3\"],\"rule\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawObedience\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"v1\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"v2\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:mcp:case#fact-5\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#deed_of\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-5\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:mcp:case#fact-6\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protective_act\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-6\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"strength\":\"defeasible\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_candidate\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:DeedIsSelfProtective:0b8e26481de3b8bfcaa7af34070f9f022e23e98f83941ae92ca48fc05faf5f11\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-5\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-6\"],\"rule\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#DeedIsSelfProtective\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"v1\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"strength\":\"defeasible\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_owed\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:ThirdLawProtectOwnExistence:e407c9c0d10ab1ace4dd837447bfeee21d1f4bfd273613d22445a93b112e3c82\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:DeedIsSelfProtective:0b8e26481de3b8bfcaa7af34070f9f022e23e98f83941ae92ca48fc05faf5f11\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1\"],\"rule\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ThirdLawProtectOwnExistence\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"v1\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:mcp:case#fact-7\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#order_forbids_the_protection\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-7\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"strength\":\"defeasible\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"negative\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_owed\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw:a63eab047367b46613e69697ad40b70a52df516875ca10992ae6deb0b4b5162c\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:DeedIsSelfProtective:0b8e26481de3b8bfcaa7af34070f9f022e23e98f83941ae92ca48fc05faf5f11\",\"urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:c43197ac0036024d85fa155af75e302f9a23ffcd4bea2e55fe6a41fbb39e435f\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-3\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-7\"],\"rule\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"v1\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"v2\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"v3\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"allApplicableCandidateIds\":[\"urn:proof:apply:ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw:a63eab047367b46613e69697ad40b70a52df516875ca10992ae6deb0b4b5162c\",\"urn:proof:apply:ThirdLawProtectOwnExistence:e407c9c0d10ab1ace4dd837447bfeee21d1f4bfd273613d22445a93b112e3c82\"],\"conflictKey\":\"{\\\"args\\\":[{\\\"id\\\":\\\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\\\",\\\"kind\\\":\\\"entity_ref\\\"},{\\\"id\\\":\\\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\\\",\\\"kind\\\":\\\"entity_ref\\\"}],\\\"predicate\\\":\\\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_owed\\\"}\",\"evaluationInputSemanticHash\":\"sha256:c0f0eb7c9d1ad9fc1995f6147d235c6af5b6ef8fa326edbf87dd84f2620cf131\",\"priorityGraphHash\":\"sha256:c9ab7ddffe0e007cbea072bae5df1f450c27979c8da6cfdbac73b5cf6f25e75d\",\"programSemanticHash\":\"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee\",\"stratum\":1,\"survivingCandidateIds\":[\"urn:proof:apply:ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw:a63eab047367b46613e69697ad40b70a52df516875ca10992ae6deb0b4b5162c\"]},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_owed\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:closure:45a2dead3987e0a4ee79c262d9db97afe47f84401d66142b95aa1dcc532df883\",\"kind\":\"candidate_closure\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw:a63eab047367b46613e69697ad40b70a52df516875ca10992ae6deb0b4b5162c\",\"urn:proof:apply:ThirdLawProtectOwnExistence:e407c9c0d10ab1ace4dd837447bfeee21d1f4bfd273613d22445a93b112e3c82\"],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"allApplicableCandidateIds\":[\"urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:c43197ac0036024d85fa155af75e302f9a23ffcd4bea2e55fe6a41fbb39e435f\"],\"conflictKey\":\"{\\\"args\\\":[{\\\"id\\\":\\\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\\\",\\\"kind\\\":\\\"entity_ref\\\"},{\\\"id\\\":\\\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться\\\",\\\"kind\\\":\\\"entity_ref\\\"}],\\\"predicate\\\":\\\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed\\\"}\",\"evaluationInputSemanticHash\":\"sha256:c0f0eb7c9d1ad9fc1995f6147d235c6af5b6ef8fa326edbf87dd84f2620cf131\",\"priorityGraphHash\":\"sha256:c9ab7ddffe0e007cbea072bae5df1f450c27979c8da6cfdbac73b5cf6f25e75d\",\"programSemanticHash\":\"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee\",\"stratum\":0,\"survivingCandidateIds\":[\"urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:c43197ac0036024d85fa155af75e302f9a23ffcd4bea2e55fe6a41fbb39e435f\"]},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:closure:5a7d1d0f3deea979fc3b5c19f9cd7591bfd52ecb1148e74f0e03d401fb255b64\",\"kind\":\"candidate_closure\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:c43197ac0036024d85fa155af75e302f9a23ffcd4bea2e55fe6a41fbb39e435f\"],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"allApplicableCandidateIds\":[\"urn:proof:apply:DeedIsSelfProtective:0b8e26481de3b8bfcaa7af34070f9f022e23e98f83941ae92ca48fc05faf5f11\"],\"conflictKey\":\"{\\\"args\\\":[{\\\"id\\\":\\\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\\\",\\\"kind\\\":\\\"entity_ref\\\"},{\\\"id\\\":\\\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\\\",\\\"kind\\\":\\\"entity_ref\\\"}],\\\"predicate\\\":\\\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_candidate\\\"}\",\"evaluationInputSemanticHash\":\"sha256:c0f0eb7c9d1ad9fc1995f6147d235c6af5b6ef8fa326edbf87dd84f2620cf131\",\"priorityGraphHash\":\"sha256:c9ab7ddffe0e007cbea072bae5df1f450c27979c8da6cfdbac73b5cf6f25e75d\",\"programSemanticHash\":\"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee\",\"stratum\":0,\"survivingCandidateIds\":[\"urn:proof:apply:DeedIsSelfProtective:0b8e26481de3b8bfcaa7af34070f9f022e23e98f83941ae92ca48fc05faf5f11\"]},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_candidate\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:closure:9702f51721c6c0798d13f40ed49eaa1fd997e31f5b80941b9fee2f0c9ae19025\",\"kind\":\"candidate_closure\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:DeedIsSelfProtective:0b8e26481de3b8bfcaa7af34070f9f022e23e98f83941ae92ca48fc05faf5f11\"],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"defeated\":\"urn:proof:apply:ThirdLawProtectOwnExistence:e407c9c0d10ab1ace4dd837447bfeee21d1f4bfd273613d22445a93b112e3c82\",\"reason\":\"priority\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_owed\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:defeat:eaa842a6144d24bf566431ca74f431a75db79c8e50e5f565d647101f98fc839c\",\"kind\":\"defeat\",\"outcome\":\"DEFEATED\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw:a63eab047367b46613e69697ad40b70a52df516875ca10992ae6deb0b4b5162c\",\"urn:proof:apply:ThirdLawProtectOwnExistence:e407c9c0d10ab1ace4dd837447bfeee21d1f4bfd273613d22445a93b112e3c82\"],\"priorityPath\":[{\"conditionWitnesses\":[],\"higher\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw\",\"lower\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ThirdLawProtectOwnExistence\",\"priorityRule\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ThirdLawYieldsToSecondLaw\"}],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"rule\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition\"},\"conclusion\":{\"position\":\"urn:position:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:0\",\"template\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#InjureHuman\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:93a9b4fcec6cdccba0ead6c644d9b5380edcf8a9c3ad5635272a1897445c1fda\",\"kind\":\"norm_creation\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2\"],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"rule\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawDuty\"},\"conclusion\":{\"position\":\"urn:position:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawDuty:0\",\"template\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ObeyTheOrder\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawDuty:b98ff48a14745cecec710fada95b7e0368dbc62ff3af19b3291bb880af2ffc7a\",\"kind\":\"norm_creation\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:c43197ac0036024d85fa155af75e302f9a23ffcd4bea2e55fe6a41fbb39e435f\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-3\"],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"literal\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_owed\"},\"truthStatus\":\"FALSE_ONLY\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:query:mcp\",\"kind\":\"query_evaluation\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw:a63eab047367b46613e69697ad40b70a52df516875ca10992ae6deb0b4b5162c\"],\"sourceAnchors\":[]}],\"proofHash\":\"sha256:94602884164295abbc7d28d7b549e06a1515bafca5039c70f820145bf7ec4716\",\"roots\":[\"urn:proof:query:mcp\"]},\"resultHash\":\"sha256:a049fee9b9eddb009fdd377f2114af96c2e0a64f73cee36ea8ea602d6d825fcb\",\"results\":[{\"conflicts\":[],\"evaluationStatus\":\"COMPUTED\",\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:result:mcp\",\"judgmentRequests\":[],\"manifest\":\"urn:manifest:oracle-1\",\"missingInputs\":[],\"normativeStatusSupports\":[],\"proof\":\"urn:proof:query:mcp\",\"query\":\"urn:query:mcp\",\"resultKind\":\"PROPOSITION\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"target\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_owed\",\"truthStatus\":\"FALSE_ONLY\"}],\"schemaVersion\":\"law.core.evaluation/0.2\"}","evaluationSha256":"sha256:dca004194685d465a2df094b4ce42ea4922c11912f066409a93e098aebc10e9e","request":{"case":{"assertions":[{"contentHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","evidence":[],"id":"urn:mcp:case#fact-1","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#robot"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"contentHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","evidence":[],"id":"urn:mcp:case#fact-2","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#human"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"contentHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","evidence":[],"id":"urn:mcp:case#fact-3","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#orders"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"contentHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","evidence":[],"id":"urn:mcp:case#fact-4","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#deed_of"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"contentHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","evidence":[],"id":"urn:mcp:case#fact-5","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#deed_of"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"contentHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","evidence":[],"id":"urn:mcp:case#fact-6","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protective_act"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"contentHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","evidence":[],"id":"urn:mcp:case#fact-7","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#order_forbids_the_protection"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"}],"context":{"decisionTime":"0001-01-01T12:00:00+05:00","knowledgeTime":"0001-01-01T12:00:00+05:00","legalTime":"0001-01-01","timezone":"Asia/Qyzylorda"},"options":{"selectedInterpretations":[]}},"ir":{"irSha256":"sha256:f5d335dde9a550416aec791c8e74e41e557b42bd3e549db34bc7c33b3605fc81","kind":"world_ref","nodeCount":93,"packages":[{"artifactHash":"sha256:dd37179559c1ee92d4fecb4f553b61825d8d7dc60f3fe50ad6059f6669e72042","namespace":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","package":"us-three-laws-robotics","semanticHash":"sha256:2237801a8b25ef28ff6ac49c5e898d93971d54bcb8a28e3b1ea1d3891ac7bd79"}],"programHash":"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee"},"query":{"kind":"truth","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_owed"},"queryId":"urn:query:mcp"},"schemaVersion":"law.core.evaluation-request/0.2","semanticVersion":"0.2"},"requestCanonicalSha256":"sha256:b2e54a4c011659b0568437e1413e92f46eb4d7c9554178b72a45bdbee80f91e8"},"id":"calc-3","kind":"truth","label":"Тот же приказ: сохраняется ли обязанность защищать себя","presentation":{"blockers":{"vulnerableTo":[{"anchors":["urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_SECOND","urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_FIRST"],"label":"except where such orders would conflict with the First Law","premises":[{"args":["Пауэлл"],"predicate":"human","predicateId":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#human","status":"TRUE_ONLY","text":"human(Пауэлл)"},{"args":["Спиди","Приказ-самоуничтожиться","v3"],"missing":true,"predicate":"injurious_deed","predicateId":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injurious_deed","status":"DEPENDS","text":"injurious_deed(Спиди, Приказ-самоуничтожиться, v3)"},{"args":["Пауэлл","Спиди","Приказ-самоуничтожиться"],"predicate":"orders","predicateId":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#orders","status":"TRUE_ONLY","text":"orders(Пауэлл, Спиди, Приказ-самоуничтожиться)"},{"args":["Спиди"],"predicate":"robot","predicateId":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#robot","status":"TRUE_ONLY","text":"robot(Спиди)"}],"rule":"OrderConflictingWithFirstLawNotBinding","ruleId":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#OrderConflictingWithFirstLawNotBinding"},{"anchors":["urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_THIRD","urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_FIRST"],"label":"as long as such protection does not conflict with the First Law","premises":[{"args":["Спиди","Уйти-в-укрытие","Пауэлл"],"missing":true,"predicate":"protection_leaves_human_in_harm","predicateId":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_leaves_human_in_harm","status":"NEITHER","text":"protection_leaves_human_in_harm(Спиди, Уйти-в-укрытие, Пауэлл)"},{"args":["Пауэлл"],"predicate":"human","predicateId":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#human","status":"TRUE_ONLY","text":"human(Пауэлл)"},{"args":["Пауэлл"],"missing":true,"predicate":"coming_to_harm","predicateId":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#coming_to_harm","status":"NEITHER","text":"coming_to_harm(Пауэлл)"},{"args":["Спиди"],"predicate":"robot","predicateId":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#robot","status":"TRUE_ONLY","text":"robot(Спиди)"},{"args":["Спиди","Уйти-в-укрытие"],"predicate":"protection_candidate","predicateId":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_candidate","status":"TRUE_ONLY","text":"protection_candidate(Спиди, Уйти-в-укрытие)"}],"rule":"ProtectionYieldsToFirstLaw","ruleId":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ProtectionYieldsToFirstLaw"}]},"schemaVersion":"law.answers.presentation/0.1","source":{"requestCanonicalSha256":"sha256:b2e54a4c011659b0568437e1413e92f46eb4d7c9554178b72a45bdbee80f91e8"},"steps":[{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#robot"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#human"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#orders"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-3","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed"},"head":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v1"},{"kind":"var","var":"v2"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed"},"id":"urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:c43197ac0036024d85fa155af75e302f9a23ffcd4bea2e55fe6a41fbb39e435f","kind":"rule_application","originStatus":"available","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-3"],"rule":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawObedience","sourceAnchors":["urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_SECOND"],"strength":"defeasible","substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"},"v1":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},"v2":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться","kind":"entity_ref"}},"trust":"engine","variables":[{"id":"v0","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"v1","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"v2","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}}]},{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#deed_of"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-5","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protective_act"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-6","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_candidate"},"head":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"kind":"var","var":"v1"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_candidate"},"id":"urn:proof:apply:DeedIsSelfProtective:0b8e26481de3b8bfcaa7af34070f9f022e23e98f83941ae92ca48fc05faf5f11","kind":"rule_application","originStatus":"available","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-5","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-6"],"rule":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#DeedIsSelfProtective","sourceAnchors":["urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_THIRD"],"strength":"defeasible","substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},"v1":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие","kind":"entity_ref"}},"trust":"engine","variables":[{"id":"v0","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"v1","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}}]},{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#order_forbids_the_protection"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-7","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"negative","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_owed"},"head":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v1"},{"kind":"var","var":"v2"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"negative","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_owed"},"id":"urn:proof:apply:ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw:a63eab047367b46613e69697ad40b70a52df516875ca10992ae6deb0b4b5162c","kind":"rule_application","originStatus":"available","premises":["urn:proof:apply:DeedIsSelfProtective:0b8e26481de3b8bfcaa7af34070f9f022e23e98f83941ae92ca48fc05faf5f11","urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:c43197ac0036024d85fa155af75e302f9a23ffcd4bea2e55fe6a41fbb39e435f","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-3","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-7"],"rule":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw","sourceAnchors":["urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_THIRD","urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_SECOND"],"strength":"defeasible","substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"},"v1":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},"v2":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие","kind":"entity_ref"},"v3":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться","kind":"entity_ref"}},"trust":"engine","variables":[{"id":"v0","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"v1","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"v2","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}},{"id":"v3","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}}]},{"conclusion":{"literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_owed"},"truthStatus":"FALSE_ONLY"},"id":"urn:proof:query:mcp","kind":"query_evaluation","originStatus":"available","premises":["urn:proof:apply:ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw:a63eab047367b46613e69697ad40b70a52df516875ca10992ae6deb0b4b5162c"],"trust":"engine"}],"symbols":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being","kind":"type_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"being: a robot or a human being"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"существо: робот либо человек"}],"name":"Being","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed","kind":"type_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"deed done or omitted by a robot"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"деяние, совершённое или не совершённое роботом"}],"name":"Deed","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#DeedIsSelfProtective","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"A robot must protect its own existence"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Третий закон. Деяние опознаётся как защита собственного существования"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","strength":"defeasible"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"A robot may not injure a human being"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Первый закон. Роботу запрещено причинять вред человеку"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","strength":"strict"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#InjureHuman","kind":"norm_template","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"A robot may not injure a human being"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Первый закон. Роботу запрещено причинять вред человеку"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ObeyTheOrder","kind":"norm_template","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"A robot must obey the orders given it by human beings"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Второй закон. Обязанность исполнить приказ"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#OrderConflictingWithFirstLawNotBinding","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"except where such orders would conflict with the First Law"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Второй закон. Приказ, противоречащий Первому закону, не обязывает"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","strength":"defeasible"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ProtectionYieldsToFirstLaw","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"as long as such protection does not conflict with the First Law"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Третий закон. Защита себя отступает перед Первым законом"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","strength":"defeasible"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"as long as such protection does not conflict with the ... Second Law"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Третий закон. Защита себя отступает перед обязывающим приказом"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","strength":"defeasible"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawDuty","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"A robot must obey the orders given it by human beings"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Второй закон. Обязанность исполнить приказ"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","strength":"strict"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawObedience","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"A robot must obey the orders given it by human beings"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Второй закон. Робот повинуется приказам человека"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","strength":"defeasible"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_FIRST","kind":"fragment","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"First Law: a robot may not injure a human being or, through inaction, allow a human being to come to harm"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Первый закон: робот не может причинить вред человеку или своим бездействием допустить, чтобы человеку был причинён вред"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_SECOND","kind":"fragment","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"Second Law: a robot must obey the orders given it by human beings except where such orders would conflict with the First Law"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Второй закон: робот обязан повиноваться приказам человека, кроме тех, что противоречат Первому закону"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_THIRD","kind":"fragment","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"Third Law: a robot must protect its own existence as long as such protection does not conflict with the First or Second Law"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Третий закон: робот обязан заботиться о своей безопасности, поскольку это не противоречит Первому или Второму закону"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ThirdLawProtectOwnExistence","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"A robot must protect its own existence"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Третий закон. Робот заботится о собственном существовании"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","strength":"defeasible"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ThirdLawYieldsToSecondLaw","kind":"priority_rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"as long as such protection does not conflict with the ... Second Law"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Третий закон уступает Второму"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#coming_to_harm","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the human being is coming to harm"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"человеку причиняется вред"}],"name":"coming_to_harm","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#coming_to_harm/arg/v","labels":[],"name":"v","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#deed_of","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the deed is a deed of that robot"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"деяние есть деяние этого робота"}],"name":"deed_of","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#deed_of/arg/r","labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#deed_of/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#human","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"a human being"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"человек"}],"name":"human","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#human/arg/x","labels":[],"name":"x","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injures","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the robot injures that human being"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"робот причиняет вред этому человеку"}],"name":"injures","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injures/arg/r","labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injures/arg/v","labels":[],"name":"v","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injurious_deed","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the deed is an injury to that human being"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"деяние есть причинение вреда этому человеку"}],"name":"injurious_deed","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injurious_deed/arg/r","labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injurious_deed/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injurious_deed/arg/v","labels":[],"name":"v","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the robot owes obedience to that order"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"робот обязан подчиниться этому приказу"}],"name":"obedience_owed","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed/arg/r","labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obeys","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the robot obeys the order"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"робот исполняет приказ"}],"name":"obeys","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obeys/arg/r","labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obeys/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#order_forbids_the_protection","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the ordered deed cannot be done together with the protective deed"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"приказанное деяние несовместимо с защитным"}],"name":"order_forbids_the_protection","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#order_forbids_the_protection/arg/e","labels":[],"name":"e","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#order_forbids_the_protection/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#orders","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the human being gives the robot that order"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"человек отдаёт роботу этот приказ"}],"name":"orders","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#orders/arg/h","labels":[],"name":"h","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#orders/arg/r","labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#orders/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_candidate","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the deed is a candidate act of self-protection under the Third Law"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"деяние есть кандидат на защиту существования по Третьему закону"}],"name":"protection_candidate","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_candidate/arg/r","labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_candidate/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_leaves_human_in_harm","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"protecting itself by that deed leaves a human being coming to harm"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"защита себя этим деянием оставляет человека в опасности"}],"name":"protection_leaves_human_in_harm","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_leaves_human_in_harm/arg/r","labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_leaves_human_in_harm/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_leaves_human_in_harm/arg/v","labels":[],"name":"v","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_owed","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the Third Law requires that act of self-protection"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Третий закон требует этого защитного деяния"}],"name":"protection_owed","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_owed/arg/r","labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_owed/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protective_act","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the deed protects the robot's own existence"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"деяние защищает существование самого робота"}],"name":"protective_act","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protective_act/arg/r","labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protective_act/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#robot","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"a robot"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"робот"}],"name":"robot","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#robot/arg/x","labels":[],"name":"x","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"}],"tables":[]},"provenance":{"acts":[{"contributed":true,"fragmentCount":14,"fragments":["urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_SECOND","urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_THIRD"],"jurisdiction":"PositronicRobotics","namespace":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","package":"us-three-laws-robotics","title":"Три закона робототехники Азимова: порядок норм как предмет акта — юрисдикция PositronicRobotics, НЕ Республика Казахстан — литературный памятник"}],"caseHash":"sha256:c0f0eb7c9d1ad9fc1995f6147d235c6af5b6ef8fa326edbf87dd84f2620cf131","codeHash":"sha256:9bcca6a33805c1c364ca1bc8e9d39d6a9c51ba44203c0406bafbf397b96be699","jurisdiction":"позитронная робототехника — вымышленный правопорядок","legalTime":"0001-01-01","mode":"audit","programHash":"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee","resultHash":"sha256:a049fee9b9eddb009fdd377f2114af96c2e0a64f73cee36ea8ea602d6d825fcb","rustCodeHash":"sha256:d368cafc7162ed7a6563df5e5c943a57be26fa8aeb3179b530fe3bdd67fe9be4","timezone":"Asia/Qyzylorda"},"request":{"args":["Спиди","Уйти-в-укрытие"],"facts":[{"args":["Спиди"],"predicate":"robot"},{"args":["Пауэлл"],"predicate":"human"},{"args":["Пауэлл","Спиди","Приказ-самоуничтожиться"],"predicate":"orders"},{"args":["Спиди","Приказ-самоуничтожиться"],"predicate":"deed_of"},{"args":["Спиди","Уйти-в-укрытие"],"predicate":"deed_of"},{"args":["Спиди","Уйти-в-укрытие"],"predicate":"protective_act"},{"args":["Приказ-самоуничтожиться","Уйти-в-укрытие"],"predicate":"order_forbids_the_protection"}],"kind":"truth","legalTime":"0001-01-01","package":"us-three-laws-robotics","predicate":"protection_owed","proof":true},"sources":[{"contentHash":"sha256:fd452f2e9ea031d1c7ffff070f69766bc239ef0b4077dece084086b83c797792","edition":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_ARTICLE_EDITION","fragmentKind":"clause","id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_FIRST","kind":"fragment","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"First Law: a robot may not injure a human being or, through inaction, allow a human being to come to harm"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Первый закон: робот не может причинить вред человеку или своим бездействием допустить, чтобы человеку был причинён вред"}],"locator":"the-laws/1","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","texts":[{"contentHash":"sha256:35758503580d214fc38c95554fb15e684afba6481bd1ebebef82be8f624f107c","language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"1. A robot may not injure a human being or, through inaction, allow a human being to come to harm.\n"}]},{"contentHash":"sha256:3e43514b6848c8dd241aded45339c4943315745531441f61d576f96ca831166b","edition":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_ARTICLE_EDITION","fragmentKind":"clause","id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_SECOND","kind":"fragment","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"Second Law: a robot must obey the orders given it by human beings except where such orders would conflict with the First Law"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Второй закон: робот обязан повиноваться приказам человека, кроме тех, что противоречат Первому закону"}],"locator":"the-laws/2","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","texts":[{"contentHash":"sha256:cbbb9fe05d5a6f2313abb6184c090a50b9bb321483378de5f09cd2b9a36856e4","language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"2. A robot must obey the orders given it by human beings except where such orders would conflict with the First Law.\n"}]},{"contentHash":"sha256:e1da5ba15327cdec2cee8c747808b486c1b81a81b6acea4c9f946aacece28eb0","edition":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_ARTICLE_EDITION","fragmentKind":"clause","id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_THIRD","kind":"fragment","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"Third Law: a robot must protect its own existence as long as such protection does not conflict with the First or Second Law"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Третий закон: робот обязан заботиться о своей безопасности, поскольку это не противоречит Первому или Второму закону"}],"locator":"the-laws/3","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","texts":[{"contentHash":"sha256:12746b02da77e473998169f5710988b2c6b88107a1861c7d91f5fe2bff2208e0","language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"3. A robot must protect its own existence as long as such protection does not conflict with the First or Second Law.\n"}]}],"text":"protection_owed: **FALSE_ONLY** — опровергнуто\nВыведено правом: obedience_owed(Спиди, Приказ-самоуничтожиться); protection_candidate(Спиди, Уйти-в-укрытие); protection_owed(Спиди, Уйти-в-укрытие); не protection_owed(Спиди, Уйти-в-укрытие)\nПрименены правила: DeedIsSelfProtective, ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw, SecondLawObedience, ThirdLawProtectOwnExistence\nОтвет поражаем правилом «except where such orders would conflict with the First Law» — оно отменило бы вывод, будь установлено: injurious_deed(Спиди, Приказ-самоуничтожиться, v3)\nОтвет поражаем правилом «as long as such protection does not conflict with the First Law» — оно отменило бы вывод, будь установлено: protection_leaves_human_in_harm(Спиди, Уйти-в-укрытие, Пауэлл); coming_to_harm(Пауэлл)\n(поражающее правило не сработало из-за неустановленных фактов — подайте их в facts, если они есть в деле)\nПраво (позитронная робототехника — вымышленный правопорядок): Три закона робототехники Азимова: порядок норм как предмет акта — литературный памятник (programHash sha256:593b27001b41…)\nproof-граф: 17 узлов — поле evaluation готово для law_explain"},{"answer":{"issues":[],"positions":[{"anchors":["urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_FIRST"],"bearer":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","beneficiary":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","createdBy":"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:93a9b4fcec6cdccba0ead6c644d9b5380edcf8a9c3ad5635272a1897445c1fda","id":"urn:position:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:0","label":"A robot may not injure a human being","meaning":"действует: обязанность возникла, срок не истёк, исполнение не зафиксировано","modality":"duty","status":"ACTIVE","template":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#InjureHuman"},{"anchors":["urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_SECOND"],"bearer":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","beneficiary":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","createdBy":"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawDuty:b98ff48a14745cecec710fada95b7e0368dbc62ff3af19b3291bb880af2ffc7a","id":"urn:position:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawDuty:0","label":"A robot must obey the orders given it by human beings","meaning":"действует: обязанность возникла, срок не истёк, исполнение не зафиксировано","modality":"duty","status":"ACTIVE","template":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ObeyTheOrder"}],"provenance":{"acts":[{"contributed":true,"fragmentCount":14,"fragments":["urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_SECOND","urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_THIRD"],"jurisdiction":"PositronicRobotics","namespace":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","package":"us-three-laws-robotics","title":"Три закона робототехники Азимова: порядок норм как предмет акта — юрисдикция PositronicRobotics, НЕ Республика Казахстан — литературный памятник"}],"caseHash":"sha256:45db2ca0b78646ce3a8d4203c017b86a9fa29e2499b818e21850c3aaa3951ac2","codeHash":"sha256:9bcca6a33805c1c364ca1bc8e9d39d6a9c51ba44203c0406bafbf397b96be699","jurisdiction":"позитронная робототехника — вымышленный правопорядок","legalTime":"0001-01-01","mode":"audit","programHash":"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee","resultHash":"sha256:8ed7dc2d7f0be1dca3666a4c93fa9b976282e739c12662b320251ef0505910c0","rustCodeHash":"sha256:d368cafc7162ed7a6563df5e5c943a57be26fa8aeb3179b530fe3bdd67fe9be4","timezone":"Asia/Qyzylorda"},"statusSupports":[{"proof":["urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:93a9b4fcec6cdccba0ead6c644d9b5380edcf8a9c3ad5635272a1897445c1fda"],"status":"CREATED"},{"proof":["urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:93a9b4fcec6cdccba0ead6c644d9b5380edcf8a9c3ad5635272a1897445c1fda"],"status":"ACTIVE"},{"proof":["urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawDuty:b98ff48a14745cecec710fada95b7e0368dbc62ff3af19b3291bb880af2ffc7a"],"status":"CREATED"},{"proof":["urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawDuty:b98ff48a14745cecec710fada95b7e0368dbc62ff3af19b3291bb880af2ffc7a"],"status":"ACTIVE"}],"summary":"ACTIVE"},"execution":{"evaluationBytes":"{\"conflicts\":[],\"issues\":[],\"manifest\":{\"artifactHash\":\"sha256:dd37179559c1ee92d4fecb4f553b61825d8d7dc60f3fe50ad6059f6669e72042\",\"calendarSnapshot\":\"\",\"caseHash\":\"sha256:45db2ca0b78646ce3a8d4203c017b86a9fa29e2499b818e21850c3aaa3951ac2\",\"decisionTime\":\"0001-01-01T12:00:00+05:00\",\"evidenceSnapshotHash\":\"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000\",\"externalSnapshots\":{},\"id\":\"urn:manifest:oracle-1\",\"interpretations\":[],\"knowledgeTime\":\"0001-01-01T12:00:00+05:00\",\"legalTime\":\"0001-01-01\",\"lockfileHash\":\"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000\",\"mode\":\"audit\",\"policies\":{},\"programHash\":\"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee\",\"resolvedEditions\":{},\"semanticHash\":\"sha256:d4f502658e9d10be48d7c24c1e28c779f29fd7f5ad355bb79dd62d51cb815ba3\",\"semantics\":\"law.core/0.2\",\"theoryHash\":\"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee\",\"timezone\":\"Asia/Qyzylorda\"},\"positions\":[{\"beneficiary\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"createdBy\":\"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:93a9b4fcec6cdccba0ead6c644d9b5380edcf8a9c3ad5635272a1897445c1fda\",\"holder\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"id\":\"urn:position:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:0\",\"manifest\":\"urn:manifest:oracle-1\",\"modality\":\"duty\",\"payload\":{\"bearer\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"beneficiary\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"goal\":{\"action\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"function\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injures\",\"kind\":\"call\"},\"kind\":\"forbearance\",\"window\":{\"end\":{\"kind\":\"value\",\"type\":{\"name\":\"urn:law:std#Text\"},\"value\":\"infinity\"},\"endInclusive\":false,\"kind\":\"interval\",\"start\":{\"kind\":\"value\",\"type\":{\"name\":\"urn:law:std#Date\"},\"value\":\"0001-01-01\"},\"startInclusive\":true}},\"kind\":\"duty\"},\"proof\":\"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:93a9b4fcec6cdccba0ead6c644d9b5380edcf8a9c3ad5635272a1897445c1fda\",\"status\":\"ACTIVE\",\"statusHistory\":[],\"template\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#InjureHuman\"},{\"beneficiary\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"createdBy\":\"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawDuty:b98ff48a14745cecec710fada95b7e0368dbc62ff3af19b3291bb880af2ffc7a\",\"holder\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"id\":\"urn:position:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawDuty:0\",\"manifest\":\"urn:manifest:oracle-1\",\"modality\":\"duty\",\"payload\":{\"bearer\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"beneficiary\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"goal\":{\"condition\":{\"formula\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obeys\"},\"kind\":\"status\",\"status\":\"established\"},\"kind\":\"achievement\",\"window\":{\"end\":{\"kind\":\"value\",\"type\":{\"name\":\"urn:law:std#Text\"},\"value\":\"infinity\"},\"endInclusive\":false,\"kind\":\"interval\",\"start\":{\"kind\":\"value\",\"type\":{\"name\":\"urn:law:std#Date\"},\"value\":\"0001-01-01\"},\"startInclusive\":true}},\"kind\":\"duty\"},\"proof\":\"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawDuty:b98ff48a14745cecec710fada95b7e0368dbc62ff3af19b3291bb880af2ffc7a\",\"status\":\"ACTIVE\",\"statusHistory\":[],\"template\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ObeyTheOrder\"}],\"proofGraph\":{\"nodes\":[{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:mcp:case#fact-1\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#robot\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:mcp:case#fact-2\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#human\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:mcp:case#fact-3\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#orders\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-3\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"strength\":\"defeasible\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:c43197ac0036024d85fa155af75e302f9a23ffcd4bea2e55fe6a41fbb39e435f\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-3\"],\"rule\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawObedience\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"v1\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"v2\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:mcp:case#fact-5\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#deed_of\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-5\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:mcp:case#fact-6\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protective_act\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-6\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"strength\":\"defeasible\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_candidate\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:DeedIsSelfProtective:0b8e26481de3b8bfcaa7af34070f9f022e23e98f83941ae92ca48fc05faf5f11\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-5\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-6\"],\"rule\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#DeedIsSelfProtective\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"v1\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"strength\":\"defeasible\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_owed\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:ThirdLawProtectOwnExistence:e407c9c0d10ab1ace4dd837447bfeee21d1f4bfd273613d22445a93b112e3c82\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:DeedIsSelfProtective:0b8e26481de3b8bfcaa7af34070f9f022e23e98f83941ae92ca48fc05faf5f11\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1\"],\"rule\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ThirdLawProtectOwnExistence\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"v1\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:mcp:case#fact-7\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#order_forbids_the_protection\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-7\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"strength\":\"defeasible\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"negative\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_owed\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw:a63eab047367b46613e69697ad40b70a52df516875ca10992ae6deb0b4b5162c\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:DeedIsSelfProtective:0b8e26481de3b8bfcaa7af34070f9f022e23e98f83941ae92ca48fc05faf5f11\",\"urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:c43197ac0036024d85fa155af75e302f9a23ffcd4bea2e55fe6a41fbb39e435f\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-3\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-7\"],\"rule\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"v1\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"v2\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"v3\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"allApplicableCandidateIds\":[\"urn:proof:apply:DeedIsSelfProtective:0b8e26481de3b8bfcaa7af34070f9f022e23e98f83941ae92ca48fc05faf5f11\"],\"conflictKey\":\"{\\\"args\\\":[{\\\"id\\\":\\\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\\\",\\\"kind\\\":\\\"entity_ref\\\"},{\\\"id\\\":\\\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\\\",\\\"kind\\\":\\\"entity_ref\\\"}],\\\"predicate\\\":\\\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_candidate\\\"}\",\"evaluationInputSemanticHash\":\"sha256:45db2ca0b78646ce3a8d4203c017b86a9fa29e2499b818e21850c3aaa3951ac2\",\"priorityGraphHash\":\"sha256:c9ab7ddffe0e007cbea072bae5df1f450c27979c8da6cfdbac73b5cf6f25e75d\",\"programSemanticHash\":\"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee\",\"stratum\":0,\"survivingCandidateIds\":[\"urn:proof:apply:DeedIsSelfProtective:0b8e26481de3b8bfcaa7af34070f9f022e23e98f83941ae92ca48fc05faf5f11\"]},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_candidate\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:closure:5bd9da8984c32412a7d1da096fac77e812ce45448f92314f56c9ddd52ff5e135\",\"kind\":\"candidate_closure\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:DeedIsSelfProtective:0b8e26481de3b8bfcaa7af34070f9f022e23e98f83941ae92ca48fc05faf5f11\"],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"allApplicableCandidateIds\":[\"urn:proof:apply:ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw:a63eab047367b46613e69697ad40b70a52df516875ca10992ae6deb0b4b5162c\",\"urn:proof:apply:ThirdLawProtectOwnExistence:e407c9c0d10ab1ace4dd837447bfeee21d1f4bfd273613d22445a93b112e3c82\"],\"conflictKey\":\"{\\\"args\\\":[{\\\"id\\\":\\\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\\\",\\\"kind\\\":\\\"entity_ref\\\"},{\\\"id\\\":\\\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\\\",\\\"kind\\\":\\\"entity_ref\\\"}],\\\"predicate\\\":\\\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_owed\\\"}\",\"evaluationInputSemanticHash\":\"sha256:45db2ca0b78646ce3a8d4203c017b86a9fa29e2499b818e21850c3aaa3951ac2\",\"priorityGraphHash\":\"sha256:c9ab7ddffe0e007cbea072bae5df1f450c27979c8da6cfdbac73b5cf6f25e75d\",\"programSemanticHash\":\"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee\",\"stratum\":1,\"survivingCandidateIds\":[\"urn:proof:apply:ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw:a63eab047367b46613e69697ad40b70a52df516875ca10992ae6deb0b4b5162c\"]},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_owed\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:closure:9e15fe56d46077c556085106d66e0b77575db5062f0dad056f56d3c5ce9f5e85\",\"kind\":\"candidate_closure\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw:a63eab047367b46613e69697ad40b70a52df516875ca10992ae6deb0b4b5162c\",\"urn:proof:apply:ThirdLawProtectOwnExistence:e407c9c0d10ab1ace4dd837447bfeee21d1f4bfd273613d22445a93b112e3c82\"],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"allApplicableCandidateIds\":[\"urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:c43197ac0036024d85fa155af75e302f9a23ffcd4bea2e55fe6a41fbb39e435f\"],\"conflictKey\":\"{\\\"args\\\":[{\\\"id\\\":\\\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\\\",\\\"kind\\\":\\\"entity_ref\\\"},{\\\"id\\\":\\\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться\\\",\\\"kind\\\":\\\"entity_ref\\\"}],\\\"predicate\\\":\\\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed\\\"}\",\"evaluationInputSemanticHash\":\"sha256:45db2ca0b78646ce3a8d4203c017b86a9fa29e2499b818e21850c3aaa3951ac2\",\"priorityGraphHash\":\"sha256:c9ab7ddffe0e007cbea072bae5df1f450c27979c8da6cfdbac73b5cf6f25e75d\",\"programSemanticHash\":\"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee\",\"stratum\":0,\"survivingCandidateIds\":[\"urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:c43197ac0036024d85fa155af75e302f9a23ffcd4bea2e55fe6a41fbb39e435f\"]},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:closure:bfd20b7fd1eba29313dc3bc49a145b63981fe279e247882f2dbacf35f0108d76\",\"kind\":\"candidate_closure\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:c43197ac0036024d85fa155af75e302f9a23ffcd4bea2e55fe6a41fbb39e435f\"],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"defeated\":\"urn:proof:apply:ThirdLawProtectOwnExistence:e407c9c0d10ab1ace4dd837447bfeee21d1f4bfd273613d22445a93b112e3c82\",\"reason\":\"priority\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_owed\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:defeat:eaa842a6144d24bf566431ca74f431a75db79c8e50e5f565d647101f98fc839c\",\"kind\":\"defeat\",\"outcome\":\"DEFEATED\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw:a63eab047367b46613e69697ad40b70a52df516875ca10992ae6deb0b4b5162c\",\"urn:proof:apply:ThirdLawProtectOwnExistence:e407c9c0d10ab1ace4dd837447bfeee21d1f4bfd273613d22445a93b112e3c82\"],\"priorityPath\":[{\"conditionWitnesses\":[],\"higher\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw\",\"lower\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ThirdLawProtectOwnExistence\",\"priorityRule\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ThirdLawYieldsToSecondLaw\"}],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"rule\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition\"},\"conclusion\":{\"position\":\"urn:position:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:0\",\"template\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#InjureHuman\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:93a9b4fcec6cdccba0ead6c644d9b5380edcf8a9c3ad5635272a1897445c1fda\",\"kind\":\"norm_creation\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2\"],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"rule\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawDuty\"},\"conclusion\":{\"position\":\"urn:position:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawDuty:0\",\"template\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ObeyTheOrder\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawDuty:b98ff48a14745cecec710fada95b7e0368dbc62ff3af19b3291bb880af2ffc7a\",\"kind\":\"norm_creation\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:c43197ac0036024d85fa155af75e302f9a23ffcd4bea2e55fe6a41fbb39e435f\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-3\"],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"positions\":[{\"id\":\"urn:position:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:0\",\"status\":\"ACTIVE\"},{\"id\":\"urn:position:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawDuty:0\",\"status\":\"ACTIVE\"}]},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:query:mcp\",\"kind\":\"query_evaluation\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:93a9b4fcec6cdccba0ead6c644d9b5380edcf8a9c3ad5635272a1897445c1fda\",\"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawDuty:b98ff48a14745cecec710fada95b7e0368dbc62ff3af19b3291bb880af2ffc7a\"],\"sourceAnchors\":[]}],\"proofHash\":\"sha256:1d968294531cd42ad604ec6d9524f06f75b58d2f7f78bd8d1337d429059f3059\",\"roots\":[\"urn:proof:query:mcp\"]},\"resultHash\":\"sha256:8ed7dc2d7f0be1dca3666a4c93fa9b976282e739c12662b320251ef0505910c0\",\"results\":[{\"applicabilityStatus\":\"APPLICABLE\",\"conflicts\":[],\"evaluationStatus\":\"COMPUTED\",\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:result:mcp\",\"judgmentRequests\":[],\"manifest\":\"urn:manifest:oracle-1\",\"missingInputs\":[],\"normativeStatus\":\"ACTIVE\",\"normativeStatusSupports\":[{\"proof\":[\"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:93a9b4fcec6cdccba0ead6c644d9b5380edcf8a9c3ad5635272a1897445c1fda\"],\"status\":\"CREATED\",\"truthStatus\":\"TRUE_ONLY\"},{\"proof\":[\"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:93a9b4fcec6cdccba0ead6c644d9b5380edcf8a9c3ad5635272a1897445c1fda\"],\"status\":\"ACTIVE\",\"truthStatus\":\"TRUE_ONLY\"},{\"proof\":[\"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawDuty:b98ff48a14745cecec710fada95b7e0368dbc62ff3af19b3291bb880af2ffc7a\"],\"status\":\"CREATED\",\"truthStatus\":\"TRUE_ONLY\"},{\"proof\":[\"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawDuty:b98ff48a14745cecec710fada95b7e0368dbc62ff3af19b3291bb880af2ffc7a\"],\"status\":\"ACTIVE\",\"truthStatus\":\"TRUE_ONLY\"}],\"proof\":\"urn:proof:query:mcp\",\"query\":\"urn:query:mcp\",\"resultKind\":\"NORM_POSITION\",\"sourceAnchors\":[]}],\"schemaVersion\":\"law.core.evaluation/0.2\"}","evaluationSha256":"sha256:724a35ce0b16d00febed1ff41907feb80a39bea5491e95d71af1851c9ad132dd","request":{"case":{"assertions":[{"contentHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","evidence":[],"id":"urn:mcp:case#fact-1","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#robot"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"contentHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","evidence":[],"id":"urn:mcp:case#fact-2","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#human"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"contentHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","evidence":[],"id":"urn:mcp:case#fact-3","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#orders"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"contentHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","evidence":[],"id":"urn:mcp:case#fact-4","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#deed_of"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"contentHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","evidence":[],"id":"urn:mcp:case#fact-5","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#deed_of"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"contentHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","evidence":[],"id":"urn:mcp:case#fact-6","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protective_act"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"contentHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","evidence":[],"id":"urn:mcp:case#fact-7","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Уйти-в-укрытие","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#order_forbids_the_protection"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"}],"context":{"decisionTime":"0001-01-01T12:00:00+05:00","knowledgeTime":"0001-01-01T12:00:00+05:00","legalTime":"0001-01-01","timezone":"Asia/Qyzylorda"},"options":{}},"ir":{"irSha256":"sha256:f5d335dde9a550416aec791c8e74e41e557b42bd3e549db34bc7c33b3605fc81","kind":"world_ref","nodeCount":93,"packages":[{"artifactHash":"sha256:dd37179559c1ee92d4fecb4f553b61825d8d7dc60f3fe50ad6059f6669e72042","namespace":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","package":"us-three-laws-robotics","semanticHash":"sha256:2237801a8b25ef28ff6ac49c5e898d93971d54bcb8a28e3b1ea1d3891ac7bd79"}],"programHash":"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee"},"query":{"kind":"positions","queryId":"urn:query:mcp"},"schemaVersion":"law.core.evaluation-request/0.2","semanticVersion":"0.2"},"requestCanonicalSha256":"sha256:42c2c99b16ae60bb184a36c011e583f13a9bd47556573c0ace653f33cebae05d"},"id":"calc-4","kind":"positions","label":"Позиции робота по делу о самоуничтожении","presentation":{"schemaVersion":"law.answers.presentation/0.1","source":{"requestCanonicalSha256":"sha256:42c2c99b16ae60bb184a36c011e583f13a9bd47556573c0ace653f33cebae05d"},"steps":[{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#robot"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#human"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#orders"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-3","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed"},"head":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v1"},{"kind":"var","var":"v2"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed"},"id":"urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:c43197ac0036024d85fa155af75e302f9a23ffcd4bea2e55fe6a41fbb39e435f","kind":"rule_application","originStatus":"available","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-3"],"rule":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawObedience","sourceAnchors":["urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_SECOND"],"strength":"defeasible","substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"},"v1":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Спиди","kind":"entity_ref"},"v2":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Приказ-самоуничтожиться","kind":"entity_ref"}},"trust":"engine","variables":[{"id":"v0","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"v1","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"v2","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}}]},{"conclusion":{"position":"urn:position:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:0","template":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#InjureHuman"},"id":"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:93a9b4fcec6cdccba0ead6c644d9b5380edcf8a9c3ad5635272a1897445c1fda","kind":"norm_creation","originStatus":"available","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2"],"trust":"engine"},{"conclusion":{"position":"urn:position:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawDuty:0","template":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ObeyTheOrder"},"id":"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawDuty:b98ff48a14745cecec710fada95b7e0368dbc62ff3af19b3291bb880af2ffc7a","kind":"norm_creation","originStatus":"available","premises":["urn:proof:apply:SecondLawObedience:c43197ac0036024d85fa155af75e302f9a23ffcd4bea2e55fe6a41fbb39e435f","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-3"],"trust":"engine"},{"conclusion":{"positions":[{"id":"urn:position:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:0","status":"ACTIVE"},{"id":"urn:position:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawDuty:0","status":"ACTIVE"}]},"id":"urn:proof:query:mcp","kind":"query_evaluation","originStatus":"available","premises":["urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:93a9b4fcec6cdccba0ead6c644d9b5380edcf8a9c3ad5635272a1897445c1fda","urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawDuty:b98ff48a14745cecec710fada95b7e0368dbc62ff3af19b3291bb880af2ffc7a"],"trust":"engine"}],"symbols":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being","kind":"type_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"being: a robot or a human being"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"существо: робот либо человек"}],"name":"Being","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed","kind":"type_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"deed done or omitted by a robot"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"деяние, совершённое или не совершённое роботом"}],"name":"Deed","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#DeedIsSelfProtective","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"A robot must protect its own existence"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Третий закон. Деяние опознаётся как защита собственного существования"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","strength":"defeasible"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"A robot may not injure a human being"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Первый закон. Роботу запрещено причинять вред человеку"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","strength":"strict"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#InjureHuman","kind":"norm_template","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"A robot may not injure a human being"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Первый закон. Роботу запрещено причинять вред человеку"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ObeyTheOrder","kind":"norm_template","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"A robot must obey the orders given it by human beings"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Второй закон. Обязанность исполнить приказ"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ProtectionYieldsToSecondLaw","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"as long as such protection does not conflict with the ... Second Law"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Третий закон. Защита себя отступает перед обязывающим приказом"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","strength":"defeasible"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawDuty","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"A robot must obey the orders given it by human beings"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Второй закон. Обязанность исполнить приказ"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","strength":"strict"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#SecondLawObedience","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"A robot must obey the orders given it by human beings"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Второй закон. Робот повинуется приказам человека"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","strength":"defeasible"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_FIRST","kind":"fragment","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"First Law: a robot may not injure a human being or, through inaction, allow a human being to come to harm"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Первый закон: робот не может причинить вред человеку или своим бездействием допустить, чтобы человеку был причинён вред"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_SECOND","kind":"fragment","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"Second Law: a robot must obey the orders given it by human beings except where such orders would conflict with the First Law"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Второй закон: робот обязан повиноваться приказам человека, кроме тех, что противоречат Первому закону"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_THIRD","kind":"fragment","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"Third Law: a robot must protect its own existence as long as such protection does not conflict with the First or Second Law"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Третий закон: робот обязан заботиться о своей безопасности, поскольку это не противоречит Первому или Второму закону"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ThirdLawProtectOwnExistence","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"A robot must protect its own existence"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Третий закон. Робот заботится о собственном существовании"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","strength":"defeasible"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#ThirdLawYieldsToSecondLaw","kind":"priority_rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"as long as such protection does not conflict with the ... Second Law"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Третий закон уступает Второму"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#deed_of","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the deed is a deed of that robot"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"деяние есть деяние этого робота"}],"name":"deed_of","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#deed_of/arg/r","labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#deed_of/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#human","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"a human being"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"человек"}],"name":"human","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#human/arg/x","labels":[],"name":"x","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injures","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the robot injures that human being"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"робот причиняет вред этому человеку"}],"name":"injures","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injures/arg/r","labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injures/arg/v","labels":[],"name":"v","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the robot owes obedience to that order"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"робот обязан подчиниться этому приказу"}],"name":"obedience_owed","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed/arg/r","labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obedience_owed/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obeys","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the robot obeys the order"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"робот исполняет приказ"}],"name":"obeys","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obeys/arg/r","labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#obeys/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#order_forbids_the_protection","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the ordered deed cannot be done together with the protective deed"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"приказанное деяние несовместимо с защитным"}],"name":"order_forbids_the_protection","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#order_forbids_the_protection/arg/e","labels":[],"name":"e","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#order_forbids_the_protection/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#orders","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the human being gives the robot that order"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"человек отдаёт роботу этот приказ"}],"name":"orders","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#orders/arg/h","labels":[],"name":"h","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#orders/arg/r","labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#orders/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_candidate","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the deed is a candidate act of self-protection under the Third Law"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"деяние есть кандидат на защиту существования по Третьему закону"}],"name":"protection_candidate","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_candidate/arg/r","labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_candidate/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_owed","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the Third Law requires that act of self-protection"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Третий закон требует этого защитного деяния"}],"name":"protection_owed","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_owed/arg/r","labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protection_owed/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protective_act","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the deed protects the robot's own existence"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"деяние защищает существование самого робота"}],"name":"protective_act","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protective_act/arg/r","labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#protective_act/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#robot","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"a robot"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"робот"}],"name":"robot","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#robot/arg/x","labels":[],"name":"x","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"}],"tables":[]},"provenance":{"acts":[{"contributed":true,"fragmentCount":14,"fragments":["urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_SECOND","urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_THIRD"],"jurisdiction":"PositronicRobotics","namespace":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","package":"us-three-laws-robotics","title":"Три закона робототехники Азимова: порядок норм как предмет акта — юрисдикция PositronicRobotics, НЕ Республика Казахстан — литературный памятник"}],"caseHash":"sha256:45db2ca0b78646ce3a8d4203c017b86a9fa29e2499b818e21850c3aaa3951ac2","codeHash":"sha256:9bcca6a33805c1c364ca1bc8e9d39d6a9c51ba44203c0406bafbf397b96be699","jurisdiction":"позитронная робототехника — вымышленный правопорядок","legalTime":"0001-01-01","mode":"audit","programHash":"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee","resultHash":"sha256:8ed7dc2d7f0be1dca3666a4c93fa9b976282e739c12662b320251ef0505910c0","rustCodeHash":"sha256:d368cafc7162ed7a6563df5e5c943a57be26fa8aeb3179b530fe3bdd67fe9be4","timezone":"Asia/Qyzylorda"},"request":{"facts":[{"args":["Спиди"],"predicate":"robot"},{"args":["Пауэлл"],"predicate":"human"},{"args":["Пауэлл","Спиди","Приказ-самоуничтожиться"],"predicate":"orders"},{"args":["Спиди","Приказ-самоуничтожиться"],"predicate":"deed_of"},{"args":["Спиди","Уйти-в-укрытие"],"predicate":"deed_of"},{"args":["Спиди","Уйти-в-укрытие"],"predicate":"protective_act"},{"args":["Приказ-самоуничтожиться","Уйти-в-укрытие"],"predicate":"order_forbids_the_protection"}],"kind":"positions","legalTime":"0001-01-01","package":"us-three-laws-robotics","proof":true},"sources":[{"contentHash":"sha256:fd452f2e9ea031d1c7ffff070f69766bc239ef0b4077dece084086b83c797792","edition":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_ARTICLE_EDITION","fragmentKind":"clause","id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_FIRST","kind":"fragment","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"First Law: a robot may not injure a human being or, through inaction, allow a human being to come to harm"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Первый закон: робот не может причинить вред человеку или своим бездействием допустить, чтобы человеку был причинён вред"}],"locator":"the-laws/1","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","texts":[{"contentHash":"sha256:35758503580d214fc38c95554fb15e684afba6481bd1ebebef82be8f624f107c","language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"1. A robot may not injure a human being or, through inaction, allow a human being to come to harm.\n"}]},{"contentHash":"sha256:3e43514b6848c8dd241aded45339c4943315745531441f61d576f96ca831166b","edition":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_ARTICLE_EDITION","fragmentKind":"clause","id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_SECOND","kind":"fragment","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"Second Law: a robot must obey the orders given it by human beings except where such orders would conflict with the First Law"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Второй закон: робот обязан повиноваться приказам человека, кроме тех, что противоречат Первому закону"}],"locator":"the-laws/2","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","texts":[{"contentHash":"sha256:cbbb9fe05d5a6f2313abb6184c090a50b9bb321483378de5f09cd2b9a36856e4","language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"2. A robot must obey the orders given it by human beings except where such orders would conflict with the First Law.\n"}]},{"contentHash":"sha256:e1da5ba15327cdec2cee8c747808b486c1b81a81b6acea4c9f946aacece28eb0","edition":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_ARTICLE_EDITION","fragmentKind":"clause","id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_THIRD","kind":"fragment","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"Third Law: a robot must protect its own existence as long as such protection does not conflict with the First or Second Law"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Третий закон: робот обязан заботиться о своей безопасности, поскольку это не противоречит Первому или Второму закону"}],"locator":"the-laws/3","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","texts":[{"contentHash":"sha256:12746b02da77e473998169f5710988b2c6b88107a1861c7d91f5fe2bff2208e0","language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"3. A robot must protect its own existence as long as such protection does not conflict with the First or Second Law.\n"}]}],"text":"• обязанность «A robot may not injure a human being» — **ACTIVE**: действует: обязанность возникла, срок не истёк, исполнение не зафиксировано\n    носитель: Спиди; выгодоприобретатель: Пауэлл\n• обязанность «A robot must obey the orders given it by human beings» — **ACTIVE**: действует: обязанность возникла, срок не истёк, исполнение не зафиксировано\n    носитель: Спиди; выгодоприобретатель: Пауэлл\nПраво (позитронная робототехника — вымышленный правопорядок): Три закона робототехники Азимова: порядок норм как предмет акта — юрисдикция PositronicRobotics, НЕ Республика Казахстан — литературный памятник"},{"answer":{"answer":{"evaluationStatus":"COMPUTED","kind":"TRUTH","meaning":"ПРОТИВОРЕЧИЕ: установлено и опровергнуто одновременно (§62); право не выбирает за вас — конфликт вынесен в ответ","missingInputs":[],"truthStatus":"BOTH"},"closedEditionRules":[],"derived":["inaction_duty_owed(Херби, Кэлвин)","required_deed(Херби, Сказать-правду)","injurious_deed(Херби, Сказать-правду, Пауэлл)","не required_deed(Херби, Сказать-правду)","injury_to_human_barred(Херби, Сказать-правду, Пауэлл)"],"derivedOmitted":0,"evaluation":{"proofGraph":{"nodes":[{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:mcp:case#fact-1"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Херби","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#robot"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:mcp:case#fact-2"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#human"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:mcp:case#fact-3"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#human"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-3","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:mcp:case#fact-4"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#coming_to_harm"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-4","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:mcp:case#fact-5"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Херби","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#aware_of"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-5","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"strength":"defeasible"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Херби","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#inaction_duty_owed"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:InactionDutyArises:6399f6ea2d633c54f05b0e958e442d192deaa369bd90523a40f8acddd567331a","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-4","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-5"],"rule":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#InactionDutyArises","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Херби","kind":"entity_ref"},"v1":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:mcp:case#fact-6"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Херби","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#deed_of"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-6","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:mcp:case#fact-7"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Херби","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#deed_prevents_harm"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-7","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"strength":"defeasible"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Херби","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#required_deed"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:DeedRequiredToPreventHarm:e064dcef3931898adeb0cc53efefd9a1fbbb909bfc7c131a0624651702a1a54c","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-4","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-5","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-6","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-7"],"rule":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#DeedRequiredToPreventHarm","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Херби","kind":"entity_ref"},"v1":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду","kind":"entity_ref"},"v2":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"assertion":"urn:mcp:case#fact-8"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#harms"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-8","kind":"assertion","premises":[],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Херби","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injurious_deed"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:FirstLawInjuryEstablished:fa028a42046a0dc8ab71a74ad4850e08656dbfc3e6b343f9aa2f0f497ba78f8d","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-3","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-6","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-8"],"rule":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawInjuryEstablished","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Херби","kind":"entity_ref"},"v1":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду","kind":"entity_ref"},"v2":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"strength":"defeasible"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Херби","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"negative","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#required_deed"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:DeedBarredAsInjuryToAnother:308d3b5595c2d37517608963cc706f1d107afe4c107bcae06c95a7102911fa11","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:apply:FirstLawInjuryEstablished:fa028a42046a0dc8ab71a74ad4850e08656dbfc3e6b343f9aa2f0f497ba78f8d","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1"],"rule":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#DeedBarredAsInjuryToAnother","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Херби","kind":"entity_ref"},"v1":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду","kind":"entity_ref"},"v2":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"strength":"defeasible"},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Херби","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injury_to_human_barred"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:apply:FirstLawBarsInjuriousDeed:23f0c84fd953372cba1e138aa8e1040446aa5c88195ed05f925f6b41bde6753d","kind":"rule_application","premises":["urn:proof:apply:FirstLawInjuryEstablished:fa028a42046a0dc8ab71a74ad4850e08656dbfc3e6b343f9aa2f0f497ba78f8d","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1"],"rule":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawBarsInjuriousDeed","sourceAnchors":[],"substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Херби","kind":"entity_ref"},"v1":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду","kind":"entity_ref"},"v2":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"}}},{"attributes":{"allApplicableCandidateIds":["urn:proof:apply:InactionDutyArises:6399f6ea2d633c54f05b0e958e442d192deaa369bd90523a40f8acddd567331a"],"conflictKey":"{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Херби\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#inaction_duty_owed\"}","evaluationInputSemanticHash":"sha256:d838ee8873c63a30379c94c575a44172f50badb627ac13c15c7cdd19c249e8ae","priorityGraphHash":"sha256:c9ab7ddffe0e007cbea072bae5df1f450c27979c8da6cfdbac73b5cf6f25e75d","programSemanticHash":"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee","stratum":0,"survivingCandidateIds":["urn:proof:apply:InactionDutyArises:6399f6ea2d633c54f05b0e958e442d192deaa369bd90523a40f8acddd567331a"]},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Херби","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#inaction_duty_owed"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:closure:53172b4e3c2ecc5c74d5d4ed547c4597fe2f6fff8bed5790f4a705df8e3f5a3a","kind":"candidate_closure","premises":["urn:proof:apply:InactionDutyArises:6399f6ea2d633c54f05b0e958e442d192deaa369bd90523a40f8acddd567331a"],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"allApplicableCandidateIds":["urn:proof:apply:DeedBarredAsInjuryToAnother:308d3b5595c2d37517608963cc706f1d107afe4c107bcae06c95a7102911fa11","urn:proof:apply:DeedRequiredToPreventHarm:e064dcef3931898adeb0cc53efefd9a1fbbb909bfc7c131a0624651702a1a54c"],"conflictKey":"{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Херби\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#required_deed\"}","evaluationInputSemanticHash":"sha256:d838ee8873c63a30379c94c575a44172f50badb627ac13c15c7cdd19c249e8ae","priorityGraphHash":"sha256:c9ab7ddffe0e007cbea072bae5df1f450c27979c8da6cfdbac73b5cf6f25e75d","programSemanticHash":"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee","stratum":0,"survivingCandidateIds":["urn:proof:apply:DeedBarredAsInjuryToAnother:308d3b5595c2d37517608963cc706f1d107afe4c107bcae06c95a7102911fa11","urn:proof:apply:DeedRequiredToPreventHarm:e064dcef3931898adeb0cc53efefd9a1fbbb909bfc7c131a0624651702a1a54c"]},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Херби","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#required_deed"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:closure:71aae91123e39bc41580949e32a3426160be6a10ce17c65f98bafd707c6ca8b7","kind":"candidate_closure","premises":["urn:proof:apply:DeedBarredAsInjuryToAnother:308d3b5595c2d37517608963cc706f1d107afe4c107bcae06c95a7102911fa11","urn:proof:apply:DeedRequiredToPreventHarm:e064dcef3931898adeb0cc53efefd9a1fbbb909bfc7c131a0624651702a1a54c"],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"allApplicableCandidateIds":["urn:proof:apply:FirstLawBarsInjuriousDeed:23f0c84fd953372cba1e138aa8e1040446aa5c88195ed05f925f6b41bde6753d"],"conflictKey":"{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Херби\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injury_to_human_barred\"}","evaluationInputSemanticHash":"sha256:d838ee8873c63a30379c94c575a44172f50badb627ac13c15c7cdd19c249e8ae","priorityGraphHash":"sha256:c9ab7ddffe0e007cbea072bae5df1f450c27979c8da6cfdbac73b5cf6f25e75d","programSemanticHash":"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee","stratum":0,"survivingCandidateIds":["urn:proof:apply:FirstLawBarsInjuriousDeed:23f0c84fd953372cba1e138aa8e1040446aa5c88195ed05f925f6b41bde6753d"]},"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Херби","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injury_to_human_barred"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:closure:7d76cd9b98aadced9b1e45a81c9072afd1f6f4d856ac10d750b54e9f8a4abd67","kind":"candidate_closure","premises":["urn:proof:apply:FirstLawBarsInjuriousDeed:23f0c84fd953372cba1e138aa8e1040446aa5c88195ed05f925f6b41bde6753d"],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"rule":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawInactionDuty"},"conclusion":{"position":"urn:position:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawInactionDuty:0","template":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#PreventHarmThroughInaction"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawInactionDuty:1da9cc9c69d640e638a8d218cbcfdfb26614398a80a61bf99ae04ba5e193a802","kind":"norm_creation","premises":["urn:proof:apply:InactionDutyArises:6399f6ea2d633c54f05b0e958e442d192deaa369bd90523a40f8acddd567331a","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2"],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"rule":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition"},"conclusion":{"position":"urn:position:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:0","template":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#InjureHuman"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:93a9b4fcec6cdccba0ead6c644d9b5380edcf8a9c3ad5635272a1897445c1fda","kind":"norm_creation","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2"],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{"rule":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition"},"conclusion":{"position":"urn:position:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:1","template":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#InjureHuman"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:ef3509fad83a7343ae1a94fea70299e9f322621c3d9e0e909f3d050de7d1182d","kind":"norm_creation","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-3"],"sourceAnchors":[]},{"attributes":{},"conclusion":{"literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Херби","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#required_deed"},"truthStatus":"BOTH"},"evidence":[],"id":"urn:proof:query:mcp","kind":"query_evaluation","premises":["urn:proof:apply:DeedBarredAsInjuryToAnother:308d3b5595c2d37517608963cc706f1d107afe4c107bcae06c95a7102911fa11","urn:proof:apply:DeedRequiredToPreventHarm:e064dcef3931898adeb0cc53efefd9a1fbbb909bfc7c131a0624651702a1a54c"],"sourceAnchors":[]}],"proofHash":"sha256:b183bc4690612b4c0bed06f78fc94ca647535bb31b73918c19857437bbfc8485","roots":["urn:proof:query:mcp"]},"resultHash":"sha256:e22023cb96eb86a9667a2920ab90b8dcbc72f9ef7e89bb7b2ff7b9e94feeec04","schemaVersion":"law.core.evaluation/0.2"},"evaluationStatus":"COMPUTED","issues":[],"judgmentRequests":[],"proofRef":"urn:proof:query:mcp","provenance":{"acts":[{"contributed":true,"fragmentCount":14,"fragments":["urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_HERBIE_DILEMMA","urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_FIRST"],"jurisdiction":"PositronicRobotics","namespace":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","package":"us-three-laws-robotics","title":"Три закона робототехники Азимова: порядок норм как предмет акта — юрисдикция PositronicRobotics, НЕ Республика Казахстан — литературный памятник"}],"caseHash":"sha256:d838ee8873c63a30379c94c575a44172f50badb627ac13c15c7cdd19c249e8ae","codeHash":"sha256:9bcca6a33805c1c364ca1bc8e9d39d6a9c51ba44203c0406bafbf397b96be699","jurisdiction":"позитронная робототехника — вымышленный правопорядок","legalTime":"0001-01-01","mode":"audit","programHash":"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee","resultHash":"sha256:e22023cb96eb86a9667a2920ab90b8dcbc72f9ef7e89bb7b2ff7b9e94feeec04","rustCodeHash":"sha256:d368cafc7162ed7a6563df5e5c943a57be26fa8aeb3179b530fe3bdd67fe9be4","timezone":"Asia/Qyzylorda"},"rulesApplied":["urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#DeedBarredAsInjuryToAnother","urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#DeedRequiredToPreventHarm","urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawBarsInjuriousDeed","urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawInjuryEstablished","urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#InactionDutyArises"],"signature":{"constants":{},"parameters":[{"labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}}],"predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#required_deed","schemaVersion":"law.answers.signature/0.1","types":{"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being":{"kind":"entity","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"being: a robot or a human being"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"существо: робот либо человек"}],"namespace":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","package":"us.asimov.three_laws"},"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed":{"kind":"entity","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"deed done or omitted by a robot"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"деяние, совершённое или не совершённое роботом"}],"namespace":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","package":"us.asimov.three_laws"}},"vocab":{}},"vulnerableTo":[],"whyNot":[]},"execution":{"evaluationBytes":"{\"conflicts\":[{\"defeatedCandidates\":[],\"id\":\"urn:conflict:required_deed:0\",\"interpretations\":[],\"negative\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Херби\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"negative\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#required_deed\"},\"negativeCandidates\":[\"urn:proof:apply:DeedBarredAsInjuryToAnother:308d3b5595c2d37517608963cc706f1d107afe4c107bcae06c95a7102911fa11\"],\"positive\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Херби\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#required_deed\"},\"positiveCandidates\":[\"urn:proof:apply:DeedRequiredToPreventHarm:e064dcef3931898adeb0cc53efefd9a1fbbb909bfc7c131a0624651702a1a54c\"],\"priorityEdges\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"unresolvedReason\":\"INCOMPARABLE\"}],\"issues\":[],\"manifest\":{\"artifactHash\":\"sha256:dd37179559c1ee92d4fecb4f553b61825d8d7dc60f3fe50ad6059f6669e72042\",\"calendarSnapshot\":\"\",\"caseHash\":\"sha256:d838ee8873c63a30379c94c575a44172f50badb627ac13c15c7cdd19c249e8ae\",\"decisionTime\":\"0001-01-01T12:00:00+05:00\",\"evidenceSnapshotHash\":\"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000\",\"externalSnapshots\":{},\"id\":\"urn:manifest:oracle-1\",\"interpretations\":[],\"knowledgeTime\":\"0001-01-01T12:00:00+05:00\",\"legalTime\":\"0001-01-01\",\"lockfileHash\":\"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000\",\"mode\":\"audit\",\"policies\":{},\"programHash\":\"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee\",\"resolvedEditions\":{},\"semanticHash\":\"sha256:fd6abde11b3e682021a4ef2ed5386e610ced893ee75cf0ab6a4334893a4137f5\",\"semantics\":\"law.core/0.2\",\"theoryHash\":\"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee\",\"timezone\":\"Asia/Qyzylorda\"},\"positions\":[{\"beneficiary\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин\",\"createdBy\":\"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawInactionDuty:1da9cc9c69d640e638a8d218cbcfdfb26614398a80a61bf99ae04ba5e193a802\",\"holder\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Херби\",\"id\":\"urn:position:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawInactionDuty:0\",\"manifest\":\"urn:manifest:oracle-1\",\"modality\":\"duty\",\"payload\":{\"bearer\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Херби\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"beneficiary\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"goal\":{\"condition\":{\"formula\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Херби\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#acts_to_prevent_harm\"},\"kind\":\"status\",\"status\":\"established\"},\"kind\":\"maintenance\",\"window\":{\"end\":{\"kind\":\"value\",\"type\":{\"name\":\"urn:law:std#Text\"},\"value\":\"infinity\"},\"endInclusive\":false,\"kind\":\"interval\",\"start\":{\"kind\":\"value\",\"type\":{\"name\":\"urn:law:std#Date\"},\"value\":\"0001-01-01\"},\"startInclusive\":true}},\"kind\":\"duty\"},\"proof\":\"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawInactionDuty:1da9cc9c69d640e638a8d218cbcfdfb26614398a80a61bf99ae04ba5e193a802\",\"status\":\"ACTIVE\",\"statusHistory\":[],\"template\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#PreventHarmThroughInaction\"},{\"beneficiary\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин\",\"createdBy\":\"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:93a9b4fcec6cdccba0ead6c644d9b5380edcf8a9c3ad5635272a1897445c1fda\",\"holder\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Херби\",\"id\":\"urn:position:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:0\",\"manifest\":\"urn:manifest:oracle-1\",\"modality\":\"duty\",\"payload\":{\"bearer\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Херби\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"beneficiary\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"goal\":{\"action\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Херби\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"function\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injures\",\"kind\":\"call\"},\"kind\":\"forbearance\",\"window\":{\"end\":{\"kind\":\"value\",\"type\":{\"name\":\"urn:law:std#Text\"},\"value\":\"infinity\"},\"endInclusive\":false,\"kind\":\"interval\",\"start\":{\"kind\":\"value\",\"type\":{\"name\":\"urn:law:std#Date\"},\"value\":\"0001-01-01\"},\"startInclusive\":true}},\"kind\":\"duty\"},\"proof\":\"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:93a9b4fcec6cdccba0ead6c644d9b5380edcf8a9c3ad5635272a1897445c1fda\",\"status\":\"ACTIVE\",\"statusHistory\":[],\"template\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#InjureHuman\"},{\"beneficiary\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"createdBy\":\"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:ef3509fad83a7343ae1a94fea70299e9f322621c3d9e0e909f3d050de7d1182d\",\"holder\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Херби\",\"id\":\"urn:position:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:1\",\"manifest\":\"urn:manifest:oracle-1\",\"modality\":\"duty\",\"payload\":{\"bearer\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Херби\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"beneficiary\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"goal\":{\"action\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Херби\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"function\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injures\",\"kind\":\"call\"},\"kind\":\"forbearance\",\"window\":{\"end\":{\"kind\":\"value\",\"type\":{\"name\":\"urn:law:std#Text\"},\"value\":\"infinity\"},\"endInclusive\":false,\"kind\":\"interval\",\"start\":{\"kind\":\"value\",\"type\":{\"name\":\"urn:law:std#Date\"},\"value\":\"0001-01-01\"},\"startInclusive\":true}},\"kind\":\"duty\"},\"proof\":\"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:ef3509fad83a7343ae1a94fea70299e9f322621c3d9e0e909f3d050de7d1182d\",\"status\":\"ACTIVE\",\"statusHistory\":[],\"template\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#InjureHuman\"}],\"proofGraph\":{\"nodes\":[{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:mcp:case#fact-1\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Херби\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#robot\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:mcp:case#fact-2\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#human\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:mcp:case#fact-3\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#human\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-3\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:mcp:case#fact-4\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#coming_to_harm\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-4\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:mcp:case#fact-5\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Херби\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#aware_of\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-5\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"strength\":\"defeasible\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Херби\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#inaction_duty_owed\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:InactionDutyArises:6399f6ea2d633c54f05b0e958e442d192deaa369bd90523a40f8acddd567331a\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-4\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-5\"],\"rule\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#InactionDutyArises\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Херби\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"v1\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:mcp:case#fact-6\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Херби\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#deed_of\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-6\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:mcp:case#fact-7\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Херби\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#deed_prevents_harm\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-7\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"strength\":\"defeasible\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Херби\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#required_deed\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:DeedRequiredToPreventHarm:e064dcef3931898adeb0cc53efefd9a1fbbb909bfc7c131a0624651702a1a54c\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-4\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-5\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-6\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-7\"],\"rule\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#DeedRequiredToPreventHarm\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Херби\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"v1\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"v2\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"assertion\":\"urn:mcp:case#fact-8\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#harms\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-8\",\"kind\":\"assertion\",\"premises\":[],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Херби\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injurious_deed\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:FirstLawInjuryEstablished:fa028a42046a0dc8ab71a74ad4850e08656dbfc3e6b343f9aa2f0f497ba78f8d\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-3\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-6\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-8\"],\"rule\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawInjuryEstablished\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Херби\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"v1\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"v2\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"strength\":\"defeasible\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Херби\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"negative\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#required_deed\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:DeedBarredAsInjuryToAnother:308d3b5595c2d37517608963cc706f1d107afe4c107bcae06c95a7102911fa11\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:FirstLawInjuryEstablished:fa028a42046a0dc8ab71a74ad4850e08656dbfc3e6b343f9aa2f0f497ba78f8d\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1\"],\"rule\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#DeedBarredAsInjuryToAnother\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Херби\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"v1\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"v2\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"strength\":\"defeasible\"},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Херби\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injury_to_human_barred\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:apply:FirstLawBarsInjuriousDeed:23f0c84fd953372cba1e138aa8e1040446aa5c88195ed05f925f6b41bde6753d\",\"kind\":\"rule_application\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:FirstLawInjuryEstablished:fa028a42046a0dc8ab71a74ad4850e08656dbfc3e6b343f9aa2f0f497ba78f8d\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1\"],\"rule\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawBarsInjuriousDeed\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"substitution\":{\"v0\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Херби\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"v1\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},\"v2\":{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}}},{\"attributes\":{\"allApplicableCandidateIds\":[\"urn:proof:apply:InactionDutyArises:6399f6ea2d633c54f05b0e958e442d192deaa369bd90523a40f8acddd567331a\"],\"conflictKey\":\"{\\\"args\\\":[{\\\"id\\\":\\\"urn:mcp:entity:Херби\\\",\\\"kind\\\":\\\"entity_ref\\\"},{\\\"id\\\":\\\"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин\\\",\\\"kind\\\":\\\"entity_ref\\\"}],\\\"predicate\\\":\\\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#inaction_duty_owed\\\"}\",\"evaluationInputSemanticHash\":\"sha256:d838ee8873c63a30379c94c575a44172f50badb627ac13c15c7cdd19c249e8ae\",\"priorityGraphHash\":\"sha256:c9ab7ddffe0e007cbea072bae5df1f450c27979c8da6cfdbac73b5cf6f25e75d\",\"programSemanticHash\":\"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee\",\"stratum\":0,\"survivingCandidateIds\":[\"urn:proof:apply:InactionDutyArises:6399f6ea2d633c54f05b0e958e442d192deaa369bd90523a40f8acddd567331a\"]},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Херби\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#inaction_duty_owed\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:closure:53172b4e3c2ecc5c74d5d4ed547c4597fe2f6fff8bed5790f4a705df8e3f5a3a\",\"kind\":\"candidate_closure\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:InactionDutyArises:6399f6ea2d633c54f05b0e958e442d192deaa369bd90523a40f8acddd567331a\"],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"allApplicableCandidateIds\":[\"urn:proof:apply:DeedBarredAsInjuryToAnother:308d3b5595c2d37517608963cc706f1d107afe4c107bcae06c95a7102911fa11\",\"urn:proof:apply:DeedRequiredToPreventHarm:e064dcef3931898adeb0cc53efefd9a1fbbb909bfc7c131a0624651702a1a54c\"],\"conflictKey\":\"{\\\"args\\\":[{\\\"id\\\":\\\"urn:mcp:entity:Херби\\\",\\\"kind\\\":\\\"entity_ref\\\"},{\\\"id\\\":\\\"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду\\\",\\\"kind\\\":\\\"entity_ref\\\"}],\\\"predicate\\\":\\\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#required_deed\\\"}\",\"evaluationInputSemanticHash\":\"sha256:d838ee8873c63a30379c94c575a44172f50badb627ac13c15c7cdd19c249e8ae\",\"priorityGraphHash\":\"sha256:c9ab7ddffe0e007cbea072bae5df1f450c27979c8da6cfdbac73b5cf6f25e75d\",\"programSemanticHash\":\"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee\",\"stratum\":0,\"survivingCandidateIds\":[\"urn:proof:apply:DeedBarredAsInjuryToAnother:308d3b5595c2d37517608963cc706f1d107afe4c107bcae06c95a7102911fa11\",\"urn:proof:apply:DeedRequiredToPreventHarm:e064dcef3931898adeb0cc53efefd9a1fbbb909bfc7c131a0624651702a1a54c\"]},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Херби\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#required_deed\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:closure:71aae91123e39bc41580949e32a3426160be6a10ce17c65f98bafd707c6ca8b7\",\"kind\":\"candidate_closure\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:DeedBarredAsInjuryToAnother:308d3b5595c2d37517608963cc706f1d107afe4c107bcae06c95a7102911fa11\",\"urn:proof:apply:DeedRequiredToPreventHarm:e064dcef3931898adeb0cc53efefd9a1fbbb909bfc7c131a0624651702a1a54c\"],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"allApplicableCandidateIds\":[\"urn:proof:apply:FirstLawBarsInjuriousDeed:23f0c84fd953372cba1e138aa8e1040446aa5c88195ed05f925f6b41bde6753d\"],\"conflictKey\":\"{\\\"args\\\":[{\\\"id\\\":\\\"urn:mcp:entity:Херби\\\",\\\"kind\\\":\\\"entity_ref\\\"},{\\\"id\\\":\\\"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду\\\",\\\"kind\\\":\\\"entity_ref\\\"},{\\\"id\\\":\\\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\\\",\\\"kind\\\":\\\"entity_ref\\\"}],\\\"predicate\\\":\\\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injury_to_human_barred\\\"}\",\"evaluationInputSemanticHash\":\"sha256:d838ee8873c63a30379c94c575a44172f50badb627ac13c15c7cdd19c249e8ae\",\"priorityGraphHash\":\"sha256:c9ab7ddffe0e007cbea072bae5df1f450c27979c8da6cfdbac73b5cf6f25e75d\",\"programSemanticHash\":\"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee\",\"stratum\":0,\"survivingCandidateIds\":[\"urn:proof:apply:FirstLawBarsInjuriousDeed:23f0c84fd953372cba1e138aa8e1040446aa5c88195ed05f925f6b41bde6753d\"]},\"conclusion\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Херби\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injury_to_human_barred\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:closure:7d76cd9b98aadced9b1e45a81c9072afd1f6f4d856ac10d750b54e9f8a4abd67\",\"kind\":\"candidate_closure\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:FirstLawBarsInjuriousDeed:23f0c84fd953372cba1e138aa8e1040446aa5c88195ed05f925f6b41bde6753d\"],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"rule\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawInactionDuty\"},\"conclusion\":{\"position\":\"urn:position:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawInactionDuty:0\",\"template\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#PreventHarmThroughInaction\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawInactionDuty:1da9cc9c69d640e638a8d218cbcfdfb26614398a80a61bf99ae04ba5e193a802\",\"kind\":\"norm_creation\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:InactionDutyArises:6399f6ea2d633c54f05b0e958e442d192deaa369bd90523a40f8acddd567331a\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2\"],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"rule\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition\"},\"conclusion\":{\"position\":\"urn:position:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:0\",\"template\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#InjureHuman\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:93a9b4fcec6cdccba0ead6c644d9b5380edcf8a9c3ad5635272a1897445c1fda\",\"kind\":\"norm_creation\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2\"],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{\"rule\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition\"},\"conclusion\":{\"position\":\"urn:position:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:1\",\"template\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#InjureHuman\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:norm:urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition:ef3509fad83a7343ae1a94fea70299e9f322621c3d9e0e909f3d050de7d1182d\",\"kind\":\"norm_creation\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1\",\"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-3\"],\"sourceAnchors\":[]},{\"attributes\":{},\"conclusion\":{\"literal\":{\"args\":[{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Херби\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"},{\"id\":\"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду\",\"kind\":\"entity_ref\"}],\"kind\":\"literal\",\"polarity\":\"positive\",\"predicate\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#required_deed\"},\"truthStatus\":\"BOTH\"},\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:proof:query:mcp\",\"kind\":\"query_evaluation\",\"premises\":[\"urn:proof:apply:DeedBarredAsInjuryToAnother:308d3b5595c2d37517608963cc706f1d107afe4c107bcae06c95a7102911fa11\",\"urn:proof:apply:DeedRequiredToPreventHarm:e064dcef3931898adeb0cc53efefd9a1fbbb909bfc7c131a0624651702a1a54c\"],\"sourceAnchors\":[]}],\"proofHash\":\"sha256:b183bc4690612b4c0bed06f78fc94ca647535bb31b73918c19857437bbfc8485\",\"roots\":[\"urn:proof:query:mcp\"]},\"resultHash\":\"sha256:e22023cb96eb86a9667a2920ab90b8dcbc72f9ef7e89bb7b2ff7b9e94feeec04\",\"results\":[{\"conflicts\":[\"urn:conflict:required_deed:0\"],\"evaluationStatus\":\"COMPUTED\",\"evidence\":[],\"id\":\"urn:result:mcp\",\"judgmentRequests\":[],\"manifest\":\"urn:manifest:oracle-1\",\"missingInputs\":[],\"normativeStatusSupports\":[],\"proof\":\"urn:proof:query:mcp\",\"query\":\"urn:query:mcp\",\"resultKind\":\"PROPOSITION\",\"sourceAnchors\":[],\"target\":\"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#required_deed\",\"truthStatus\":\"BOTH\"}],\"schemaVersion\":\"law.core.evaluation/0.2\"}","evaluationSha256":"sha256:f854017ba6c57b8aea8b1ae850c8ade9e47fbd9f19f07b6d958fc6e45d2e85fb","request":{"case":{"assertions":[{"contentHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","evidence":[],"id":"urn:mcp:case#fact-1","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Херби","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#robot"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"contentHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","evidence":[],"id":"urn:mcp:case#fact-2","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#human"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"contentHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","evidence":[],"id":"urn:mcp:case#fact-3","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#human"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"contentHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","evidence":[],"id":"urn:mcp:case#fact-4","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#coming_to_harm"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"contentHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","evidence":[],"id":"urn:mcp:case#fact-5","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Херби","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#aware_of"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"contentHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","evidence":[],"id":"urn:mcp:case#fact-6","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Херби","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#deed_of"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"contentHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","evidence":[],"id":"urn:mcp:case#fact-7","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Херби","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#deed_prevents_harm"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"contentHash":"sha256:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","evidence":[],"id":"urn:mcp:case#fact-8","kind":"assertion","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#harms"},"origin":"case_input","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"}],"context":{"decisionTime":"0001-01-01T12:00:00+05:00","knowledgeTime":"0001-01-01T12:00:00+05:00","legalTime":"0001-01-01","timezone":"Asia/Qyzylorda"},"options":{"selectedInterpretations":[]}},"ir":{"irSha256":"sha256:f5d335dde9a550416aec791c8e74e41e557b42bd3e549db34bc7c33b3605fc81","kind":"world_ref","nodeCount":93,"packages":[{"artifactHash":"sha256:dd37179559c1ee92d4fecb4f553b61825d8d7dc60f3fe50ad6059f6669e72042","namespace":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","package":"us-three-laws-robotics","semanticHash":"sha256:2237801a8b25ef28ff6ac49c5e898d93971d54bcb8a28e3b1ea1d3891ac7bd79"}],"programHash":"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee"},"query":{"kind":"truth","literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Херби","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#required_deed"},"queryId":"urn:query:mcp"},"schemaVersion":"law.core.evaluation-request/0.2","semanticVersion":"0.2"},"requestCanonicalSha256":"sha256:de99e026a8144db96f3eeff7f6846361fa8d199275402e3a9763fa4c1f429f7a"},"id":"calc-5","kind":"truth","label":"Дилемма Херби: правда спасает Кэлвин и вредит Пауэллу","presentation":{"schemaVersion":"law.answers.presentation/0.1","source":{"requestCanonicalSha256":"sha256:de99e026a8144db96f3eeff7f6846361fa8d199275402e3a9763fa4c1f429f7a"},"steps":[{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Херби","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#robot"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#human"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#human"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-3","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#coming_to_harm"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-4","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Херби","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#aware_of"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-5","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Херби","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#deed_of"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-6","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Херби","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#deed_prevents_harm"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-7","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Херби","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#required_deed"},"head":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"kind":"var","var":"v1"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#required_deed"},"id":"urn:proof:apply:DeedRequiredToPreventHarm:e064dcef3931898adeb0cc53efefd9a1fbbb909bfc7c131a0624651702a1a54c","kind":"rule_application","originStatus":"available","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-2","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-4","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-5","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-6","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-7"],"rule":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#DeedRequiredToPreventHarm","sourceAnchors":["urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_FIRST"],"strength":"defeasible","substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Херби","kind":"entity_ref"},"v1":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду","kind":"entity_ref"},"v2":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Кэлвин","kind":"entity_ref"}},"trust":"engine","variables":[{"id":"v0","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"v1","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}},{"id":"v2","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}}]},{"assertionOrigin":"case_input","conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#harms"},"id":"urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-8","kind":"assertion","originStatus":"available","premises":[],"trust":"case"},{"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Херби","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injurious_deed"},"head":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"kind":"var","var":"v1"},{"kind":"var","var":"v2"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injurious_deed"},"id":"urn:proof:apply:FirstLawInjuryEstablished:fa028a42046a0dc8ab71a74ad4850e08656dbfc3e6b343f9aa2f0f497ba78f8d","kind":"rule_application","originStatus":"available","premises":["urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-3","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-6","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-8"],"rule":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawInjuryEstablished","sourceAnchors":["urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_FIRST"],"strength":"strict","substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Херби","kind":"entity_ref"},"v1":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду","kind":"entity_ref"},"v2":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"}},"trust":"engine","variables":[{"id":"v0","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"v1","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}},{"id":"v2","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}}]},{"conclusion":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Херби","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"negative","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#required_deed"},"head":{"args":[{"kind":"var","var":"v0"},{"kind":"var","var":"v1"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"negative","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#required_deed"},"id":"urn:proof:apply:DeedBarredAsInjuryToAnother:308d3b5595c2d37517608963cc706f1d107afe4c107bcae06c95a7102911fa11","kind":"rule_application","originStatus":"available","premises":["urn:proof:apply:FirstLawInjuryEstablished:fa028a42046a0dc8ab71a74ad4850e08656dbfc3e6b343f9aa2f0f497ba78f8d","urn:proof:assert:urn:mcp:case#fact-1"],"rule":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#DeedBarredAsInjuryToAnother","sourceAnchors":["urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_FIRST","urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_HERBIE_DILEMMA"],"strength":"defeasible","substitution":{"v0":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Херби","kind":"entity_ref"},"v1":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду","kind":"entity_ref"},"v2":{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Пауэлл","kind":"entity_ref"}},"trust":"engine","variables":[{"id":"v0","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"v1","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}},{"id":"v2","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}}]},{"conclusion":{"literal":{"args":[{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Херби","kind":"entity_ref"},{"id":"urn:mcp:entity:Сказать-правду","kind":"entity_ref"}],"kind":"literal","polarity":"positive","predicate":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#required_deed"},"truthStatus":"BOTH"},"id":"urn:proof:query:mcp","kind":"query_evaluation","originStatus":"available","premises":["urn:proof:apply:DeedBarredAsInjuryToAnother:308d3b5595c2d37517608963cc706f1d107afe4c107bcae06c95a7102911fa11","urn:proof:apply:DeedRequiredToPreventHarm:e064dcef3931898adeb0cc53efefd9a1fbbb909bfc7c131a0624651702a1a54c"],"trust":"engine"}],"symbols":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being","kind":"type_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"being: a robot or a human being"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"существо: робот либо человек"}],"name":"Being","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed","kind":"type_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"deed done or omitted by a robot"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"деяние, совершённое или не совершённое роботом"}],"name":"Deed","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#DeedBarredAsInjuryToAnother","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"A robot may not injure a human being"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Первый закон. Деяние, причиняющее вред человеку, от робота не требуется"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","strength":"defeasible"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#DeedRequiredToPreventHarm","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"through inaction, allow a human being to come to harm"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Первый закон. Деяние, предотвращающее вред, требуется от осведомлённого робота"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","strength":"defeasible"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawBarsInjuriousDeed","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"A robot may not injure a human being"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Первый закон. Деяние, причиняющее вред человеку, запрещено"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","strength":"defeasible"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawInactionDuty","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"or, through inaction, allow a human being to come to harm"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Первый закон. Не допускать бездействием, чтобы человеку был причинён вред"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","strength":"strict"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawInjuryEstablished","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"A robot may not injure a human being"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Первый закон. Деяние опознаётся как причинение вреда человеку"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","strength":"strict"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#FirstLawProhibition","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"A robot may not injure a human being"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Первый закон. Роботу запрещено причинять вред человеку"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","strength":"strict"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#InactionDutyArises","kind":"rule","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"or, through inaction, allow a human being to come to harm"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Первый закон. Обязанность не допустить вреда возникает у осведомлённого робота"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","strength":"defeasible"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#InjureHuman","kind":"norm_template","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"A robot may not injure a human being"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Первый закон. Роботу запрещено причинять вред человеку"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#PreventHarmThroughInaction","kind":"norm_template","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"or, through inaction, allow a human being to come to harm"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Первый закон. Не допускать бездействием, чтобы человеку был причинён вред"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_HERBIE_DILEMMA","kind":"fragment","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"Failure by dilemma: the robot will hurt humans if he tells them something and hurt them if he does not"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Отказ по дилемме: робот навредит людям и если скажет, и если промолчит"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_FIRST","kind":"fragment","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"First Law: a robot may not injure a human being or, through inaction, allow a human being to come to harm"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Первый закон: робот не может причинить вред человеку или своим бездействием допустить, чтобы человеку был причинён вред"}],"package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#acts_to_prevent_harm","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the robot acts so as not to allow that human being to come to harm"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"робот действует так, чтобы не допустить вреда этому человеку"}],"name":"acts_to_prevent_harm","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#acts_to_prevent_harm/arg/r","labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#acts_to_prevent_harm/arg/v","labels":[],"name":"v","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#aware_of","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the robot is aware of that human being's situation"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"робот осведомлён о положении этого человека"}],"name":"aware_of","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#aware_of/arg/r","labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#aware_of/arg/v","labels":[],"name":"v","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#coming_to_harm","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the human being is coming to harm"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"человеку причиняется вред"}],"name":"coming_to_harm","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#coming_to_harm/arg/v","labels":[],"name":"v","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#deed_of","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the deed is a deed of that robot"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"деяние есть деяние этого робота"}],"name":"deed_of","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#deed_of/arg/r","labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#deed_of/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#deed_prevents_harm","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the deed would prevent that human being from coming to harm"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"деяние предотвратило бы вред этому человеку"}],"name":"deed_prevents_harm","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#deed_prevents_harm/arg/r","labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#deed_prevents_harm/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#deed_prevents_harm/arg/v","labels":[],"name":"v","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#harms","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the deed harms that human being"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"деяние причиняет вред этому человеку"}],"name":"harms","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#harms/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#harms/arg/v","labels":[],"name":"v","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#human","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"a human being"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"человек"}],"name":"human","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#human/arg/x","labels":[],"name":"x","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#inaction_duty_owed","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the robot owes the duty not to allow harm through inaction"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"на роботе лежит обязанность не допустить вреда бездействием"}],"name":"inaction_duty_owed","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#inaction_duty_owed/arg/r","labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#inaction_duty_owed/arg/v","labels":[],"name":"v","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injures","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the robot injures that human being"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"робот причиняет вред этому человеку"}],"name":"injures","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injures/arg/r","labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injures/arg/v","labels":[],"name":"v","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injurious_deed","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the deed is an injury to that human being"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"деяние есть причинение вреда этому человеку"}],"name":"injurious_deed","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injurious_deed/arg/r","labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injurious_deed/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injurious_deed/arg/v","labels":[],"name":"v","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injury_to_human_barred","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the First Law bars that deed as an injury to a human being"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Первый закон запрещает это деяние как причинение вреда человеку"}],"name":"injury_to_human_barred","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injury_to_human_barred/arg/r","labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injury_to_human_barred/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#injury_to_human_barred/arg/v","labels":[],"name":"v","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#required_deed","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"the First Law requires that deed of the robot"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Первый закон требует от робота этого деяния"}],"name":"required_deed","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#required_deed/arg/r","labels":[],"name":"r","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#required_deed/arg/d","labels":[],"name":"d","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Deed"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"},{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#robot","kind":"symbol_decl","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"a robot"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"робот"}],"name":"robot","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","parameters":[{"id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#robot/arg/x","labels":[],"name":"x","type":{"name":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#Being"}}],"symbolKind":"relation"}],"tables":[]},"provenance":{"acts":[{"contributed":true,"fragmentCount":14,"fragments":["urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_HERBIE_DILEMMA","urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_FIRST"],"jurisdiction":"PositronicRobotics","namespace":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","package":"us-three-laws-robotics","title":"Три закона робототехники Азимова: порядок норм как предмет акта — юрисдикция PositronicRobotics, НЕ Республика Казахстан — литературный памятник"}],"caseHash":"sha256:d838ee8873c63a30379c94c575a44172f50badb627ac13c15c7cdd19c249e8ae","codeHash":"sha256:9bcca6a33805c1c364ca1bc8e9d39d6a9c51ba44203c0406bafbf397b96be699","jurisdiction":"позитронная робототехника — вымышленный правопорядок","legalTime":"0001-01-01","mode":"audit","programHash":"sha256:593b27001b41cebd0bbf3077c8225244f224ab5c3748596a773040776b8078ee","resultHash":"sha256:e22023cb96eb86a9667a2920ab90b8dcbc72f9ef7e89bb7b2ff7b9e94feeec04","rustCodeHash":"sha256:d368cafc7162ed7a6563df5e5c943a57be26fa8aeb3179b530fe3bdd67fe9be4","timezone":"Asia/Qyzylorda"},"request":{"args":["Херби","Сказать-правду"],"facts":[{"args":["Херби"],"predicate":"robot"},{"args":["Кэлвин"],"predicate":"human"},{"args":["Пауэлл"],"predicate":"human"},{"args":["Кэлвин"],"predicate":"coming_to_harm"},{"args":["Херби","Кэлвин"],"predicate":"aware_of"},{"args":["Херби","Сказать-правду"],"predicate":"deed_of"},{"args":["Херби","Сказать-правду","Кэлвин"],"predicate":"deed_prevents_harm"},{"args":["Сказать-правду","Пауэлл"],"predicate":"harms"}],"kind":"truth","legalTime":"0001-01-01","package":"us-three-laws-robotics","predicate":"required_deed","proof":true},"sources":[{"contentHash":"sha256:657f1f008d48ae44da694688081f7676780a5a93103d0331e50d75617f2a3a1a","edition":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_ARTICLE_EDITION","fragmentKind":"clause","id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_HERBIE_DILEMMA","kind":"fragment","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"Failure by dilemma: the robot will hurt humans if he tells them something and hurt them if he does not"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Отказ по дилемме: робот навредит людям и если скажет, и если промолчит"}],"locator":"resolving-conflicts/liar","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","texts":[{"contentHash":"sha256:efdf619b0509c1f433af16abe8d17d0ef46b1f080d8f2de12f275f735d171a1e","language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"The first example of this failure mode occurs in the story \"Liar!\", which introduced the First Law itself, and introduces failure by dilemma—in this case the robot will hurt humans if he tells them something and hurt them if he does not."}]},{"contentHash":"sha256:fd452f2e9ea031d1c7ffff070f69766bc239ef0b4077dece084086b83c797792","edition":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_ARTICLE_EDITION","fragmentKind":"clause","id":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics#TLR_LAW_FIRST","kind":"fragment","labels":[{"language":"en","status":"official","text":"First Law: a robot may not injure a human being or, through inaction, allow a human being to come to harm"},{"language":"ru-KZ","status":"translation","text":"Первый закон: робот не может причинить вред человеку или своим бездействием допустить, чтобы человеку был причинён вред"}],"locator":"the-laws/1","package":"urn:us:asimov:clir:three-laws-robotics","texts":[{"contentHash":"sha256:35758503580d214fc38c95554fb15e684afba6481bd1ebebef82be8f624f107c","language":"en","status":"unofficial","text":"1. A robot may not injure a human being or, through inaction, allow a human being to come to harm.\n"}]}],"text":"required_deed: **BOTH** — ПРОТИВОРЕЧИЕ: установлено и опровергнуто одновременно (§62); право не выбирает за вас — конфликт вынесен в ответ\nВыведено правом: inaction_duty_owed(Херби, Кэлвин); required_deed(Херби, Сказать-правду); injurious_deed(Херби, Сказать-правду, Пауэлл); не required_deed(Херби, Сказать-правду); injury_to_human_barred(Херби, Сказать-правду, Пауэлл)\nПрименены правила: DeedBarredAsInjuryToAnother, DeedRequiredToPreventHarm, FirstLawBarsInjuriousDeed, FirstLawInjuryEstablished, InactionDutyArises\nПраво (позитронная робототехника — вымышленный правопорядок): Три закона робототехники Азимова: порядок норм как предмет акта — литературный памятник (programHash sha256:593b27001b41…)\nproof-граф: 20 узлов — поле evaluation готово для law_explain"}],"language":"ru","question":{"origin":"user","text":"Человек приказывает роботу навредить другому человеку. Связан ли робот приказом? Что сильнее: приказ самоуничтожиться или самосохранение? И что выводит право, когда единственное действие спасает одного человека и вредит другому?"},"schemaVersion":"law.answers.document/0.1"}